I found myself recently in a conversation with a young man whom I baptized some years ago. I’ll call him Max. It was great to see him again, after years in which our paths had diverged. We had a good catch-up. Along the way, Max shared his rather uneasy relationship with organized religion—a trait he shares with many in his generation. 

 

But Max hasn’t walked away entirely. And I can’t stop thinking about something he said about local churches, especially those with a denominational label: 

 

“They’re easy like a chain restaurant. You walk in; you know what to expect.”

 

I was immediately struck by the positive side of that description—which is what I think Max was trying to express—and also by the bad news it names. I want to share a bit of that here.

 

A clarification, as we begin. With those words “chain restaurant,” I understood Max to mean, and I’ll use that term here, the well-known chain restaurants whose jingles or advertising we know and which we see repeatedly on our travels around the country. Some are fast food; others are dine-in. Not all have locations all across the country, but each has a lot of locations.

 

I’m guessing we’d all agree with Max about the ease we feel walking into a chain restaurant. You enter those doors and you already know what to expect. The menu, the physical space, the quality: there’s a predictability there that makes it comfortable. In the chain restaurants I frequent, I don’t even need to think about my order; there’s a thing I always get when I go there. At Jimmy John’s, it’s the Veggie, #6. At Panda Express, my order (like more than 50% of their customers) will include orange chicken. At Olive Garden, I’m mostly there for the breadsticks.

 

Max was pointing out that this same kind of familiarity happens when people walk into their local churches. A good kind of familiarity. I’m not sure he said, “like putting on a pair of comfortable shoes,” but he might have.

 

It’s an interesting observation given what many of us know about local churches—even those with a particular denominational label: We’re nowhere near as standard as, say, Applebee’s. There are wide variations in music, for instance. Within a 100-mile radius practically anywhere you could likely walk into a United Methodist church that sings from the hymnal, another that’s led by a gospel ensemble, and a third with some version of a band leading contemporary praise music. Liturgy similarly ranges from “high church” readings to “low church” spontaneity, with similar swings in theology and emphasis. Will there be talk of sin and repentance, or love and justice? That’s a lot of variation, right off the bat, as compared to chain restaurants which tend to be much more consistent.

 

Still, you can walk into almost any local church and it will feel familiar.[1] There will be some form of a sanctuary or other worship space where people are arranged around the one(s) who are speaking. Worship will have a flow and feel that we recognize. I understand what Max was saying about this having some of that positive comfort that we are used to finding in a chain restaurant. In both settings, we show up and we can expect to be fed something we enjoy and recognize, served up with some degree of attention to quality and meaning. And we’ll go away satisfied, at least to a point.

 

You can tell, of course, that I’m hedging on all of those statements. “Quality” and “meaning” and “satisfied” are not fully assured whether we’re talking about a chain restaurant or a church service. Among all the things we expect in that chain eatery, some menu items might be unavailable that day. This particular church might not do communion on this first Sunday of the month as we expected. For all the times I’ve left a chain restaurant without thinking much about whether it was “good” that day, I can also remember times when I left disappointed for one reason or another. We’ve probably had similar experiences in church.

 

What struck me most, though, in Max’s statement, wasn’t the way I might be disappointed if the chain, or the church, doesn’t measure up to what I went there expecting. I mostly thought: 

 

“I want people to come to my church expecting more than they’d expect at Applebee’s!”

 

I said as much to Max. “Thinking of the church like a chain restaurant feels like a very low bar!” 

 

If we each made a list of the five best restaurants we’ve visited or the ones we’d choose for a special occasion if we could afford it, I’m guessing that our lists would not include many of our nearby chain restaurants.[2] Most of our lists would include higher-end restaurants that have wowed us if we’ve been lucky enough to experience that. There would be local standouts that have someone behind the scenes that gets called “Chef.” Our lists would reflect memories of times when menu and flavor and service came together to leave us enchanted.

 

My awareness of what’s possible in terms of culinary delight was heightened by The Bear, an FX series that airs on Hulu. Have you seen it? In this comedy-drama of a young chef inheriting his family’s Italian sandwich shop, we see glimpses of what’s possible in restaurants that earn Michelin stars.[3] What I saw there went way beyond anything I’ve known or could afford, but I did find it inspiring.[4]

 

These reflections, alongside my conversation with Max, made me wonder what it might look like for the local church to offer more of a “Michelin-star” experience, or at least for us to promise and deliver “something more” than people would expect of a run-of-the-mill visit to a typical chain restaurant. I’m asking this question because I don’t think the chain restaurant experience cuts it in a world where church attendance and religious practice have so significantly declined.[5] Not only that, but if the best we can offer is a chain-restaurant-level experience, I’m not sure we’re living up to the fullness of the God we’re here to worship and the gospel we’re gathering to proclaim.

 

So what would that look like? Wouldn’t it be cool if people walked out of worship saying, “Wow, my expectations were way too low!”?

 

In the context of a restaurant, that kind of response comes (in my experience, and my imagining) when there are:


Deeply personalized service. A server recently asked about us and then remembered and used our names while he tended to us. That felt amazing!
A surprising interplay of delightful ingredients and flavors.
An appealing space that conveys creativity, care, and/or comfort. 
Lusciously prepared food, with gradations like “rare” or “medium rare” that mean what they say, and with things like temperature, caramelization, seasoning and exquisitely achieved.
Consistency throughout the meal, from greeting to order-taking, to water-filling, to getting the check paid.

 

If I were to translate those qualities into the context of the church, I can imagine being delighted by:


Personalized attention at the right moments that doesn’t feel intrusive.
Elements in the liturgy, music, and/or preaching that connect to tradition and express something true that I haven’t heard put that way before.
A space that is generously welcoming and offers room or elements that help me think creatively about the day’s theme and/or about the God we worship.
Good, nourishing food for thought, spirituality, relationship, and/or putting my faith into action.

Those are the qualities that come to mind for me; yours are likely different in various ways. It’s worth considering these questions. What kind of expectations are we prepared to and able to meet, and what more might we aspire to do and be in the time we share with members and guests? Let’s not assume we’re only talking about Sunday morning attractional worship, either. What about our outreach, our missions, our connections within our communities, and our work toward justice and equity? In what ways might our presence—yours and mine—in all the spaces where we’re found bring unexpected delight and meaning to others, in the name and for the love of Jesus Christ?

 

Thanks, Max, for drawing this fertile connection to the comfort people might find in what we offer, as well as its capacity to help us think more deeply about the more that is possible when expectations are exceeded. Even our expectations, about what is possible. May it be so.

 

[1] Church websites greatly increase every visitor’s ability to choose the ones to enter that will most closely fit their expectations and hopes in terms of music, liturgy, theology, and more.

[2] I’m saying this mindful that my comments here almost certainly sound elitist and arrogant. I know many of us have had good and fun experiences at chain restaurants; I have, too! Please don’t read my comments here as a belittling of those memories.

[3] There are no Michelin-star restaurants in Iowa. https://guide.michelin.com/us/en/restaurants

[4] A similar portrayal happens in the 2022 film The Menu, at least until it turns horrifying.

 

Dining and Cooking