Mashed potatoes are beloved for many reasons. They’re soft, buttery, and simple enough to pair with just about any protein or roasted vegetable — especially on Thanksgiving.

“With all of the other dishes, sometimes having something that gently hums in the background versus trying to be the lead singer is most welcome,” says 2015 F&W Best New Chef Zoi Antonitsas, a culinary consultant based in Portland, Oregon.

Even if mashed potatoes are designed to be a supporting character, that doesn’t mean they have to be boring. Here are six chef-approved upgrades to consider for a restaurant-quality mash.

Forgo the boil

While most mashed potato recipes start with boiling peeled potatoes on a stovetop, Ron Hsu, chef-owner of Lazy Betty in Atlanta, takes a different approach. He adds the potatoes to a Dutch oven, along with milk, cream, butter, and roasted garlic, then places the pot in a 350°F oven. “I keep it covered in the oven so that the potatoes steam,” he says. “With this method, you’re not losing any potato flavor to the water, and it yields a fluffier mash since you retain all the starch in the Dutch oven.”

Don’t overcook the potatoes

Whether you’re boiling or steaming your potatoes, it’s important that you don’t overcook them. “Overcooked potatoes can become waterlogged, which ultimately affects the texture,” says Tanner Marino, executive chef of Table 301 restaurant group in Greenville, South Carolina. Cook your potatoes just until they become fork-tender — you should be able to slide a fork into the center with no resistance.

Credit: jgareri / Getty Images

Credit: jgareri / Getty Images

Use a potato ricer

Instead of using a masher or electric mixer, Marino opts for a ricer, a gadget that presses potatoes through small holes, resulting in a silkier, smoother mash. “I rice [the potatoes] while they’re still hot and incorporate the remaining ingredients by hand,” he says. “Overmixing can break down the potatoes too much, releasing excess starch and leaving you with a gummy texture.”

Related: This Tool is the Secret to the Smoothest Mashed Potatoes (and It’s Not a Masher)

Heat your cream

“My number one tip for upgrading mashed sweet potatoes is to warm the heavy cream and butter,” says Adam Markowitz, executive chef of Beach House Hilton Head Island resort in South Carolina. “It’ll allow the potatoes to remain hot and make for a creamier and smoother texture.”

2026 F&W Best New Chef Melissa López, owner of Barra Santos in Los Angeles, likes to steep aromatics like garlic, thyme, and bay leaves into the cream. “I keep it on very low heat to infuse the cream, and then strain it into the cooked and drained potatoes,” she says.

And, according to 2026 F&W Best New Chef Lucas McKinney, owner of Josephine’s in Houston, there are many other ingredients you can incorporate into your cream. “You can add shallots, chile flakes, black pepper, lemon zest — whatever you want to infuse the cream with.”

Always include garlic

Nearly every chef we reached out to uses garlic in their mashed potato recipe. “The only and best upgrade for mashed potatoes is to add tons of garlic,” says Jacob Dela Cruz, executive chef and cofounder of Bobo in Chicago. Whether you steep it into the cream or press roasted cloves into the mash, garlic brings in a gentle layer of savoriness.

Related: Garlic-and-Herb Mashed Potatoes

Credit: Audrey Patsiga / Getty Images

Credit: Audrey Patsiga / Getty Images

Finish with olive oil

Antonitsas keeps her mashed potato formula fairly simple: boiled russet potatoes with salt, pepper, and lots of butter. But right before serving, she drizzles the mash with one final ingredient. “I like to add some good-quality olive oil for a pop of freshness and subtle spice,” she says. And if there’s gravy on the dinner table, she’ll add that, too. “Amazing gravy is key to the whole meal, in my opinion.”

Read the original article on Food & Wine

Dining and Cooking