Five years ago, Eric Valchuis and brothers Cyrus and Koby Elias were consultants and engineers living in different states. Today, they’re in Salt Lake City managing Baby’s Bagels and coming off the launch of a second concept, Pie Boy Pizza.
Neither Valchuis nor Koby had culinary backgrounds. Cyrus trained at an Alice Waters restaurant in Berkley for under a year, but left the industry soon after. Yet, for years, food remained their (occasionally demanding) hobby.
“Cyrus was known for getting obsessed with different kinds of food — one time he was making hand-pulled noodles every day for a month,” Valchuis says. “It was something our friends started to expect.” Koby was at home throwing pizza parties and perfecting recipes.
That history was the foundation for a conversation sparked at the start of the pandemic, when all three soon-to-be founders finally lived in one place: Utah.
“It was a convergence of friends and family,” Valchuis says.
While Valchuis wasn’t as passionate about cooking, his father’s example of entrepreneurship pushed him to make a pitch.
“A restaurant was something we’d talked about but never did,” Valchuis says. “I had the bandwidth, so I kind of flippantly threw it out there — why don’t we try?”
The Elias brothers signed on quickly. “We wanted to build a community in Salt Lake,” Cyrus says. “And food was what connected us.”
Cyrus’ wife is from Queens and struggled to find a “satisfactory bagel” in the West. The team agreed with her, and soon, they were back in the kitchen together.
“I was definitely the most reluctant of the three to be in a kitchen,” Valchuis says. “At that point none of us had any idea what we were doing, but we did know we were smart people who could figure it out.”
Photo courtesy of Baby’s Bagels Slow and steady
They made a dozen bagels at a time, met, discussed, compared to other bagels in the city and adjusted. No business plan, financing, suppliers or fancy kitchen supplies were involved, just how-to YouTube videos and flour from the local grocery store.
“We tried different fermentations, times, temperatures, flours,” Koby says. “Through five months of experimentation, we found what we liked.”
The trio didn’t spend “a lot of time, or really any” on budget and planning. There was no concept of a physical store. “We all had other jobs. This was a side thing for us,” Valchuis says. “I’m sure if we invested tons of money or otherwise made it feel like Baby’s was our one shot, it would be different. But because it started as fun, we didn’t feel that planning was necessary.”
In the face of challenges or failures, Cyrus says he and the rest of the team leaned on their career experiences, even if it felt unrelated.
“As an engineer on the manufacturing floor, I built processes that were easy to follow and got buy-in from a team to carry out those tasks, and that’s essentially the same thing here,” he says.
The team rented a commissary kitchen according to demand but kept spending low. “The kitchen cost real money, but otherwise, it was the ingredients, and we were eating those bagels,” Koby says. “We chalked it up to a grocery budget.”
Sales trickled in purely through Instagram. While Koby admits the concept was “weird,” it was the trial Baby’s needed. “People would reserve their bagels on a Friday and pick up Saturday morning,” Valchuis says. “We’d get up at 3 a.m. and start making bagels.”
The de-risking continued with a spot at the Downtown Farmer’s Market.
“I’m in awe of entrepreneurs who go from nothing to something overnight, who crowdfund or attract investors,” Valchuis says. “But that’s just not how we wanted to do it. We focused on lower-risk, incremental change.”
Photo courtesy of Baby’s Bagels Opening the doors
With a successful run at the Farmer’s Market, and years after the initial concept, the team finally felt like the move to brick-and-mortar was organic. Still, they played it safe, leasing just a bigger commissary kitchen first. With sales still on the rise, the team finally committed to a physical storefront and cafe space.
The physical location brought more customers and visibility, but also new challenges: “We needed to be a real restaurant now,” Cyrus says.
That meant a full menu, consistent opening hours, rent payments, payroll, insurance, financial statements and a profitable bottom line — all on very little sleep.
“I remember the day of our soft launch: We had been working around the clock for a month,” Valchuis says. “We were completely exhausted. Then we realized that was just the first day, and we’d have to do it again. And again. And again. It was really overwhelming.”
But the team knew what to do: solve one problem at a time. Now the store has over 30 employees and a functioning management separate from the team.
“Each time you take a step, you note what you learned from the last one, and hopefully it goes a bit smoother,” Cyrus says. “There’s definitely a fair amount of relearning each time, though, and the more we’ve done that, the more our confidence built.”
A mission statement was one of the final touches.
Photo courtesy of Baby’s Bagels
“We’ve had many disagreements, and out of them, we’ve come to a truly cohesive vision that would have been impossible if we tried in 2021,” Valchuis says.
The mission statement is bigger than Baby’s: to create neighborhood joints where people feel at home, as Valchuis puts it.
Next stop? Pie Boy
With bagels secured, the trio agreed that pizza was the next quality food Salt Lake City needed.
“The diversification was a personal passion. I don’t think there’s a sound business rationale for it,” Koby says. “If we were focused on growth of the business, we’d be scaling Baby’s, but that’s not what our mission statement is about. That’s not why we started any of this.”
Conquering new challenges is what the team wanted. Cyrus adds, “The fun part for us is learning how to do new things. At the bagel shop, we have a great manager, so we’ve freed ourselves up to focus on what’s next.”
Applying the lessons of “slow and steady” from Baby’s, the team started Pie Boy in their home kitchens, then small launches, and now, Pie Boy moonlights in the Baby’s storefront a few nights a week. After increasing to five nights a week, Pie Boy is outgrowing the space.
“We’ll do the same thing we’ve done: share responsibility, work together and build spaces for people in our community,” Koby says.
It wasn’t business expertise or massive funding sources that drove their success, but a focus on the community.
“Restaurants are an ethereal kind of consumer good product that come and go based on the tastes of the consumers, and they’re so sensitive to underlying costs,” Cyrus says. “It’s true that they can be fragile, but there are also durable, neighborhood staples. That’s Baby’s. And that’s Pie Boy.”

Dining and Cooking