By Kerry Altiero
Photos by Nicole Wolf
From our October 2025 issue

How many James Beard Award semifinalists serve an all-you-can-eat buffet? Probably not many, I’d wager. How about for under $20? My best bet is just one: Taj, in South Portland, which earned its first Beard nod earlier this year, in the category for outstanding hospitality, after more than a decade in business. I recently paid a visit at lunchtime, when the buffet is offered. Relative to quality and quantity, the pricing — a mere $18.99 — seemed downright proletarian. The first impression of the room where the buffet is set up is a surge of aroma (unless you’re more of a visual person and immediately gravitate to the huge wall mural of the Taj Mahal, painted by local artist Mike Rich). I counted more than two dozen chafing dishes set out in long rows. There were curries, ranging from the ubiquitous Indian butter chicken to those with house-made paneer cheese. There were vegetable noodles and spinach saag. Fried hot peppers proved especially tasty when dipped in a creamy, cooling raita. Tandoori chicken was grilled to a perfect char. Luscious, freshly baked naan is delivered straight to the table. 

There was plenty for just about everyone, from diehard carnivores to vegetarians to the gluten-free. As a vegetarian in the ’70s (I’ve since reformed), I counted on South Asian restaurants for veggie-centric meals that were integral to the cuisine, not just a lesser imitation of a meat dish. Desserts abounded too, from Indian staples like gulab jamun (fried balls of cheese doused with honey syrup) to crème brûlée or homemade ice cream. 

the door to and from Taj’s patiothe door to and from Taj’s patio

Koudalima Dolama putting finishing touches on a coconut mojito at the barKoudalima Dolama putting finishing touches on a coconut mojito at the bar

general manager Sai Guntakageneral manager Sai Guntaka

the buffet room, with its Taj Mahal muralthe buffet room, with its Taj Mahal mural
Clockwise from top left: the door to and from Taj’s patio; Koudalima Dolama putting finishing touches on a coconut mojito at the bar; general manager Sai Guntaka; the buffet room, with its Taj Mahal mural.

Ever since the Guntaka family opened Taj in a small space in a South Portland strip mall, in 2012, the restaurant has been a local favorite. But not long before then, the Guntakas couldn’t have picked Maine out on a map, having first settled in Austin, Texas, after immigrating from India. Last year, Taj moved to a new space just down the road from the original, almost quadrupling in size. Scaling up is always a risk in the restaurant business, but the Guntakas managed to maintain great food and great prices — none of the dinner entrées clock in north of $20 — and only seem to have grown in popularity. As I tasted my way around the buffet options, I observed a heterogenous crowd of hipster couples, construction workers, young families, and solo diners who looked to have surpassed retirement age. 

In the new space, the buffet room is spacious enough to be a sit-down area in its own right. In the evening, it becomes the staging ground for takeout orders, and it’s set off nicely from Taj’s bar and dining room. The dining room has a simple, modern elegance to it, with a palette of gentle greens and grays, high ceilings, soft lighting, and attractive tile work around the bar. The new kitchen looks big enough for a resort hotel, and it hosts two tandoors, the cylindrical clay ovens — sort of like wide, squat vases (but in this case, encased in stainless steel) — used for baking naan and roasting meats and vegetables.

Eating at Taj feels genuinely transportive, a world away from lobster rolls and blueberry pie, but without the hassle of TSA screening. In modern American restaurants, “fewer ingredients, more skill” has become a central tenet. A good Indian meal, with its panoply of spices and chutneys and other condiments and complexity in every bite, really pokes some holes in that idea. All the more so when it’s in the deft hands of chef Hema Latha Guntaka and her son, Sai, the general manager.

I went back to Taj for an à la carte dinner a couple of weeks later. The evening is a fine time to dabble in some of the cocktails accented with Indian flavors — maybe a whiskey sour with tamarind nectar or a margarita with a hint of curry powder. If beer is more your speed, consider the crisp Indian-style lager that resulted from a collaboration between Taj and Oxbow Brewing. Or, on the nonalcoholic side of the ledger, there’s no going wrong with a spice-subduing mango lassi, which Taj concocts with house-made yogurt and fresh mango. 

Many, but certainly not all, of the dishes had also been served at the buffet. A friend and I did our best to eat our way around the menu. The dosa mysore, a crepe of white lentils and rice, with the approximate diameter of a large pizza, was filled with masala-spiced potato. The punugulu reminded me of a hush puppy, but with amped-up flavor thanks to the inclusion of onion, chilies, and cilantro. Vindaloo goat curry brought its trademark heat, while korma, a milder option, was studded with tender bites of lamb. Biryani, with its fragrant basmati rice and chicken cooked in a lemony yogurt sauce, was a nice counterpoint to the curries, as was the gobi Manchurian, an Indo-Chinese standby of fried cauliflower tossed in a sweet and spicy soy-based sauce. None of these are clever twists on traditional cooking, and I mean that as high praise. Instead, in this era of compulsive reinterpretation and riffing, they’re skillful expressions of timeless flavors, the kinds of flavors that keep you coming back.

Help Us Celebrate Maine

If you enjoyed this story, I hope you’ll consider supporting Down East. For more than 70 years, Down East has been a leading ambassador and advocate for Maine — spreading stories across the country about its talented characters, chefs, organizations, and towns and places that make it so special. 

When you subscribe to Down East, you help ensure we can continue reporting on the people and places that make this state extraordinary. Additionally, when you join our community of readers throughout the country, you also support small businesses across the state, including all the artists and craftsmakers that help define the culture of Maine.

In exchange for your support, you get a year of stories, stunning photography, insider guides, and that unmistakable emotional connection to Maine. You can also sign up for our newsletters for weekly updates, or give a gift subscription to share Maine with someone special.

Maine is home to all our writers, editors, and photographers, and your support will help us continue to do what we do best. Together, we can ensure local Maine journalism stays strong.

Lawrence HollinsLawrence Hollins

Lawrence Hollins
Publisher, Down East magazine

SubscribeSubscribe

Dining and Cooking