I’m trying to figure out my box for next week and, while this one always piqued my interest, I’ve been nervous to try it. Is it bland or super good??

by venusdemillie

26 Comments

  1. chrissycatt9000

    I’ve always liked their shepherds pie recipes but I’ve always thought they never include enough mushrooms

  2. Wonderful-Pride1984

    I think I’m skipping this one and gonna try the Pub Style Shepards Pie the week after next. That one looked more appealing to us because it had more meat and veggies. 

  3. wheaten_lover

    I can’t stand this one. The flavors are way too intense, in a bad way.

  4. The Pub Style Shepherd’s Pie is much better (and probably my favorite HF meal), but this one is also decent.

  5. Ok-Fee1566

    This is always added. But we add ground meat and skip the mushrooms. I really just make this for my husband. He loves it.

  6. Wonderful-Pride1984

    I’m picking the Mushroom + Mozzarella Hogies under veggie meals for next week. I heard those are good. 

  7. petsbetterthanpeople

    I love this one! I adapted my own lazy recipe for it with trader joes ingredients, for when I don’t have a lot of prep time:
    1 pack pre-sliced mushrooms
    1 container pre-chopped mirepoix (carrots, onion, celery)
    Cheese of choice (I like sharp white cheddar)
    Vegetable stock/broth (however much water you would add to the concentrate, use that much veggie broth instead)
    Frozen pre-made mashed potatoes
    The flour and spices I already have at home
    Like $20 and feeds 4 people

  8. Albaloca

    Yes I love!! They also made a vegan version with white beans that I’ve only seen once. I do like the idea of a bean or lentil in it to add protein but yes this is delish

  9. FutureElleWoods20

    It’s our favorite hello fresh dish!! We even make it on our own!😋😋

  10. thepainneverleft

    That sounds delicious. Gonna add that to my first order if possible.

  11. Hazellin313

    This is one of my all time faves but I don’t eat meat

  12. SanJacInTheBox

    I’ve made it twice. Very tasty, however the second time I added 12oz of ground beef to the mushroom mix.

  13. InYourBungHolio

    I love their vegetarian shepards pie. My sister regularly asks me for the recipe card to make it herself.

  14. ardxabsence

    I like this one better than the pub style. (and the pub style is delicious too) I always order this one when it comes up- one time my sister in laws & their boyfriends showed up to my place with no warning so I whipped this up and served it to everyone and it was a HIT!

  15. sniffleprickles

    It’s been a while since we made this one, but my family liked it a lot. It’s one where we kept the recipe card, but I haven’t made it again yet.

  16. Sad-Assumption-1800

    This is one of my favorite recipes.

  17. bodycounters

    I ordered this accidentally once thinking it was beef, but I really enjoyed it anyway

Write A Comment