I am now very curious if my bottle of Elijah’s Extreme Regret was in fact a dud. How common are dud bottles in your experience? I would buy it again either way because I like the flavor, but I have frequently heard it referred to as the hottest non-extract sauce, and it find that it surpassed Peppers Up either.
by AccomplishedNeck961
5 Comments
What? It’s not hotter than the Peppers Up. I have both, it’s not hotter.
Xtreme regret is twice as hot as Tabasco scorpion to me. Is your bottle like super old or something?
I’d expect both Extreme Regret and Peppers Up to be hotter. Tabasco Scorpion is hot but it’s well short of super hot territory IMO.
Tabasco *
I don’t have experience with super-hots, but Encona produce *a lot* of dud bottles. However, I wouldn’t say that they’re less spicy, they just don’t taste as good. With the Original flavor, there are two batches that are dramatically different in appearance and taste, the ones where the sauce looks bright orange are much, much nicer than the ones where the sauce appears slightly brown