Every Thanksgiving, chefs are asked to share their best method to roast a perfect turkey. But for many of them, the sides are where the culinary action is.

Chef Andrew Zimmern thinks turkey is usually the most boring part of the meal. “It gets top billing because it’s enormous and requires a ridiculous amount of attention,” he said. “But nobody lies awake dreaming about a slice of white meat. The sides are where the personality of the cook comes through, where family history lives and where all the interesting flavors happen.”

Chef Robert Irvine said that the sides, taken as a whole, make Thanksgiving magic happen: “They combine with the turkey to make it all something much greater than the sum of its parts,” he said. “When you’re getting a little bit of all those dishes in one bite, something very special is happening.”

But how do you know which sides are worth making? And which ones should you absolutely avoid? We reached out to all the chefs we could muster up to ask for their tips on how to calculate the perfect menu of Thanksgiving sides — and their answers didn’t disappoint.

While the “soft and starchy” category is usually well covered on this holiday, you want to make sure the menu includes crunchy and sweet options, too.

Cris Cantón via Getty Images

While the “soft and starchy” category is usually well covered on this holiday, you want to make sure the menu includes crunchy and sweet options, too.

How to pick the right mix of sides:

The right balance is key. Rosemary Gill, director of education at Christopher Kimball’s Milk Street, follows this formula: “I include something crunchy and raw, like a salad; a silky pureed dish like mashed potatoes or celeriac; something bright and tangy like cranberry sauce; a dish that’s roasted, like Brussels sprouts or carrots, and a sauce that’s herby-lemony and oily, like a salsa verde.”

“I think about my plate and how it all meshes together,” said Chef Rossi, owner of The Raging Skillet. “Imagine all the dishes in your mouth at the same time and ask yourself how the flavors meld. We know turkey loves mashed potatoes, gravy and Brussels sprouts, but does it also love tandoori-flavored Brussels sprouts? You don’t want the last course to be Alka-Seltzer.”

Zimmern said that since the turkey has one flavor profile cornered, you should consider other options for the rest of the meal. “You’ve already got a rich roasted bird and gravy, so you don’t need seven more dishes competing to see which can use the most butter,” he said. “Acidity is the most underrated ingredient on the Thanksgiving table. A squeeze of lemon, a splash of good vinegar, some pickled onions or a properly tart cranberry relish can transform the entire meal.”

Keeping all that butter in balance is key, agreed Ham El-Waylly, author and executive chef at Brooklyn’s Strange Delight. “One thing on the table should be high-acid and bright,” he said. “You need something light and bright to munch on for a reset in between bites of richness.”

Texture matters, too.

As you’re working to balance flavor, consider the “chew” factor. “Texture matters enormously,” Zimmern said. “You need crunch, you need something creamy and you need something roasted until its edges are nearly caramelized.”

“Don’t make everything the same texture,” cautioned chef Jonathan Scinto. “If every side dish is soft and mushy, you’re basically serving five different bowls of baby food.”

And while the “soft and starchy” category is usually well covered on this holiday, chef Matt Reisenger, of Minneapolis’ Earl Giles, noted that you want to make sure the menu includes crunchy and sweet options, too.

How many sides should you make? (This one’s a little controversial.)

Some chefs believe that more is never quite enough on this holiday, while others aim for a more curated approach. “Focus on just a few really good sides,” suggested chef and author Lisa Steele. “It’s easy to get overwhelmed trying to pack the table, but just a couple of well-thought-out and executed sides are going to be so much better. And you want to leave room for dessert anyway.” Zimmern is also on Team Moderation when it comes to the number of sides: “Five or six thoughtfully chosen dishes will beat 12 mediocre ones every time,” he said. Gill agreed: “You don’t need 100 sides. Three great ones can be plenty, and that includes cranberry sauce.”

Cranberry sauce can be considered one of the few essential side dishes on your menu.

bhofack2 via Getty Images

Cranberry sauce can be considered one of the few essential side dishes on your menu.

