Over the past two weeks, our Seattle Times food writers have rolled out their ranking of Seattle’s 50 Essential Restaurants — a celebration of Seattle as a city of unique neighborhoods that supports a constellation of excellent neighborhood restaurants.

Mexican gem Pancita in Ravenna took our No. 1 spot as a cozy restaurant with all hits, no misses on the menu.

If you’re wondering why your favorite restaurant missed the list, see this letter from the editor. We also have a story about why we decided to rank our favorite spots to eat.

All that’s left is the debrief.

We know readers have questions about how we made the list. We have fielded dozens from readers since the 50 Essentials rollout started.

Seattle Times food writers Bethany Jean Clement, Tan Vinh and Jackie Varriano answered questions from Times readers in a virtual live panel. Features editor Trevor Lenzmeier moderated.

That’s all from us, folks!

1:57 pm

Can you do a Top 50 ‘outside Seattle’ list?

Our food team knew, at least for this inaugural list, that we had our work cut out for ourselves in Seattle. We made an intentional decision to exclude the Eastside. Here’s what I wrote in another story:

“We did not incorporate the Eastside or Seattle’s suburban cities in this project, to the dismay of at least one Times editor who outranks me.

“While our food team regularly eats around Western Washington — covering everything from the latest openings to Bellevue’s excellent Chinese food scene, all things T&T Supermarket and Neighborhood Eats adventures around the Sound — we didn’t dare open that can of worms.
“The difficulty we had culling to 50 local restaurants is a testament to the strength of the city’s dining scene. Expanding the scope beyond Seattle would be a disservice to nearby cities and to our own food scene.”

— T.L.

1:50 pm

Tell me about why you use online reviews to help select restaurants? I find these reviews unhelpful as the mediocre rise to the top. I’ve been highly disappointed by several of your top 15 places.

While we use online reviews as reference points, they did not inform this ranking and do not impact our reviews in any way. I agree (and know our critics would, too) that digital reviews on Google, Yelp, Beli, etc., are not always accurate reflections of restaurant quality.

— T.L.

1:47 pm

In the spirit of Kenji López-Alt, will you do something like “10 essential teriyaki joints”?

We’ve been doing that kind of stuff for a long time — check out our big series on Seattle Restaurant Classics, celebrating our old-school greats that are well-priced, locally owned, community-centered and timelessly tasty (a special pet project of mine as someone who grew up in Seattle!).

As far as teriyaki goes, here’s my 2019 story entitled “Why we love teriyaki so much (and where to go if you don’t),” along with “4 top Seattle-area spots for the best teriyaki” — including this for No. 4:

“4. Your favorite teriyaki place in whatever neighborhood you might find it”

“I don’t mean this as a cop-out — I know from experience that the teriyaki spot nearest to where you grew up, the one closest to your school, to your work or to your current abode, fills a special hole in your stomach and your life with comforting food and low-key joy. These are the places where they remember you when you come in, the ones that make a city a home. Let us give thanks for them!”

— B.J.C.

Is there an area/neighborhood that had consistently good options?

Hillman City is my favorite. (And still the most underrated ’hood in my opinion.)
— T.V.

Our food team’s favorite neighborhoods, by the numbers: Our critics gravitated toward Capitol Hill (eight restaurants in our 50 Essentials), Ballard (five), Fremont (five), Beacon Hill (four), the Central District (four) and Downtown (four).

I live on Capitol Hill these days so I eat around here often, but I loved my time on Eastlake, bouncing between Serafina, Pazzo’s, Sushi Kappo Tamura, the Zoo and Otherside Market.
— T.L.

1:32 pm

Do you rank restaurants only on food taste? Does price, service, seating and waiting time get factored into your reviews?

I like to eat blindfolded while listening to sludge metal on headphones turned up REALLY loud and occasionally lashing out with whatever cutlery is at hand. Just kidding! Everything matters, including what I can learn about the ethos behind a given place — dare I say the love that’s been put into it?!

— Bethany Jean Clement, food reporter and critic

—QUESTION FROM: Alex Harmatta in Seattle

1:22 pm

Not a single Desi or Desi-influenced restaurant? I can see how three critics and an editor with differing tastes might omit a given individual restaurant, but please tell us how you justify nixing an entire cuisine category that is both popular and fabulously executed in Seattle. Nirmal’s, Meesha, Rupee Bar.

