When people ask you mayo or butter: what do you say? (We may be team both.)
When people ask you mayo or butter: what do you say? (We may be team both.)
by delish
32 Comments
JustAGirl319
🧈
Aggravating-Fee-1615
Yes.
Space_Goblin_Yoda
I used mayo for a few months but found it to be too salty. Personal preference, butter is my choice.
But that spicy Chipotle mayo was goooooooood.
discgolfandhash
Butter is the only way. The flavor of mayo will never be able to compete.
Quria
Butter is a far more neutral-forward flavor largely governed by salt content and overall quality, leaving far more room for the cheese and bread flavors to shine through.
Mayo, despite being a complex flavor, is one-note in the context of grilled cheese, as it gives everything that undeniable mayo taste.
shitshowsusan
Salted butter
riverotterr
How’s this even a debate if anyone saying mayo is getting downvoted to oblivion? I prefer mayo though but depends on the cheese being used. Mayo makes it “tangier” but butter is more neutral.
shallow-green
Butter all the way but I have nothing against ppl who use mayo
ResidentAlien518
Butter over mayo but either over no grilled cheese at all!
the_business007
Butter all day everyday
Oil-of-Vitriol
Salted butter. If it stops tasting like butter I don’t want any.
lord_of_the_eyebots
Yes
Discohurricane
Butter because I can’t have mayo in the first place. Also you can use flavored butters to match your cheese selection so that’s a bonus.
CrispyMemeMan
Butter is the only way
IllvesterTalone
margarine 😄
(cause I’m poor)
Any-Wall-5991
Mayo on bread very thin, butter in the pan. Tang and delicious butter goodness
Jackong43
I switched to mayo and don’t notice a difference in taste ?
DrZurn
Butter or if I’m feeling feisty Bacon Fat.
bhay105
If it weren’t for this sub, I wouldn’t even know mayo was an option. Been eating grilled cheeses my whole life and I have never seen or heard anyone talk about using mayo instead of butter.
KvasirMeadman
Garlic spread.
ne999
Garlic butter!
sellardoore
Mayo is easier if you refrigerate your butter (like many in the U.S. do), especially if you have kids and are trying to make lunch quickly. But butter tastes way, way better.
lazercheesecake
That’s like asking cheddar or Muenster. It’s whatever I feel like that day. Sometimes if I’m feeling a froggy I’ll use my garlic herb tallow for my grilled cheezy
glassjaw2214
Show me a chef who would use mayo over butter.
ShitInMyToaster
People use mayo?
freneticboarder
Parmesan crust… because why use butter or mayo, when you can add…
# moar cheese
Yatsugami
I like both
ChannelShark
Why not both! Butter one side, mayo on the other
Noturgoto4likes
Both , butter on the outside, mayo and tomato and cheese on the inside.
Z80a
There is no need to “settle” a “debate” over a personal preference. Grilled cheese, however you like it, for the win!
Jakkerak
Jeveran
Of those two, butter. Given broader choices, though, I prefer rendered duck fat.
32 Comments
🧈
Yes.
I used mayo for a few months but found it to be too salty. Personal preference, butter is my choice.
But that spicy Chipotle mayo was goooooooood.
Butter is the only way. The flavor of mayo will never be able to compete.
Butter is a far more neutral-forward flavor largely governed by salt content and overall quality, leaving far more room for the cheese and bread flavors to shine through.
Mayo, despite being a complex flavor, is one-note in the context of grilled cheese, as it gives everything that undeniable mayo taste.
Salted butter
How’s this even a debate if anyone saying mayo is getting downvoted to oblivion?
I prefer mayo though but depends on the cheese being used. Mayo makes it “tangier” but butter is more neutral.
Butter all the way but I have nothing against ppl who use mayo
Butter over mayo but either over no grilled cheese at all!
Butter all day everyday
Salted butter. If it stops tasting like butter I don’t want any.
Yes
Butter because I can’t have mayo in the first place. Also you can use flavored butters to match your cheese selection so that’s a bonus.
Butter is the only way
margarine 😄
(cause I’m poor)
Mayo on bread very thin, butter in the pan. Tang and delicious butter goodness
I switched to mayo and don’t notice a difference in taste ?
Butter or if I’m feeling feisty Bacon Fat.
If it weren’t for this sub, I wouldn’t even know mayo was an option. Been eating grilled cheeses my whole life and I have never seen or heard anyone talk about using mayo instead of butter.
Garlic spread.
Garlic butter!
Mayo is easier if you refrigerate your butter (like many in the U.S. do), especially if you have kids and are trying to make lunch quickly. But butter tastes way, way better.
That’s like asking cheddar or Muenster. It’s whatever I feel like that day. Sometimes if I’m feeling a froggy I’ll use my garlic herb tallow for my grilled cheezy
Show me a chef who would use mayo over butter.
People use mayo?
Parmesan crust… because why use butter or mayo, when you can add…
# moar cheese
I like both
Why not both! Butter one side, mayo on the other
Both , butter on the outside, mayo and tomato and cheese on the inside.
There is no need to “settle” a “debate” over a personal preference. Grilled cheese, however you like it, for the win!
Of those two, butter. Given broader choices, though, I prefer rendered duck fat.