Key Takeaways

All four chefs unanimously recommend Amy’s Kitchen as the best canned soup brand for its simple, organic ingredients and flavors that taste genuinely homemade—not overly salty or processed.

When choosing canned soup, chefs prioritize lower sodium, short ingredient lists with recognizable foods (like vegetables, beans, and stock), and a good balance of protein and fiber for a more filling meal.

High-quality canned soups should have real texture and broth—not paste-like thickness from fillers—and can easily be upgraded with added veggies, grains, or proteins to make dinner feel more complete.

Cozy winter nights and a general lack of motivation after the busy holiday season could mean canned soup is doing a lot of heavy lifting right now. And that’s OK! Canned soup is quick, comforting, and easy for nights when cooking from scratch just isn’t going to happen. But with dozens of brands and types of soup, it can be hard to tell which ones are worth grabbing and which should stay out of your rotation.

To make soup season easier to navigate, we asked professional chefs what they actually look for when buying canned soup, and which store-bought options they genuinely eat and recommend. Spoiler: After comparing notes, all four chefs pointed to the same brand. Here’s why they say it consistently delivers.

Meet the Experts

Shawna Clark, chef, recipe creator, and founder of Healthy Foodie Girl

Dennis Littley, chef, recipe developer, and founder of Ask Chef Dennis

Kyle Taylor, chef, recipe developer, and founder of He Cooks

What to Look for When Buying Canned Soup

It’s simple enough to say to “check the label” when buying any canned food, but what does that even mean? Here’s how a chef assesses soup cans to find the best quality.

Check Sodium Content

Sodium level is often the first clue as to whether a canned soup is high quality or relying on shortcuts. “The first thing I look at when buying a canned soup is the sodium content,” says chef Dennis Littley of Ask Chef Dennis. “Many people confuse salt with flavor, and while it can boost natural flavors, those flavors need to be there to begin with.”

Across the board, each chef we spoke to told us sodium was the most important thing they check. “Salt is often used as a crutch to mask the taste of low-quality or over-processed ingredients,” says chef Kyle Taylor of He Cooks. “If a single serving has over 800 milligrams of sodium, don’t touch it. You can always add salt to it.”

Evaluate the Ingredients

Now glance at the ingredient list with a critical eye. “Read the label like a good chef would, with intention,” says Taylor. “If the first three ingredients are not vegetables, stock, or water, put it back.” Ingredients like modified starches, sugar, or vague flavor enhancers at the top of the list are usually a bad sign.

Littley agrees that recognizable ingredients are usually a reliable indicator of quality. “That means looking for other real ingredients that you recognize: Grains, beans, stock, and meat,” Littley adds. “Real ingredients = real flavor.”

Look for Protein and Fiber

Beyond scanning the ingredient list for recognizable foods, chef Marissa Stevens of Pinch and Swirl likes to pay attention to the broader nutritional profile. “I like looking for the best fit for the diet people prefer, whether that’s a good amount of protein, fiber, or other detail,” she says. Canned soups with high protein and fiber tend to be more filling and balanced than other options that are sodium or starch heavy.

Tips

To make any can of soup a heartier option for dinner, Littley has some fun adding in leftover vegetables, rice, grains, and meats to help build out a canned soup. “I keep a bag or two of frozen mixed vegetables on hand and a few jars of bullion soup bases in case I need to stretch the can to feed more people,” he says. Adding veggies will help boost a soup’s protein and fiber content, too.

Shake the Can

Another surprising suggestion to know if a soup will taste good: Shake the can. “You want to hear liquid moving. That means you are paying for substantial ingredients rather than cheap fillers,” says Taylor. While this doesn’t mean that the soup should be too watery, even thicker canned soups, like chowders or lentil soups, should still have a noticeable broth component. A paste-like consistency can indicate a heavier use of thickeners, like corn starch.

The Best Brand of Canned Soup, According to Chefs

When we asked for the best canned soup brand at the grocery store, each chef was quick to name Amy’s Kitchen due to its commitment to quality. “Amy’s Kitchen is my go-to because the ingredients are simple and organic, and the flavors taste genuinely homemade, not overly salty or processed,” says chef Shawna Clark of Healthy Foodie Girl.

The brand is one of the few that packs their soups with real texture, not just broth and filler. “Typically I cook soups from scratch, but Amy’s Kitchen is the one canned soup brand I keep in my pantry for quick, not-sad meals,” says Stevens. “The ingredient lists are short and I can pronounce them, the flavors are balanced, and the vegetables and beans actually have some texture.”

In fact, chefs think that other soup brands should take notes when it comes to flavor. “Amy’s Kitchen is the standard I measure other store bought soups against,” says Taylor. “Most canned soups have that metallic, overcooked ‘can flavor’ that you can never quite simmer out. Amy’s is the only one I have found that actually tastes like the ingredients inside.”

For Littley, the heartiness and healthfulness of soups from Amy’s Kitchen is what makes the brand stand out. “I have two go-to brands of soup that you’ll always find a few cans of in my pantry,” he shares. “When I’m looking for a hearty soup with chunks of meat and veggies, I reach for Progresso or Amy’s Kitchen. I grew up on Progresso, but more and more, I’m finding myself reaching for Amy’s soups. My grandchildren love it, and I feel better eating and serving them.”

Credit: Amy's Kitchen

There are several popular Amy’s Kitchen soup flavors, and the chefs couldn’t agree on just one. Clark loves Amy’s Organic Chunky Tomato Bisque Soup. “It’s rich and comforting with great tomato flavor, and it works just as well on its own as it does paired with a grilled cheese,” she shares.

Stevens listed off a few go-to’s: French Country Vegetable is cozy and brothy without being bland; Black Bean Vegetable is hearty, well-seasoned, and tastes almost homemade; Tortilla Soup has just the right amount of spice; and Thai Curry & Sweet Potato Soup is her favorite of the four with a mellow heat and creamy texture that makes it feel more like a meal.

Add Real Simple as a preferred source on Google to see more of our stories on Google news and search results.

Read the original article on Real Simple

Dining and Cooking