The 2026 Edition of The Best Italian Restaurants in New Jersey is written by Vinny Parisi.

If there were four pillars of New Jersey Dining, they’d be represented by Bagel Shops, Diners, Pizzerias, and Italian restaurants. But when it comes to finding The Best Italian Restaurants in New Jersey, we’re looking beyond the standard red-sauce joints. Instead, this list highlights the master chefs pushing boundaries while still respecting Italian tradition.

From scratch-made pastas and family recipes to seasonal wine pairings, these restaurants turn an ordinary dinner into something unforgettable. Our list includes white tablecloth fine dining and casual family-style restaurants alike, so there’s something for everyone. What separates these restaurants from the pack is how they balance reverence for tradition with confident innovation. So guests can enjoy something familiar, or indulge in a brand new experience that tastes like a vacation to Italy.

Quick Click Guide: Select a Region below to find The Best Italian Restaurants nearby.

| 2026 Featured Listings | North Jersey | Central Jersey | Jersey Shore | South Jersey |

Featured Italian Restaurants of 2026

Featured From Somerset County:
Luca’s Ristorante

Lucas Ristorante

Where: 2019 NJ-27, Somerset
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Luca’s Ristorante Owner/Chef Andrea Di Meglio is a staple of the Somerset community. Located in a small strip mall, the menu boasts authentic dishes native to his homeland, Ischia. Beyond dinner dates, the intimate, rustic yet modern design makes the restaurant perfect for any occasion. Chef Andrea pays homage to his roots with signature dishes like the “Luca”. This linguine dish combines shrimp, colossal crabmeat, scallops, roasted tomatoes, capers, and asparagus in a creamy white wine sauce. Another favorite is the “Coniglio,” broccoli rabe orecchiette rigate in slow-cooked red wine ragu made with braised wild rabbit. He also serves classic dishes like Branzino, Marsala Arrosto, and Cinquanta. (A 50-layer lasagna!) Everything is made from scratch, from the table bread and 100% organic pastas to the desserts. For instance, their pistachio brûlée uses crema al pistacchio reale made with pistachio del Bronte in Italy.

| Visit Their Website | Reserve a Table | Order Online / Purchase Gift Card | Follow @lucasristorantenj on Instagram | Call 732-297-7676 |

Featured From Camden County:
Mare Monte

Mare Monte

Where: 1 Kings Hwy E, Haddonfield
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: For dinner that feels like fine dining without the financial investment, Mare Monte is a popular choice. Open since 2019, the restaurant features a carefully curated selection of authentic Italian entrees. In fact, all breads, sauces, pastries, and pasta are made in-house. Plus, their kids menu makes them a great option for dinner with the whole family. Their kids menu offers options like linguine with red sauce, penne with butter, chicken strips with fries, and Fettuccine Alfredo. For the adults, Mare Monte’s signature dishes include papardelle cavatore, shrimp salsa, fried gnocchi, calamari, Gnocchi Monte, Fettuccine 417, and long hots. We also recommend the Seafood Risotto (mussels, clams, and shrimp in a saffron crema). Mare Monte is BYOB and offers ample free parking, with a selection of local wines from Blue Cork Winery. PA-based readers may also want to visit their sister restaurant — Via — in Jenkintown.

| Visit Their Website | Follow @MareMonteNJ on Instagram | Follow on Facebook | Call 856-528-2712 |

Featured from Bergen County:
Fiorentini

Lamb Croquettes from Fiorentini

Where: 98 Park Ave, Rutherford
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Fiorentini is where authentic Italian cooking meets true farm-to-table dining. Chef and owner Antonio De Ieso brings the traditions, flavors, and simplicity of his Italian roots to Rutherford, letting the farms and seasons of New Jersey shape what arrives on the plate. Chef Antonio’s seasonal menu pairs local meats and produce with carefully-selected products imported directly from Italy. The result is authentic Italian cooking that unlocks the full potential of each exceptional ingredient. Fiorentini’s menu showcases handmade pastas, seasonal vegetables, seafood, meats, housemade desserts, gelati, and sorbet. It goes far beyond farm-to-table, seamlessly synergizing the relationship between the kitchen, the farmer, and the season. For a more intimate experience, their Chef’s Table seats four guests for a multi-course tasting. This is Italian cooking meant to be enjoyed, shared, and remembered.

