About a third of the way in this container and there is barely any peanut butter ribbons. I haven't bought Tillamook in a couple years, but last time I bought this flavor it was packed with peanut butter. What happened? Is this a one-off thing or have other people experienced the same? I'm probably done with Tillamook after this one.
by fishgats
17 Comments
It can be pretty random- some tubs have a huge glob of pb and a spoon won’t break it up, and some are chintzy on the pb. It’s always a crapshoot, but I’ll still eat it happily!
It’s just how this ice cream is. Tbh, it’s not Ben and Jerry’s and you’re not going to get that insane amount of mix-ins here. If that’s enough for you to decide the ice cream in general is bad, then you do you.
I bought one last weekend was impressed with the volume of swirl of real peanut butter.
This is my hang up with mixed flavors. Never seems to be the right ratio
I’m not a big fan of Tillamook. The ice cream itself is really good quality, but I’ve been cheated on the mixins more than once.
This is my go-to flavor and can confirm that it’s just so wildly inconsistent. Doesn’t stop me, I still love it and press on undeterred, but yeah. Luckily I like the plain chocolate well enough, but when you get a stacked one, life is good! (How do they get the peanut butter so salty? Why can’t I just buy it separately? Is there anything better then getting one with that, like, giant plug of PB at the bottom?)
I like Hagen Daaz for this combo. They usually have a good peanut butter core to ice cream ratio and it’s pretty consistent across batches
Wack. Don’t forget, Oregon isn’t even that great.
It’s cos Tillamook suuuuuucks
For all the hype this sub gives Tillamook, I think it’s one of the worst ice creams around. Your experience is typical from my perspective.
ive had this experience with tillamook several times, to the point i’ve stopped buying. it’s 7-9 dollars in my area not worth it, imo.
Best peanut butter chocolate ice cream is Haagen Dazs hands down. Tastiest and it has only like 5-6 ingredients. Check out the ingredients in the Tillamook…
Peanut butter ice cream with fudge swirls is the correct way.
I bought mint chocolate chip that barely had any chocolate in it, and then I bought one a few weeks later that had waaaay too many chocolate chips in it.
Their quality control is not great.
Save the code on the bottom with a pic and reach out to Tillamook customer service. They can comp you a coupon for free item
Maybe the peanutbutter dispenser was near empty at your tub.
Sometimes I get a ton.
I had the same experience all three times I tried Tillamook. It’s gummy as hell and almost completely devoid of inclusions and variegates. Fat content and overrun might technically qualify it as premium, but it’s just not a quality product.