LITTLE ROCK, Ark. (KATV) — Nancie Givens, the former executive director of the Arkansas Supreme Court’s Office of Professional Programs, was arrested and charged with 65 felonies earlier this month for allegedly tampering with bar exam scores over five years, potentially failing test takers who would have otherwise passed and passing individuals who failed.
RELATED | Former Arkansas bar exam official charged with 65 felonies in alleged score tampering
An attorney told KATV he believes he was one of Givens’ victims and that she actively prevented him from passing or even taking the bar exam.
Attorney Matthew Draper said he tried to pass the Arkansas bar for eight years, sitting for the exam about eight times and being told by Givens that he failed every attempt. But as soon as he moved to Mississippi, he passed the bar there on the first try.
Right from the beginning, Draper said it felt like Givens was making it difficult for him to even sit for the exam.
“Every time I turned something in this lady’s email and me telling me they’re not getting it and it’s this lady, Nancie Givens and she’s saying like, ‘Hey, your application’s missing this’ or ‘it’s missing that.’ And I’m like, ‘okay, well I sent it in. I’ll send it in again.’ She would find things wrong with them…And every time you apply, you have to pay an application fee. You don’t get that fee back,” Draper said.
When Draper was finally allowed to take the bar exam, he said Givens made him sign an unusual acknowledgment form making him agree that if he passed the bar exam, he would not necessarily be admitted to the bar and his name would not appear on the publicized list of test takers who passed. Instead, Givens would personally email him to let him know if he passed and what his score was.
“I had to sign one of these every time I took the bar exam all the way up until 2020,” Draper told KATV.
Draper said Givens never actually emailed him his scores.
“The emails she would send me would tell me I didn’t pass. And she would say my scores… my scores would be in the mail, but I never actually received those scores in the mail,” Draper said.
Self-doubt and pressure to provide for his family grew after each apparent exam failure, and Draper nearly gave up on practicing law.
After seeing Givens’ arrest for tampering with bar exam scores, Draper said he felt vindicated.
“All those years, I felt like in my gut that something was going on…going in there when when your wife’s got a kid on the way, and you know, you’re like, okay, I have to get this done this time. Like, I’m not going to be able to provide for us unless I make this happen. And all the time I put into like studying and just to in my mind, fall short, doubt myself…And it’s a… it’s nice to feel vindicated,” Draper said.
The charges Givens faces span the years between 2020 and 2025, but because of his experience, Draper believes her alleged score tampering was more extensive than that.
Draper questioned how Givens was able to get away with her alleged crimes for so long at the Supreme Court’s Office of Professional Programs and as secretary of the State Board of Law Examiners.
“If one person was able to even do something like this to this magnitude, or just even for the magnitude they’re claiming she did it…that’s a lack of checks and balances right there. I mean, that kind of just looks like somebody else was either not paying attention and there should have been… a better system to where this couldn’t have been able to happen,” Draper said.
Draper said he is considering filing a lawsuit against Givens and arranged to speak with Little Rock attorneys today. He also hopes to share his story with prosecutors in Givens’ case.

Dining and Cooking