I have enjoyed meals at Nirmal’s, Meesha and Rupee Bar (and the mango gin cocktail there is one of my favorites). They just didn’t make our cut for the Top 50.

— T.V.

1:17 pm

If I’m understanding correctly by reading the other questions/answers, this list came only from favorite restaurants you ate at over the past year, correct? Also, noted you will not share the full list of all the restaurants considered, but can I just ask if Lark was one?

Yes, we talked about Lark. We won’t get into every perceived “snub” — but the overarching point is that there are many more than 50 great restaurants in Seattle, so many restaurants that folks love got cut. Support your favorites regardless of their inclusion on our list! Your personal Top 10 can and should trump our critic picks.

— T.L.

What is your quintessential Seattle restaurant?

Cafe Presse. (Gone but never forgotten.)

— Tan Vinh, food reporter and critic

This is a trick question — our city’s culinary scene contains multitudes, and no one restaurant can represent all of it, right?!

— Bethany Jean Clement, food reporter and critic

I think this would be like pinning down my favorite restaurant — which changes constantly depending on my mood, what else I’ve already eaten and where I’m currently at in the city. Sometimes the most quintessential restaurant is the one closest to you that is open right now.

— Jackie Varriano, food reporter and critic

One not on the list? Saigon Deli on Jackson, a hole-in-the-wall deli in Little Saigon with the same friendly folks serving affordable banh mi every weekend.

— Trevor Lenzmeier, features editor

—QUESTION FROM: David Martin in Edmonds

1:05 pm

How do you go about ranking different cuisines against each other? I imagine it can be difficult to compare Japanese to East African, for example.

I don’t think we were ranking different cuisines against each other so much as answering the question of: “How well is this restaurant accomplishing what it’s trying to do?” Then we leaned on our individual expertise on different styles of cuisine while balancing our own tastes and preferences. It’s not an exact science. Food is personal, and so were our answers.

— Jackie Varriano, food reporter and critic

—QUESTION FROM: Ravi Desai in Pinehurst, Seattle

The prevailing online sentiment is that Seattle’s food scene is “mid.” I disagree, and your list backs me up. What is driving the negative sentiment? Is it the cost of dining here versus other communities?

We bring expectations and personal baggage to a restaurant. We mourn the days of dollar oysters and 50-cent tacos and real happy hour deals, which makes us question if X dish at Y price is “worth it” or “mid.” That can keep you from falling in love with how things are right now. There’s plenty of magic in Seattle restaurants if you know where to look.

— Jackie Varriano, food reporter and critic

—QUESTION FROM: Todd Rosin in Ballard, Seattle

12:41 pm

Please list all of the restaurants you reviewed for this project.

I don’t think you want to read that list of several hundred restaurants on your laptop. (Also: I do not have it typed up and ready for you.)

It’s not so much one list as it is multiple lists — many on paper, between Moleskine notebooks and legal pads, on whiteboards across two Seattle Times office buildings in South Lake Union, in addition to the sprawling master spreadsheet that we used for the project. (No, I will not be sharing that spreadsheet publicly.)

— T.L.

12:38 pm

Who were the other 75 restaurants you surveyed?

I would wager Jackie, Bethany and I have eaten at 250 to 300 restaurants this year. (That’s a conservative estimate!)

For this project, we started with a list of 125 restaurants. It grew, then shrank. We whittled the list down to 100, then 75. Then the arguments started.

We debated. We bickered with each other over who deserved the last slot (No. 50). Picking the last 10 “in” was just as hard as picking the Top 10.

You remember that chalkboard scene in “A Beautiful Mind”? With all the math equations and theorems covering every inch of the board? That was what our brainstorming sessions looked like.

— T.V.

12:31 pm

How does Pink Door not make the list? By far the biggest omission. It’s vitally important to the community in terms of location, reputation, popularity, and support of all things artistic and creative that make Seattle so special.

