The #1 Pizza Order in America, According to Pizzeria Regulars

Pizzeria regulars share their ultimate favorite pizza order across top chains.

Anyone who orders pizza regularly knows exactly what their favorite pizza is, and which pizza restaurant is the best. I’m one of those outliers who loves getting anchovies on pizza, but rarely orders it because it causes such an uproar with the rest of the household (is this what fans of Hawaiian pizza deal with too?). When it comes to the popular nationwide chains, customers make it very clear what their favorite crusts and toppings are at each restaurant through online chatter and rave reviews. If you’re curious what other pizza-lovers are ordering, here is the #1 favorite pizza order according to regulars.

Domino’s—Pepperoni

” src=”https://www.diningandcooking.com/restaurants/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Dominos-Pepperoni.png” alt=”” width=”640″ height=”469″ />Domino’s Pizza

Domino’s Pizza fans really, really love their Pepperoni Pizza, preferably with extra cheese. “Pan pizza with extra cheese and extra pepperoni 🤤,” one Redditor said. “I went through a phase for over a year where I kept ordering a medium pan pizza with half cheese, half pepperoni, and then asking the sweet employees at the dominos to put garlic butter around the edge. It is still amazing,” another commented, adding that they wish it was actually on the menu.

Pizza Hut

” src=”https://www.diningandcooking.com/restaurants/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Pizza-Hut-Pepperoni.png” alt=”” width=”640″ height=”469″ />Pizza Hut6254a4d1642c605c54bf1cab17d50f1e

Pizza Hut diners are also Pepperoni Pizza fanatics, but it MUST be an Original Pan Pizza. “What makes Pizza Hut’s Pan Pizza so freaking good?!?” one fan said, sharing a picture of their pizza. “Personal pepperoni pizza with a side of cinnamon sticks. Sometimes I get this every now and then as my cheat meal,” another commented. Honorable mention goes to the classic ham and cheese!

Papa John’s—Pepperoni

” src=”https://www.diningandcooking.com/restaurants/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Papa-Johns-pepperoni-pizza.png” alt=”” width=”640″ height=”469″ />Papa John’s

Papa John’s diners also love the Pepperoni, also with delicious extra cheese. “I ordered extra sauce, but I am pretty sure it was accidentally made with extra cheese,” one fan shared via Reddit, with a picture of their meal. “It was the best pizza that I have ever eaten, at Papa John’s or anywhere. Temp, cheese, pepperoni, crust, were incredible… I can’t even put it into words how good it was. Perfection. I will probably get extra cheese every time now.”

5 Chain Restaurants With the Best BBQ Chicken Pizza, According to Chefs

Little Caesars

” src=”https://www.diningandcooking.com/restaurants/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Little-Caesars-pepperoni-pizza.png” alt=”” width=”640″ height=”469″ />Little Caesars

Little Caesars fans can’t get enough of… you guessed it, pepperoni! “I’ve had them all but I think the classic pepperoni is LC’s best pizza,” one diner said. “It reminds me of when I was a kid and mom shopping at K-mart. Inside the store there was a little LC section where you could get a slice of pie.” Fans also love the Pretzel Pizza.

Marco’s Pizza

” src=”https://www.diningandcooking.com/restaurants/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Marcos-Pepperoni-Magnifico.png” alt=”” width=”640″ height=”469″ />Marcos Pizza

Marco’s Pizza fans can’t get enough of the “old world” cupped pepperoni on pizzas like the Triple Pepperoni Magnifico. “It’s lovely. Pepperoni Magnifico for me,” one diner said. ” Lite crust, double sauce, old world pepperoni. The best 9 dollar pizza in the game,” another commented.

Pepperoni Is the Nation’s Favorite

” src=”https://www.diningandcooking.com/restaurants/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/shutterstock_91499282.jpg” alt=”” width=”640″ height=”469″ />Shutterstock

It’s no surprise pepperoni gets such high praise—it’s officially the most popular pizza topping in America. According to the PMQ Pizza/Datassential Pizza Power Report 2025, pepperoni was second only to onion. “Hot honey (430%) and pepperoni cups (406%) were other heavily trending toppings, as were internationally-sourced ingredients like cotija cheese (163%) and tandoori (153%),” the publication says.