In the series, Portnoy gives pizzerias a ranking out of 10 based on “one bite” of their pizza. The series began nearly a decade ago, and Portnoy has tried slices from several Connecticut pizzerias on camera.
The Barstool Sports founder visited Hartford Pizza Garden, located at 2053 Park St. in Hartford, in a video posted on Wednesday. Pornoy described the pizzeria as “half pizza, half like a psychedelic garden.”
Hartford Pizza Garden owner Pepe Burby immediately recognized Portnoy when he entered the establishment, telling him that he “came to the right spot.” He showed Portnoy Hartford Pizza Garden’s in-restaurant basil, arugula and bok choy garden and its mobile pizza oven.
“Would’ve been an intergalactic mistake if we didn’t make it here,” Portnoy said immediately after taking his first bite of the pizza. “Because (Burby) is unbelievable, and the pizza is an easy eight.”
Portnoy described the pizza’s flavor as being “a little bit sweet” and more of a traditional style rather than New Haven style. Portnoy said he likes “New Haven more,” but said the pizza was an eight.
However, Portnoy said he sometimes bumps up a pizza place’s score “just because there’s something going on.”
“And Pepe is going on. You walk in there, it’s like the pizza’s being grown,” Portnoy said. “It’s an eight without Pepe and that environment.”
Overall, Portnoy ranked Hartford Pizza Garden an 8.4.
“I need a score that’s like, ‘We gotta try this place,'” Portnoy said. “You have to go to this place. If you live around here, you haven’t been here, what are you doing?”
Portnoy said in his 13 to 14 years of doing pizza reviews that Hartford Pizza Garden is a “one of one pizza spot.”
Burby spoke to Portnoy about his background in pizza, including how he learned to make pizza through YouTube, and explained that Hartford Pizza Garden’s pies are made with no sugar, no bromate and no bleach in their flour. He also gave Portnoy a bottle of Hartford-made honey.

Dining and Cooking