When Sutro Hall opens inside the 140 New Montgomery building on Dec. 7, the restaurant will pull on several threads of San Francisco history: its location, inside the 101-year-old Pacific Telephone Building, and its name, an homage to early civic leader Adolf Sutro. The team behind it – some of whom have worked together for decades – also has deep roots in the city’s restaurant industry.

This includes Elisabeth Prueitt, the co-founder and co-owner of Tartine Bakery, who has joined Sutro Hall as consulting pastry chef. Though initially hesitant to get involved in a new brick-and-mortar project, Prueitt decided to come on board in part because she’s known two of Sutro Hall’s partners for many years, including managing partner Doug Washington. The deal was sealed when she saw the location, which housed the upscale Moroccan restaurant Mourad from 2015 until 2024, and has since been transformed with new details such as vintage gold pendant lights from France that mirror the style of the building’s Art Deco lobby.

From left: Sutro Hall managing partner Doug Washington, consulting pastry chef Elisabeth Prueitt, executive chef Michael Magallanes and beverage director Scott Baird. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

From left: Sutro Hall managing partner Doug Washington, consulting pastry chef Elisabeth Prueitt, executive chef Michael Magallanes and beverage director Scott Baird. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

“I just thought the space was fantastic,” Prueitt said. “Sometimes you just come across just the right thing and it speaks to you.” At Washington’s request – both his wife, Freya Prowe, and Prueitt are gluten intolerant – she created an entirely gluten-free dessert menu that staff will serve from a cart, including a Basque cheesecake with mandarins poached in white wine, honey and thyme and a baked Alaska flambéed tableside.

With Prueitt on board, Sutro Hall is now a Who’s-Who of restaurant industry veterans. Prueitt and Steven Eckler, a partner at Sutro Hall, first met while waiting tables at the famed Swedish-inspired New York restaurant Aquavit, which opened in the late 1980s. Washington was a founding partner at Jardiniere, the fine dining Hayes Valley institution, and of three popular South of Market restaurants – Town Hall, Salt House and Anchor & Hope – all now closed. Beverage director Scott Baird co-founded acclaimed bar Trick Dog in the Mission District and developed cocktails at 15 Romolo in North Beach.

Dukkah-roasted winter squash with Brussels sprouts and cranberry is one of the vegetable-forward dishes from executive chef Michael Magallanes. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

Dukkah-roasted winter squash with Brussels sprouts and cranberry is one of the vegetable-forward dishes from executive chef Michael Magallanes. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

The team is bringing new energy to a marquee downtown space that had sat empty for two years, part of a prolonged post-pandemic slump in vacancies in the surrounding area. That has been changing recently, including with a proposed $1 billion plan for new office space at Fourth and Harrison streets and prominent openings, such as of the Japanese fast-fashion chain Uniqlo, which previously closed its Union Square location during the pandemic, and Filipino fast-food restaurant Jollibee, both on Market Street.

Sutro Hall executive chef Michael Magallanes, who was most recently executive chef at the Jay Hotel in San Francisco, created a vegetable- and seafood-heavy menu inspired by Coastal Mediterranean traditions and spices, such as whole grilled dorade with roasted tomato herb sauce and dukkah roasted winter squash with Brussels sprouts and cranberry. Raw and cooked seafood dishes will include one inspired by his father, who used to dive for wild abalone when that was still legal: farmed Monterey abalone steamed until tender, chilled and served with Meyer lemon, Aleppo chile oil and pickled Fresno chiles. Magallanes also serves a scallop in its shell with an apple-tarragon relish.

Monterey abalone steamed, chilled and served with Meyer lemon and pickled Fresno chiles, is inspired by executive chef Michael Magallanes' father, who used to dive for abalone. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

Monterey abalone steamed, chilled and served with Meyer lemon and pickled Fresno chiles, is inspired by executive chef Michael Magallanes’ father, who used to dive for abalone. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

Inspired by shawarma and al pastor, Magallanes developed a vegetarian main course made of thinly sliced celery root blanched and bound together with a spiced celery root puree, which will be charred on a skewer over the grill. Meat dishes include a confit leg and seared breast of Liberty duck from Sonoma, served with fresh watercress and duck jus, cut with watercress oil.

Magallanes worked at Mourad under chef-owner Mourad Lahlou from its opening in 2015 and for several years after. He still has an “emotional connection” to the space, he said.

Baird created a cocktail menu of “light, bright and seasonal drinks,” Washington previously told the Chronicle, including a house margarita and a Manhattan served on tap. Also expect a California Drop, a frozen take on a lemon drop, and Café Sutro, which draws inspiration from San Francisco Irish coffee.

Cocktails from Scott Baird at Sutro Hall include, from left, the Café Sutro, with tequila, coffee liqueur, cold brew and passion fruit; Provencal Frappe, with pastis, Sauternes, lemon and mint; Banana Old-Fashioned, with bourbon, banana liqueur and amaro; and Pink Bicycle, with rosé and aperitif. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

Cocktails from Scott Baird at Sutro Hall include, from left, the Café Sutro, with tequila, coffee liqueur, cold brew and passion fruit; Provencal Frappe, with pastis, Sauternes, lemon and mint; Banana Old-Fashioned, with bourbon, banana liqueur and amaro; and Pink Bicycle, with rosé and aperitif. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

For the past decade, Washington stepped away from running restaurants to focus on his eponymous restaurant design company, which worked on projects such as Acre Kitchen and Bar in Oakland. At Sutro Hall, he collaborated with Prowe, an artist and floral designer, to paint murals and bring in plants, including two 15-foot trees. Compared to Mourad’s sleek, industrial aesthetic, Sutro Hall’s dining room has a honeyed, warm tone with wood paneling, red wool rugs and leather banquets. The 6,000-square-foot space seats 85 in the dining room and another 23 in a lounge and bar.

Prueitt, a James Beard Award winner who has written several cookbooks and creates gluten-free recipes for a Substack called Have Your Cake, still gives input on recipes at Tartine but said they’ve become “wonderfully standardized.” She hopes the same will happen at Sutro Hall, where she said creating recipes for a dessert cart was an interesting challenge. For example, she wanted to overcome several flaws she often sees with baked Alaska: It’s usually rock hard in the center, with “frozen-solid” cake and ice cream, while its meringue coating, which gets flambéed tableside, often isn’t toasted enough. Prueitt has instructed staff to brown the meringue a bit in advance and ensure the ice cream interior is tempered. “I want it perfectly edible when it gets to the table,” Prueitt said.

Sutro Hall's apple mille feuille is made of 60 layers of apple. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

Sutro Hall’s apple mille feuille is made of 60 layers of apple. (Jessica Christian/S.F. Chronicle)

Prueitt also created a moist flourless chocolate cake with a cremeux filling – a creme anglaise blended with chocolate. “The chocolate and egg, of course, give it structure when it cools,” she said, creating the “silkiest pudding because there’s no flour.”

Prueitt said she’s enjoyed collaborating with the Sutro Hall team and has been inspired, for example, by Baird’s cocktail garnishes such as pickled fig leaves, an ingredient she would like to use in a dessert.

“When you’re working with people who have a common sensibility and point of view, it makes the whole thing such a pleasure,” she said. “You all have a similar language, and an understanding of what this place is.”

Sutro Hall. Opening Dec. 7. 140 New Montgomery, San Francisco. sutrohall.com

Subscribe

There’s more to San Francisco with the Chronicle. Subscribe today for just 25¢.

This article originally published at An all-star team, a dessert cart and a historic building: Inside downtown S.F.’s newest restaurant.

Dining and Cooking