What Would You Choose?

by Hordfest

30 Comments

  1. Smart_Piece_9832

    To crack the third one from the left over…your… head. Repeatedly.

  2. sdhiman33

    Maybe a touch biased but 21 Dominus is going to be fire in a few years. Should be a benchmark vintage for them

  3. The ones wrapped in white tissue paper are probably super exclusive.

  4. Raspberries-Are-Evil

    Im a partner with Hall- so Im biased but man that Kathryn Hall is STUNNING. Its a 99 point cab.

  5. So many are just so young. With quality wine just as these you really should let them develop for another 5-10yrs before thinking of opening them.

  6. nice--marmot

    I’ve had that 17 Roy; it’s fucking incredible. I’d do that again in a heartbeat. Second choice would probably be either the One Point Five or the Pahlmeyer. Is that Mt. Brave the Cab? I’m curious whether you’ve tasted that vintage. A few years ago a coworker gifted me a Mt. Brave Malbec that was leftover from a tasting. I can’t remember the vintage, it must have been 13, 14, 15, somewhere in there. It was the single most tannic wine I’ve ever tasted. Way more tannic than any Tannat I’ve tried. I double decanted that sucker and left the decanter open on the counter. I came back to it every day for four days and it barely budged. Anyway, I’d be interested to hear your thoughts. Cheers!

  7. Celeres517

    Probably the Pahlmeyer or the Kathryn Hall, but I’d bury them in my cellar for several years.

  8. coolcouchpotato

    i’ve recently had a mt brave 2015 cabernet franc, and it was incredible. all these wines are young though!

  9. Abject_Engine2150

    Dominus 2021 is gonna be a monster of a wine in a decade

  10. Yoshimadashi

    Out of the bunch? 2016 Opus by a large margin, but only if the price is comparable with the other Opus.

    The others are way too young to drink anytime soon, but all nice wines as well. If I were to buy these type of wines, I’d personally wait til the 2023 vintage to release as that’s been one of the most hyped up well received vintages in the past decade.

  11. Chose your bottle with the thought that it’s “prime window” for drinking might outlive you.

    Dominus. F the world.

  12. Thick_white_duke

    If you’re drinking now? The Hall. If you’re holding for 5-10? Dominus

  13. FieldOk6455

    Dominos, K. Hall, Opus, Shafer, you can’t go wrong.

Write A Comment