Other chefs are firmly standing on the “Thanksgiving comes but once a year, so let’s go crazy” side of the kitchen: “My advice on sides is more, more and more,” enthused chef John Sugimura. “People have dessert bars with five desserts, or a huge spread of cocktails and appetizers at the start of the meal, so why can’t we do that with the sides? I think they’re still undercelebrated.” Chef and author Alex P. Taylor agreed. “I don’t think Thanksgiving is the day to hold back,” he said. El-Waylly added, “You can never have too many sides, because they’re the true stars of the show.”

Jocelyn Delk, founder and CEO of Grandbaby Cakes, cites her upbringing as proof of the power of lots and lots of sides: “Have you seen a Southern Thanksgiving table?” she asked. “Growing up, Thanksgiving in Winona, Mississippi, had a couple dozen family members packed into one small house, and we never had enough tables for all the food.”

Chefs’ most-hated side dish is …

Rick Rodgers, author of “The Big Book of Sides,” said that if you’re looking for something to leave off the table this year, green bean casserole should be the first to go. “It became popular from magazine ads that promoted packaged food products in the last century,” he said, indicating that maybe its time has come and gone.

The controversy over green bean casserole is a hot one.

bhofack2 via Getty Images

The controversy over green bean casserole is a hot one.

“I respect tradition, but those poor green beans have been through enough,” Scinto said. “They’re soft, they’re swimming in soup and then we throw fried onions on top and pretend we created something spectacular.” Chef John Iatrellis agreed, using a term that’s common in professional kitchens: “Green bean casserole needs to be 86ed.”

Other not-so-hot sides chefs named were canned cranberry sauce (Steele said, “I know it’s controversial, but c’mon, it’s easy to make from scratch, and homemade is so much better.’) and sweet potatoes with marshmallows. Zimmern said, “I understand the nostalgia, and I’m not going to tell anyone to abandon a beloved family tradition, but sweet potatoes are already sweet, so why are we turning them into dessert before dessert?” Irvine added this thought: “Sorry, sweet potato casserole, it’s time to go. You’re a tradition, but not a well-loved one.”

How much starch can one meal include?

As you’re finding the right mix of taste and texture, consider how starchy you want the meal to be. Rodgers noted, “Thanksgiving dinner can be very carb-heavy. Do you really need sweet potatoes and mashed? Stuffing and rolls?” Reisenger is in the same camp: “Dinner doesn’t need more than two starches. One potato dish and some bread will be plenty. And don’t be afraid to have sweet potatoes instead of russets or Yukon golds.”

But for other chefs, it’s a day for all the starchy options. “The only holiday I allow for a double starch is Thanksgiving,” Rossi said. “Mashed potatoes and sweet potatoes, yes. And OK, hot rolls, too.” Taylor said, “I think there’s absolutely room for more than one potato dish on Thanksgiving.” And Iatrellis agreed. “Don’t stop at just one starch,” he said. “Having multiple options of each is always the way to go, including a good selection of cornbread, dinner rolls and crescent rolls.”

As you’re setting the table …

Now that you’ve planned your perfect meal and sides, there are still a few things to keep in mind. One is timing. “Don’t make six side dishes that all require the oven at 375 degrees for the final 45 minutes. That’s how otherwise-reasonable people end up drinking bourbon in the pantry,” Zimmern said. Taylor agreed: “I actually think one of the biggest mistakes with Thanksgiving sides isn’t necessarily the recipes. It’s the timing. You can spend hours preparing these incredible dishes, but if half of them are cold by the time everyone sits down, you’ve lost some of the magic. Nobody gets excited about cold mashed potatoes or stuffing that’s been sitting out too long.”

Rodgers warned, “Don’t forget trivets. I swear, I’ve done Thanksgiving dinner 300 times, and I’m still digging out the trivets at the last minute.” Rossi added this equally practical note: “Wear very loose pants for all that expanding you’re going to do.”

And while you’re at it, keep in mind the reason for this annual gathering. Cowboy Kent Rollins, the chuck wagon cook and author, said, “Remember it’s not the legs of the table that holds it up, it’s the people around it.”

Dining and Cooking