| Visit Their Website | Reserve a Table | Purchase Gift Card | Follow on Instagram | Follow on Facebook | Call 973-721-3404 |

Best in Camden County:
Graziano’s Ristoranti

Graziano's Rstoranti

Where: 400 White Horse Pike, Chesilhurst
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Traditional meets trendy at Graziano’s, an Italian dining experience that pairs authentic recipes with modern flavors. Folks travel quite a distance — from Atlantic City to Philadelphia — just to eat here. Their rotating selection of weekly specials always includes something unique. One example is their Pasta Flight, which currently features short rib ravioli, rigatoni in vodka sauce, and spaghetti bolognese. Popular menu staples include the Crispy Beet Fries, Short Rib Crostini with fig glaze, Pittsburg Angus Sirloin Steak, Chicken Pizzuto, and Provolone Baked Shrimp Fra Diavolo. Their drink menu boasts specialty mocktails and “mocktinis” like Lavender Mint Lemonade and Sparkling Blood Orange, as well as diverse cocktails like the Hot Honey Smoked Old Fashioned and Big Daddy Frozen Banana Espresso Martini. Must-try desserts include the Caramel Banana Bread Pudding and homemade Tiramisu of the week in unique flavors.

| Visit their Website | Follow @grazianos_ristoranti on Instagram | Follow on Facebook | Call 856-768-4177 |

Featured from Passaic County:
Spuntino Wine Bar & Italian Tapas

Spuntino Wine Bar

Where: 70 Kingsland Rd, Clifton
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Spuntino Wine Bar & Italian Tapas brings the warmth, flavor, and hospitality of Italy to New Jersey. The restaurant serves as a premier destination for wine lovers and food enthusiasts seeking an elevated, approachable dining experience. Every menu item showcases quality ingredients, bold flavors, and passion for Italian cooking. In particular, every pasta dish is made fresh in-house alongside freshly-baked pizza. This includes favorites like the Orecchiette alla Vodka (tomato vodka sauce, parmigiano reggiano); and the Piccante pizza (San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, red pepper flakes, and honey). Their world-class wine program features over 150 pours by the glass, each curated to perfectly pair with a signature entree. Spuntino boasts a welcoming atmosphere for romantic date nights, with plenty of event space for celebrations, corporate gatherings, and private dinners.

| Visit Their Website | Reserve a Table | Follow on Instagram | Follow on Facebook | Call 973-661-2435 |

North Jersey

Casa Bellisima

Where: Sparta
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: The cuisine at Casa Bellissima is effortlessly stylish to match the casual polo and jeans atmosphere. The menu takes classic Italian favorites and gives them a modern twist. Executive Chef Michael Penaranda diligently curates signature dishes that leave guests thinking about their meal long after they leave. Menu favorites include the lobster ravioli, blackened salmon, chicken rollatini (stuffed with prosciutto and mozzarella), and veal marsala. Sitting at the bar? We recommend the Parmesan truffle fries and seasonal burger!

Clementina

Where: Upper Montclair
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Clementina brings the flavors of Senigallia straight to Montclair. Chef Michele Rocchi hails from the resort town of Senigallia, located within Le Marche, Italy. Though the menu is rooted in tradition — Chef Rocchi has been cooking since he was 14 years old — his dishes offer a fresh, modern take on classic cooking. Clementina prioritizes organic, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, bringing the flavors of New Jersey to familiar Italian dishes. Must-try dishes include the Tagliatelle with Shellfish and Chicken al Potacchio (a Le Marche specialty).

Cotto

Where: Morristown
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: This elevated Italian restaurant is a fan favorite for its handmade pastas and innovative approach to classic cuisine. The chef-driven BYO perfectly balances tradition and creativity to create refined yet approachable regional Italian dishes. We recommend starting with the potato leek croquettes before ordering the simply must-try Linguine Amatriciana. (Made with calamari and squid ink.) The soft lighting, white tablecloths, and exquisite service all make for one of our favorite North Jersey Date Night Spots.

