If you grew up in New Jersey, you know a good Italian deli when you smell one. The garlic, the fresh mozzarella, the counter guy who somehow remembers your order from three years ago. So when a national food publication set out to name the best Italian delis across the country, it was worth paying attention to who took the crown in New Jersey.
Chowhound recently published a list of standout Italian delis across the country, and the Garden State pick is one food lovers will want to check out (or brag that they already have).
How Chowhound Picked the Winners
This wasn’t a random popularity contest. According to the outlet, the selection process focused on delis that generate genuine customer enthusiasm and repeat business, not just a one-time viral moment. The team combed through social media chatter and online forums, then cross-referenced that buzz with recognition from established food publications.
From there, they weighed a few key factors: the variety and quality of products (think imported goods, made-to-order sandwiches, and house-made cheeses), the strength of prepared dishes, the overall atmosphere, and whether customers felt the experience was actually worth what they paid.
READ MORE: A Popular Jersey Shore Steakhouse is Opening Another Location Inland
What Makes This Pick Stand Out
By that standard, the New Jersey winner checks every box. The shop is known for a serious selection of meats and cheeses, plus prepared meals like pastas, sausage with peppers, and chicken Parmesan, making it easy to skip cooking dinner altogether.
Highlights include a stuffed prosciutto bread and The Italian Special, a sandwich loaded with house-made mozzarella, sliced provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, and roasted red peppers.
That’s the Palermo, featuring homemade focaccia, homemade creamy pesto, mortadella, arugula, fresh burrata, and sun-dried tomatoes.
Welcome to Dolce & Clemente’s Italian Gourmet Market in Robbinsville Township, located at 2 N Commerce Square.
If you’ve ever been chasing the best sandwich in the state, this might just be worth the trip. If you’ve been, you already know. If you haven’t, consider this your sign.
10 Jersey Shore Restaurants You Have To Try
Gallery Credit: Lou Russo
Dining and Cooking