‘I want to create a restaurant that we are all proud of that fills a niche in the market,’ says co-owner of bistro in former Mexican cantina

French-inspired cuisine is being added to the menu in downtown Orillia.

Picnic, a Mexican cantina, was recently closed to make way for Simcoe Tavern, a new bistro set to open its doors Tuesday.

Simon MacRae and Darcy MacDonell, owners of The Common Stove and The Hog and Penny, have partnered with Melissa Luth and Joel Bennett to create the new restaurant that will offer French-inspired cuisine, wines, cocktails and craft beers.

“I want to create a restaurant that we are all proud of that fills a niche in the market,” said MacDonell.

MacRae said the restaurant will be a “stepping stone” between The Common Stove and The Hog and Penny but with the same “elevated” level of hospitality and coziness. 

“Hospitality is a huge thing for our restaurants in general. It’s always a big highlight. We have wonderful, wonderful people who work for us,” said MacRae.

“If you don’t want your big ribeye at The Common Stove, but you want something that’s more upscale than a burger or fish and chips, you come to the bistro,” he said.

Simcoe Tavern gives the group a new venue to expand menu offerings. Bennett is the chef as well as an owner. 

“Chef started out with a blank sheet of paper and listed a pile of dishes that he really wanted to cook that inspired him and us and it turned out to be a bistro, so it’s Simcoe Tavern,” said MacRae.

The restaurant will serve appetizers, main courses, desserts, wines, cocktails and mocktails, beer and cider.

The opening menu includes beef carpaccio, oysters, croquettes, lobster mac and cheese, beef short rib and an autumn salad, to name a few items.

“Duck confit, I think, will be very popular. The creme brûlée, customers have been asking us to put that on the menu and this seems like the right restaurant for that,” MacRae said. 

The price point of the appetizers are $15 to $20 and main courses are generally $20 to $30.

“There are some wicked cocktails, plenty of spirit-free cocktails, and a fantastic value wine list,” said MacRae.

Beer offerings include Quayle’s of Oro-Medonte, Wood Brothers from eastern Ontario and award-winning Woodfolk cider from Coldwater.

The Emma Caesar is a signature cocktail.

“She’s been working on this for years and has finessed it for this release,” said MacRae.

The quartet of owners are also behind Luca, an Italian restaurant in Barrie, and Simcoe Tavern, while MacRae and MacDonell also own The Common Stove and The Hog and Penny.

Simcoe Tavern, located at 140 Mississaga St. E., will open at 5 p.m. Monday through Thursday and will open at 11 a.m. Friday and Saturday, with both lunch and dinner servings.

Reservations can be made online at simcoetavern.com. 

Dining and Cooking