We could spend the rest of this week debating what ended up on this list (and what didn’t), but ultimately it came down to: Where did we consistently have the best meals in Seattle this year? Beyond that, our three critics’ opinions splintered on lines of taste, both about individual restaurants and the list as a whole. This 50 is a compromise, as folks have different tastes, including our critics.

Use our 50 Essential Restaurants as an excuse to try a new spot. Use it as an excuse to return to your favorites, too — whether or not they are on the list.

— Trevor Lenzmeier, features editor

Why did you use the word “essential”?

I hoped to capture the spirit of the project: that independent local restaurants are essential to the soul of Seattle and should be supported.

The argument is not that a place like Dick’s isn’t essential. More so that neighborhood restaurants are essential to the city.

And, given it’s a subjective list made by food critics, the final product trends toward “50 essential dining experiences for in-the-know restaurant lovers in 2026” rather than “the all-time 50 quintessential Seattle restaurants.”

This is, without argument, our critics’ list of the 50 favorite places they ate this year, ranked based on all the usual criteria from our reviews, from food to atmosphere and service.

We talked about Dick’s and Ray’s and Ivar’s and Ezell’s and Taco Time and your neighborhood teriyaki joint. We ultimately made a different type of list.

Calling it “50 best” would have been no less controversial, I would argue, and just as subjective.

But hey: I have seen the commenters saying we defiled the dictionary definition of “essential.” Note taken. Shoot me an email and let me hear it!

— Trevor Lenzmeier, features editor

To add to what Trevor said about this pesky word: While food is essential, dining out is a luxury, obviously. Here, I think we mean “essential” as in “conveying essence,” not “necessary for the continuation of life” (clearly!). What places convey Seattle-ness, in all its greatness, the best? Also worth-it-ness was a huge consideration — should you spend your dining-out money here? We thought about the restaurants that we name over and over when we’re asked for an extra-super-good recommendation. Not necessarily the newest and the hottest, but the quintessential ones that consistently make us so, so happy.

— B.J.C.

—QUESTION FROM: Multiple readers

12:23 pm

What core food memory do you associate with a Seattle restaurant? (My first taste of hollandaise sauce was on asparagus at Henry’s Off Broadway as a 9-year-old at a family birthday. This was approximately 1977.)

12:20 pm

Please explain that you all paid for all meals. That seems extraordinary. And expensive.

Answer: We did — well, the paper did! The Seattle Times always pays for restaurant-review-and-related outings. We also make reservations under aliases in order to arrive unannounced — we’ve found that there’s very little a place can do to up its game at the last minute. And that no restaurant can inject joy where there isn’t any. And we found a lot of joy here!!!

—  Bethany Jean Clement, food reporter and critic

Costs per menu items are increasing to the level that diners may reduce eating out. Is that happening in Seattle?

An emphatic “yes.” Just about every chef I interview cites high food costs as the most challenging issue facing their kitchens. Pretty much every Seattle restaurant has raised prices. Many now offer smaller portions or focus on rice bowls, tinned seafood, pork chops and other high-profit-margin dishes in an attempt to break even. Burgers are a prime example. The standard burger used to be a half-pounder. Now it’s mostly 3- to-4-ounce smashburgers sold for the same price.

— Tan Vinh, food reporter and critic

—QUESTION FROM: Meredith Radella in Frelard, Seattle

What is the most underrated place in Seattle?

One spot I fought for was Bongos, which is doing exactly what it wants to and crushing it. I also think Brimmer & Heeltap is one of the places I always find myself for celebratory meals. Also worthy of a mention is Ben’s Bread on Phinney Ridge. It’s amazing and everyone should know!

— Jackie Varriano, food reporter and critic

Off the top of my head: Oh Dang, which is the nicest possible husband-and-wife team making absurdly great food, including an out-of-this-world chicken katsu sandwich, out of the back of the bar Black Cat in Belltown. Warning: The music can be really loud there, but they do offer takeout.

— Bethany Jean Clement, food reporter and critic

Your local coffee shop, which often has decent sandwiches and salads to go with your cup of joe. This is especially true at Vietnamese coffeehouses that sell banh mi sandwiches, noodle bowls and French pastries. Many coffee counters source their goods from local bakeries and restaurants, which cater to this market as a side hustle.

