What Role Could the Food Pantry System Play in Reducing Poverty and its Severity?
New Yorkers who use food pantries often turn to free food providers to fill food gaps that they are unable to meet otherwise in budgets already stretched thin. We examine how much food pantries are helping families financially by valuing the food they receive from free food providers and adding the value of the meals they received to their family financial resources. We treat this value like other food-related assistance such as SNAP, as free food assistance provides direct resources to families that we can quantify. Considering the value of the food families receive as a supplementary financial resource, we recalculate poverty to analyze the anti-poverty effects of current food pantry use in New York City.
How are the meals that families in New York City receive from the food pantry system valued?
To calculate the monetary value of food accessed through the pantry system, we use data from Feeding America, which provides borough-level price estimates of the cost of an average food pantry meal, and which establishes that a standard food pantry meal distribution typically includes 9 meals per person in the family.
We calculate the total number of meals a family receives by first multiplying the number of people in the family by the number of meals allotted to each family member in a standard food pantry distribution. This provides the number of meals a household is expected to receive during a food pantry visit. We then take the family’s frequency of food pantry use, convert it to weeks, and multiply the number of meals by the number of weeks to obtain the total number of meals the family receives (or would be projected to receive) across the 12-month reference period.
Finally, we calculate the average cost of a food pantry meal across the five boroughs and multiply the total number of meals received by this amount to obtain the total monetary value of the food pantry meals. With this monetary value in hand, we add the value of pantry use to each family’s total financial resources and then recalculate poverty and the poverty shortfall.
What is the Povery Shortfall?
The poverty shortfall, sometimes referred to as the poverty gap, is the total amount of resources required to lift everyone living in poverty out of poverty. This amount is estimated by calculating the gap between the family resources of a family living in poverty and the poverty threshold for that family. The amount by which a family’s resources fall below the poverty threshold can be summed across all families living in poverty in New York City to estimate the total amount of resources it would require to lift this population up to the poverty line.
We then explore the potential anti-poverty effects of food pantries if they were more widely used in New York City under three different simulated scenarios:
Simulation 1: The first simulation models weekly use by all current food pantry users.
Simulation 2: The second simulation builds on this and models weekly use by current food pantry users and by New Yorkers experiencing severe food hardship.
Simulation 3: The third simulation further expands food pantry use and models weekly pantry use by current pantry users and by New Yorkers experiencing any type of food hardship, or those who sometimes or often run out of food or worry about running out of food before having enough money to buy more.
We note that this exercise is a thought experiment to better understand the potential of and limits to the free food assistance system in the city in the wake of major cuts to the SNAP program and other policies that New Yorkers benefit from to make ends meet. More frequent pantry use would depend on the system, which is already financially strained, having the backing required to fill this need, and even with additional resources it is always best seen as a complement rather than a substitute for public food assistance.
In an average year from 2022 to 2024, a quarter of New Yorkers were living in poverty (24.7%). If we put a monetary value on the free food assistance that New Yorkers currently report receiving, we see a small reduction in the poverty rate to 24.1%, indicating that the pantry system at current capacity lifts about 51,000 New Yorkers out of poverty and reduces the poverty rate by about 2% (Table 2). The poverty shortfall is also reduced by about 2%, defined as the percent of the total dollars necessary to lift all New Yorkers out of poverty in a given year.

Source: Findings drawn from Poverty Tracker data collected from the second, third, fourth, fifth, and sixth cohorts.
We proceed to simulate how increased pantry usage would change the poverty rate and poverty shortfall in the city. In the first simulated scenario, we modify usage so that all current food pantry users receive food weekly. This results in an increase in the anti-poverty potential of food pantries, reducing poverty by 6% (to 23.2%). The poverty shortfall would also be reduced by nearly 6%.
In the last two scenarios we simulate expanded food pantry use by those who experience food hardship but aren’t currently utilizing free food assistance. We run these simulations to illustrate how much antipoverty impact could be generated from free food assistance. It is important to note that these simulated increases in utilization would require the system to be adequately resourced to accommodate increased demand. Rather than representing an ideal scenario for pantry use, we argue that the results provide a ceiling for what can be expected from the city’s free food system given the impending (and occurring) cuts to government food assistance.
If all current pantry users tapped the pantry system weekly, alongside current non-users who experience food hardship, we estimate that the poverty rate could fall to as low as 21.2%, filling about 15% of the overall poverty shortfall in the city. Such increased participation and utilization levels would require new resources injected into an already strapped food delivery system. So while there is power to reduce the poverty shortfall in the city more through increased food provision, and this remains a worthy goal, the pantry system should not be thought of as a substitute for the support provided through major government programs like SNAP. Nevertheless, the system does reduce the city’s poverty shortfall and remains an important complement to government food assistance.

Dining and Cooking