Mama’s Cafe Baci

Where: Hackettstown
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Mama’s is a two-for-one, combining the restaurant Mama’s with their cozy Cafe Baci. The restaurant is popular for their Pizza, calzones, and strombolis as well as their authentic pasta dishes. Popular classic pastas include cheese tortellini alfredo, baked ziti, and lasagna. In addition, they serve specialty pastas like Pear & Gorgonzola, Champagne Palma, and Vesuvio. The latter combines penne with mushrooms, peas, and bacon in a creamy rosa sauce. Besides dine-in options, they offer takeout, pickup, and curbside delivery.

Central Jersey

Da Filippo’s

Where: Somerville
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Da Filippo’s has been a Somerville staple for over 35 years. This neighborhood BYOB feels like a trip to Sicily, one where fresh seafood is the highlight of the experience. Chef Filippo Russo has been cooking traditional Italian meals stateside since 1982. (Prior to that, he lived in Sicily and learned his mother’s recipes.) At Da Filippo’s, Chef Russo brings guests on a culinary tour of Piemonte, Veneto, Lazio, Umbria, Liguria, Lombardia, Toscana, Sardegna, and Marche. We recommend the Lampuga e Gamberi (Pan Seared Pacific Mahi-Mahi).

Mario’s Tutto Bene

Where: Union
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: The menu at Mario’s Tutto Bene fuses old-world Italian cuisine with modern culinary creations. Which means whether guests are looking for familiar cooking or hoping to try something new, they’ll find both options here. For instance, Mario’s serves traditional shrimp scampi and Tuscan salmon as well as unique dishes including Vinegar Pork Chops and Cacio E Pepe Chicken. The latter is boneless chicken breast crusted with cracked black pepper, Parmesan, and Pecorino Romano topped with peppercorn cream sauce.

Vidalia Restaurant by Salvatore Scarlata

Where: Lawenceville
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: This BYOB Italian bistro is perfect for indoor or outdoor patio dining in their garden. Chef Salvatore Scarlata has spent many years refining his recipes, which fuse the flavors of various Italian regions. Many dishes take inspiration from his birthplace of Villalba in Sicily, others from the northern Italian city of Liguria where he was raised. The end result is a perfect marriage of the chef’s favorite dishes, which allows him to cook with passion. We recommend the Sacchettini (pasta purses filled with fontina cheese and pear puree) for dinner.

Vincenzo’s Ristorante

Where: Middlesex
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Vincenzo’s promises fine Italian dining for lunch or dinner, and is a great option for warm weather patio dining. The restaurant walks a fine line between high-quality cuisine and reasonable prices, all while cultivating a relaxing, family atmosphere. Highlights from the starters menu include Clams fra Diavolo, Mushrooms Giovanna (with crushed hot peppers), and artichokes Francese. Meanwhile, main dish must-haves we recommend are the homemade Gnocchi Portobello, Shrimp & Scallops Aurora, and Chicken Mona Lisa.

Jersey Shore

Anjelica’s Restaurant

Where: Sea Bright
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Anjelica’s offers upscale Italian dining in an energetic atmosphere. This year marks their 30th Anniversary, and continues their longstanding tradition of high-quality cuisine and gracious hospitality. Founder Ray Lena named the restaurant after his daughter, who was 10 at the time Anjelica’s first opened. Anjelica herself now operates the restaurant, continuing the family tradition. The seasonal menu at this BYOB spot features favorites like Rigatoni al Fabian (with lobster meat in a spicy blush sauce) and their signature Pollo Ripieno.

Il Giardinello Di Bacoli

Where: Toms River
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: The self-proclaimed “Best Place for Italian Food in Ocean County” sets the bar pretty high for itself. Though not the original owners, Gennaro “Gerry” and his wife Danielle Costigliola are committed to this same pursuit of excellence. Gerry was born and raised in Bacoli, Italy, and the menu reflects his favorite Neapoletan dishes from his youth. One popular entree is the Italian Trio, a mix of eggplant, meatballs, and sausage. For special occasions and corporate events, they offer both private or semi-private dining and catering options.

