Ages ago, my girlfriend went to house of pies and noticed there was a footnote “ you can add a slice of cheese to any pie”. Intrigued by this, she tried to do so. The staff acted like that was an absurd request and said they didn’t do that. She has been looking for a place that serves cheese on a pie ever since.
She is also not a fan of house of pies after that incident. Is there anywhere in LA that has this? I would like to surprise her soon with a date that has cheese pie.
by KMFDM__SUCKS
32 Comments
Apple pan
west hollywood barney’s beanery — it’s good
Moms in Julian. Thank me later.
Go to your favorite pie place and bring a slice of cheese
Maybe Pie N Burger
Funny seeing this, I was at Fishing with Dynamite yesterday and they serve Dutch Apple Pie with Cheddar Cheese Ice Cream.
What does this do to the flavor of the pie? I’ve never really understood the appeal
Maybe Marie Callandar’s?
I refuse to try things that I find categorically gross,
this is one of those things.
Johnny rockets used to have this, bit I haven’t been in a while, so i dont know for sure
Your gf isnt a fan of House of Pies because they refused to ruin their heavenly pies with an abhorrent use of American Cheese? Im with HOP on this one.
This is the Wisconsin way.
Norm’s will do it if you ask (at least they’ve done it before).
Apple pan is the only answer
Not a place rec, but if you ever get around to making it… grated cheddar cheese folded into the pie crust. You’re welcome.
I grew up with this in my pie
This is probably a lot further than you had in mind, but last time I tried to go apple picking I noticed “add cheese 75¢” on the menu at Los Rios Rancho in Oak Glen. It looks like they had a fire in 2020 that disrupted things and I don’t see it mentioned on their site: [https://losriosrancho.com/farm-store-and-kitchen](https://losriosrancho.com/farm-store-and-kitchen)
Marie Calendars napkins when I was growing up. “Apple pie without some cheese, is like a kiss without a squeeze.”
Apple Pan is the only way
My Dad used to eat apple pie with a slice of cheddar
had this at a cafe in Oak Glen, CA called Apple Annie’s. thought cheese on a pie looked insane until my uncle forced me to take a bite, shit is fire
Barney’s Beanery does it and Johnnie Rockets originally did
Paty’s in Toluca Lake
Apple Pan still does it. Never tried it but seen people order it.
Do people order w/cheese and vanilla ice cream or it’s one or the other?
How is it that so many people are replying with answers other than Apple Pan? How is that possible
Bake & Broil in LB, some of the best pies in SoCal
Astro Diner!!!
It really depends on the server in my experience but 90% of the time they know what’s up.
Apple pan… Johnny rockets
You can get it by the slice or the whole pie at Cake Monkey in Beverly Grove
Apple Pan
Pie n’ burger in Pasadena
someone can say something about this dish, should i try this?