— Tan Vinh, food reporter and critic

I love Blazing Grill in Ballard! Tamari Bar is my weeknight Capitol Hill date night / happy hour spot. Otherside Market for hoagies. A not-so-secret hidden gem: Quick Pack Food Mart for fried chicken. Loved Serafina when I lived on Eastlake Avenue. Feels like everybody knows about Oriental Mart, but it missed our list and is undervoted in people’s choice polling. Three Sacks Full was an if-you-know-you-know neighborhood gem that Jackie introduced to me. And: Newish on Capitol Hill is the very cute Cafe Lolo.

— Trevor Lenzmeier, features editor

—QUESTION FROM: Rose McAleese in Mount Baker, Seattle

12:00 pm

Were there any unanimous choices among your Top 50? (i.e.: Were all three critics in agreement on any of the picks?)

Lots of them! While disagreements (and bargaining, and one person getting overruled by the other two) did happen, we were surprised by how often our opinions dovetailed nicely. And even the disagreeing was all entirely amicable — nobody was reduced to tears at any point!

— Bethany Jean Clement, food reporter and critic

—QUESTION FROM: Linda Lenzmeier in Raleigh, N.C. 

11:56 am

Do bagel shops not count as restaurants? Just curious because they usually serve more than just bagels.

We did stay away from bagel shops (as well as roving pop-ups, a humble yet iconic corner-store chicken place in the Central District and other “exceptions to the rule” type restaurants). But rules are made to be broken … I would listen if the critics stumped hard for an exceptionally good bagel shop to make the list.

— Trevor Lenzmeier, features editor

—QUESTION FROM: Poto in Broadview, Seattle

I like the idea of this project but with one exception: the numerical rankings. It seems silly to rank a serious haute cuisine place (e.g., Iconiq) lower than a pizza joint (e.g., Stevie’s Famous).  Why not just list these places without rankings?

Many reasons! Business decisions: Lists are fun to debate for readers and critics alike. Ranking all 50 made the project challenging for our writers and engaging for readers, I’d argue. Utility is another reason. We spent all this money dining out … don’t you wanna know the critics’ picks? Now, on apples and oranges, Stevie’s and Iconiq. Which spot is more expertly executing two very different menus? The critics disagreed; the list is a compromise. I’ll say also, as we celebrate every one of these 50 restaurants: I figured 30 to 50 in particular would inspire a spirited dialogue. 

— Trevor Lenzmeier, features editor

—QUESTION FROM: Steve Robinson in Seward Park, Seattle

What were the criteria? How did you avoid recency bias?

It boiled down to: Does this dish deliver what it promises? Whether that’s a juicy roast chicken or a medium rare rib-eye. Also: Does this spot have significance to the community? Is it a third place? Or is it renowned for a particular dish? This ranking was a group decision between myself and my two food critic colleagues and our editor, who all have different backgrounds and tastes. The hardest part of this process: I am always right. And I don’t understand why my colleagues don’t see it my way. Like any proper family gathering, we bicker at the table and whine when we don’t get our way. In the end, we all made our case, listened to each other and compromised with this ranking, which we’re all happy with.

— Tan Vinh, food reporter and critic

[Editor’s note: Our team stayed away from spots that opened in 2026 and graded 2025 debuts with heightened scrutiny in an attempt to reward staying power and account for recency bias. We also made sure to retry even the places we’ve eaten at and enjoyed (or disliked) in the past. — Trevor Lenzmeier,  features editor]

—QUESTION FROM: Matt Draper in Fremont/Phinney Ridge, Seattle

Bethany Jean Clement: 206-464-2050 or bclement@seattletimes.com: On Facebook at bethany.jean.clement and on Instagram @bethanyjeanclement. Clement has written about food, restaurants and the people and cultures intrinsic to them for The Seattle Times since 2014.

Jackie Varriano: Jackie Varriano is a food writer at The Seattle Times who covers neighborhood restaurants around Western Washington, reporting on the ways food and communities intersect.

Tan Vinh: 206-515-5656 or tvinh@seattletimes.com: Tan Vinh is a food writer for The Seattle Times and the original host of “Seattle Eats,” a podcast from KUOW.

Dining and Cooking