Is “Philly style” thin-sliced ribeye an acceptable alternative for an Italian Beef?
Is “Philly style” thin-sliced ribeye an acceptable alternative for an Italian Beef?
by VictorChaos
18 Comments
CrazySwayze82
I’ve actually got the Erie, PA version roasting right now. Up there they call it Ox Roast. I’m using a round roast though, not ribeye.
HeySlimIJustDrankA5
Survey says no.
WormBurnerUKV
The beef is not the issue here. Bread is bone dry. I know you plan on dipping it into that tiny bowl of au jus but that thing needs to be soaking brother.
Speedhabit
This is a fine meal that will piss off absolutely everyone on both sides
JiovanniTheGREAT
I would say this is much closer to an “Italian Philly” than it is to being a “Philly Italian”
jeexbit
Looks killer to me man.
HudsonCommodore
Dumb question: what’s the difference? (I equate an Italian Beef as a hot sliced beef sandwich with the pickled relish & au jus, all of which looks to be accounted for in the pic above.)
DrDeboGalaxy
No
JediSailor
You’ve killed a cheesesteak
BaileyJay-Z
This looks *kinda good* but you gotta make those vegetables smaller
BradMathews
YES. Also, what? But YES.
gonzotheape
Wait, is that cauliflower?!
Proud-Butterfly6622
It is neither you absolute, ignorant buffoon of a human! Take thee to a nunnery.
FiscallyImpared
Looks amazing – so long that you take it swimming
TheWalrus101123
Is that cauliflower?
MopingAppraiser
No and fuck off. There’s the cheesesteak. End of subject!
reese81944
Please keep my city’s name out your title
AmosRid
This is the sandwich you get when you order a cheese steak or an Italian beef and they do it wrong and it is triggering.
OTOH if it were called a French dip or just beef sandwich everyone would be happy.
AFAICT French dip means it is beef and you get a bowl of wet stuff nearby. There are not other critical ingredients.
18 Comments
I’ve actually got the Erie, PA version roasting right now. Up there they call it Ox Roast. I’m using a round roast though, not ribeye.
Survey says no.
The beef is not the issue here. Bread is bone dry. I know you plan on dipping it into that tiny bowl of au jus but that thing needs to be soaking brother.
This is a fine meal that will piss off absolutely everyone on both sides
I would say this is much closer to an “Italian Philly” than it is to being a “Philly Italian”
Looks killer to me man.
Dumb question: what’s the difference? (I equate an Italian Beef as a hot sliced beef sandwich with the pickled relish & au jus, all of which looks to be accounted for in the pic above.)
No
You’ve killed a cheesesteak
This looks *kinda good* but you gotta make those vegetables smaller
YES. Also, what? But YES.
Wait, is that cauliflower?!
It is neither you absolute, ignorant buffoon of a human! Take thee to a nunnery.
Looks amazing – so long that you take it swimming
Is that cauliflower?
No and fuck off. There’s the cheesesteak. End of subject!
Please keep my city’s name out your title
This is the sandwich you get when you order a cheese steak or an Italian beef and they do it wrong and it is triggering.
OTOH if it were called a French dip or just beef sandwich everyone would be happy.
AFAICT French dip means it is beef and you get a bowl of wet stuff nearby. There are not other critical ingredients.