having been born in the 90’s and growing up in the 00’s I can assure you this was never a thing
metaltastic
Just go to jail
You know what you did
KingFernando532
Well they put it on burgers too lol
MidnighT0k3r
I’ve seen some shit [my childhood friend dipped pizza in chocolate milk]… but this ain’t it. This was never a thing.
matt7259
Born in 1990 and my friends and I did this in high school. Maybe it’s a regional thing? Also – it wasn’t half bad! But maybe it’s telling that I haven’t tried this again in… 15+ years?
VirtualAnalysisLine
Is… is that peanut butter?
99Reasons_why
No it’s not, I’ve never heard of anyone doing that. Maybe it was a thing for that person in that time frame but nobody I’ve known has ever done that.
SignalCommittee4456
This is a war crime
tonyhasareddit
Nope lol
Confident-Appeal9407
Nope. Maybe at the local pizza shop where that OP lived or just at their home.
razorduc
No….
manuca1990
Nut cream? 😔🤮🤮🤮🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮
Nobodiisdamnbusiness
This is what Sin looks like folks.
Born in 88, never seen this before.
Inkl1ng6
Eww no
gloomflume
no it isn’t.
Oxideusj
Zenzitaro
This is not a thing then or ever
Not_So_Busy_Bee
Is that peppercorn sauce?
STL_TRPN
Native New Yorker here.
Never would I do this to a proper slice.
The_Arsonist1324
NSFW
jlv287
Ohh nah, you mean to tell me you don’t know about that??
STL_TRPN
I’ve seen slices with mashed potatoes on it. Won’t try those either.
FabulousBadonkey
It’s delicious especially with left over pepperoni pizza that’s been microwaved with wet tissue (this makes the dough soft).
Hamilton-Beckett
Maybe if you’re a ninja turtle…
derLeisemitderLaute
who puked on the pizza?!
nimbusyosh
It’s only a 90s thing if you count the Ninja turtles, and the fact that their running gag was putting the most disrespectful toppings on pizza. The only time I’ve EVER heard of peanut butter on pizza was from Michelangelo.
tacitjane
This conjures up thoughts of Doug Funny dipping his banana in tomato sauce. Two of my least favorite foods.
Now that I type it out, hmm, was Nickelodeon fucking with us with that too? I’m questioning everything now.
28 Comments
It’s definitely not lol
having been born in the 90’s and growing up in the 00’s I can assure you this was never a thing
Just go to jail
You know what you did
Well they put it on burgers too lol
I’ve seen some shit [my childhood friend dipped pizza in chocolate milk]… but this ain’t it. This was never a thing.
Born in 1990 and my friends and I did this in high school. Maybe it’s a regional thing? Also – it wasn’t half bad! But maybe it’s telling that I haven’t tried this again in… 15+ years?
Is… is that peanut butter?
No it’s not, I’ve never heard of anyone doing that. Maybe it was a thing for that person in that time frame but nobody I’ve known has ever done that.
This is a war crime
Nope lol
Nope. Maybe at the local pizza shop where that OP lived or just at their home.
No….
Nut cream? 😔🤮🤮🤮🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮
This is what Sin looks like folks.
Born in 88, never seen this before.
Eww no
no it isn’t.
This is not a thing then or ever
Is that peppercorn sauce?
Native New Yorker here.
Never would I do this to a proper slice.
NSFW
Ohh nah, you mean to tell me you don’t know about that??
I’ve seen slices with mashed potatoes on it. Won’t try those either.
It’s delicious especially with left over pepperoni pizza that’s been microwaved with wet tissue (this makes the dough soft).
Maybe if you’re a ninja turtle…
who puked on the pizza?!
It’s only a 90s thing if you count the Ninja turtles, and the fact that their running gag was putting the most disrespectful toppings on pizza. The only time I’ve EVER heard of peanut butter on pizza was from Michelangelo.
This conjures up thoughts of Doug Funny dipping his banana in tomato sauce. Two of my least favorite foods.
Now that I type it out, hmm, was Nickelodeon fucking with us with that too? I’m questioning everything now.