Spano’s Ristorante Italiano

Where: Point Pleasant Beach
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Chef/Owner Joseph Spano has been tantalizing taste buds with his flair for Italian fare since 1989. His mammoth portions, use of only the freshest ingredients, and general love of Italian cuisine shine through in every dish. This BYO spot curates the perfect atmosphere for date night, with a dinner menu that feels familiar yet new. Their fresh pasta is made in house daily, so we recommend trying one of their signature pasta entrees. For instance, their Seafood Fiesta plates shrimp, scallops, and lump crab meat over spaghettini.

Viggiano’s on Sunset

Where: Cape May
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Viggiano’s is all about choice. For instance, they serve all entrees as either piccolo (for one) or Grande (for two). The restaurant also follows what they call “Great Grandma’s Rules” when it comes to their menu. One rule is that all meatballs mix ground pork, veal, and beef, made with spices and cooked in marinara sauce. Their signature dishes include Chicken Piccata, Chicken Cacciatore, Sauteed Veal and Shrimp, Eggplant Parmesan, and Grilled Salmon. But no trip is complete without ordering one of their homemade desserts like tiramisu.

South Jersey

La Campagnola

Where: Shamong
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: Not to be confused with the La Campagnola in Central Jersey, this Shamong restaurant offers Fine Italian dining. The menu features favorites like calamari fritti, stuffed shells, linguine in white clam sauce, and pepper crusted yellow fin tuna. But they are most famous for their signature pasta dishes. For instance, we recommend the Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo, which cooks sauteed chicken and broccoli with house made Alfredo sauce. Ask about their soup of the day, because they always make their own soup from scratch in-house daily.

Fratelli’s

Where: Burlington
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: A true family-owned small business, Fratelli’s is as authentic as it gets. Owner Ivan Gonzalez has been in the restaurant business for over 20 years. Locals love their fair prices, top notch service, plus easy takeout and free delivery options. Menu highlights include the classic stromboli, chicken parm sub, grilled Toscani panini, and baked ziti. Meanwhile, their selection of gourmet pizzas includes the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and Grilled Chicken Fajita Pizza. Their famous thin crust tomato pie is a one of the county’s most precious exports.

Illiano Cucina

Where: Medford
Why It’s a Best of NJ Pick: This family-owned BYOB is a neighborhood favorite and longtime fixture in the community. The menu includes traditional Italian dishes alongside a popular selection of salads thanks to their homemade house dressing. Fan-favorite entrees include the Shrimp Sinatra w/ lobster meat and the Illiano Gnocchi Caprese served with buffalo mozzarella. Besides sit-down dinner, Illiano is also a popular takeout option for pizza. (We recommend the Sicilian White Special with spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and chopped tomato.)

NJ’s Best Italian Restaurants FAQs

1. Which NJ Italian Restaurants Focus On True Farm-To-Table Dining?

Fiorentini (Rutherford) seamlessly bridges local New Jersey farms with authentic Italian techniques. Chef Antonio De Ieso’s seasonal menu pairs local meats and produce with carefully selected imports. The result is a highly-elevated farm-to-table dining experience.

2. Where Can I Find Authentic Regional Dishes From Le Marche Or Ischia?

Clementina (Upper Montclair) serves Le Marche specialties like Chicken al Potacchio. Meanwhile, Luca’s Ristorante (Somerset) pays homage to the island of Ischia with signature seafood-heavy linguine dishes.

3. Are There Top-Rated Italian Restaurants That Easily Accommodate Kids And Families?

Mare Monte (Haddonfield) features a dedicated kids menu with approachable options like penne with butter and chicken strips. For adults, the restaurant offers an authentic, fine-dining feel complete with Seafood Risotto and long hots.

4. Which Italian Spots In New Jersey Feature Extensive Wine Bars?

Spuntino Wine Bar & Italian Tapas (Clifton) curates a world-class program with over 150 pours by the glass. Their extensive selection pairs perfectly with their fresh, in-house pastas and Neapolitan-style pizzas.

5. Where Can I Find A Great BYOB Italian Restaurant Down The Jersey Shore?

Anjelica’s Restaurant (Sea Bright) and Spano’s Ristorante Italiano (Point Pleasant Beach) are both popular BYOB destinations. They are best known for offering mammoth portions of scratch-made pastas and fresh seafood in upscale, energetic settings.

Click Here To See More Best of New Jersey Lists.

Top Photo: Fiorentini / Website

Dining and Cooking