What Thanksgiving Day table would be complete without a golden browned turkey, dressing, potatoes and cranberries? Don’t forget the perfect ending for this annual feast — pie! Whether you prefer traditional favorites like apple, pumpkin or mincemeat, or are looking for a creative alternative to the time-honored favorites, bakeries across Wisconsin have the perfect pie for your gathering.
Check out these scratch bakeries across Wisconsin for the ultimate Thanksgiving Day pie. Be sure to put in your order as soon as possible.
Where to find pies in Milwaukee and its suburbs
Honeypie Café, 2569 S. Kinnickinnic Ave., Milwaukee, 414-242-6389
Although Honeypie Café has a full menu, its calling card is its bakery’s pie. Customers can order pies year-round through its website. Pre-orders can also be place online for six seasonally flavored Thanksgiving pies, with pick-up at Honeypie’s sister location, Palomino, 2491 S. Superior St. Pickup times can be selected online.
Mama Ducky’s Desserts, 290 W. Main St., Waukesha, 414-949-0222
With over a dozen pies to choose from, Mama Ducky’s Desserts in Waukesha is ready to provide dessert for your Thanksgiving Day table. Owner Melissa Lugo prides herself on using family favorite recipes reminiscent of grandma’s creations including cream and fruit pies. She recommends customers pre-order their Thanksgiving pies before the end of the day on Nov. 24, as it’s only making a limited amount of pie. Pies can be picked up on Nov. 26 and 27.
Aggie’s Bakery, 7328 W. Greenfield Ave., West Allis, 414-482-1288, aggiesbakery.com
Aggie’s offers a wide variety of pies, from classic pumpkin, pecan and apple to cherry, blueberry, peach and more. All pies require a minimum of at least 48 hours notice for pick-up through Nov. 22. Pies ordered online for Thanksgiving Day can be picked up Nov. 26 and 27.
The Bake Sale, 6923 W. Becher St., West Allis, 414-543-4230
This West Allis bakery has a reputation for creating memorable pie varieties. From Pumpkin Gingersnap and Whiskey Chocolate Pecan to Caramel Apple and Double Chocolate French Silk. Gluten-free pie varieties are also available. Online and phone orders will be taken through Nov. 22. Pickup is set for Nov. 26 and 27.
Black Shoe Bakery, Blue’s Egg Milwaukee, 317 N. 76th St., Milwaukee, 414-336-1005
Black Shoe Bakery wears many hats, creating desserts and baked goods for sister businesses Maxie’s, Blue’s Egg, Story Hill BKC and Black Shoe Catering. Orders can be placed online through Nov. 22 for Dutch apple, bourbon pecan, pumpkin, salted brown butter, French silk, and key lime pies. Orders can be picked up on Nov. 27 on the south end of the Blue’s Egg parking lot, 317 N. 76th St., Milwaukee.
Miss Molly’s Cafe & Pastry Shop, 9201 W. Center St., Milwaukee, 414-249-5665
Looking for unusual pies for your holiday gathering? Among pies offered by Miss Molly’s for Thanksgiving Day pre-order are a pumpkin pie with spiced chai whipped cream or a caramelized pear and walnut galette. Pick-up is Nov. 23 at Sully’s Sandwiches, 9211 W. Center St. (next door to Miss Molly’s).
MOR Bakery, 2018 S. First St., Milwaukee, 414-249-3316, morfoodsmke.com
Along with traditional favorites, MOR Bakery, a small, local, woman-owned business, will offer several varieties of vegan and gluten-free pies for Thanksgiving. Online orders will close on Nov. 21 at 7 p.m. with pickup scheduled for Nov. 26 and 27 at MOR Bakehouse, 5504 W State St., Milwaukee.
Mr. Dye’s Pies, 3rd Street Market Hall 275 W. Wisconsin Ave., Milwaukee, 414-759-4992
Mr. Dye’s Pies is currently taking orders for Thanksgiving pies including brandy old-fashioned cherry, Blueberry Hill, sweet potato, sweet potato with pecan topping, Purple Monster, N’Awlins Pecan and more. Pies can be ordered online or over the phone. Pick-up is at 3rd Street Market Hall on Nov. 27.
The Elegant Farmer, 1545 Main St., Mukwonago, 262-363-6770
Pie in a brown paper bag? The Elegant Farmer in Mukwonago has been baking apple pies in them for years. In addition to their famous apple pie, the bakery will be offering cranberry apple, cranberry walnut, pumpkin and cherry pies for Thanksgiving. The gourmet pies are available by visiting the farm kitchen bakery. The bakery will be closed Thanksgiving Day.
All In Favor, Say Pie, 502 Mandan Drive, Waukesha, 262-549-6377
Waukesha bakery All In Favor, Say Pie is dedicated to creating a variety of pies, including Dutch apple pie and apple cranberry pie. Unfortunately, the deadline for Thanksgiving orders has passed, but the Waukesha business sells custom-baked pies throughout the year, with in-season ingredients, and a crust that owner Jenny Danks takes immense pride in. Pies can be ordered online or by phone.
Where to find pies in Madison and its suburbs
Rolling Pin Bake Shop, 2935 S. Fish Hatchery Road, Unit 4, Fitchburg, 608-663-2690
Those eager to order a pie for Thanksgiving from the Rolling Pin Bake Shop should place their order at least a week before the holiday. The Fitchburg-based bakery has several pies that are always available and can be pre-ordered at any time and are ready to pick up within 48 hours. Pie pickup for Thanksgiving is Nov. 26 and 27 until 6 p.m.
Stella’s Bakery, 2908 Syene Road, Madison, 608-663-2690
Stella’s Bakery in Madison has a wide range of items that can be ordered for Thanksgiving, including four pie flavors: pumpkin, pecan, apple, and cherry. All of the bakery’s pies are made with Stella’s Bakery signature brown butter crust. Pre-ordered pies are available to be picked up Nov. 25, and pre-paid orders can be placed on the bakery’s website.
Batch Bakehouse, 1402 Williamson St., Madison, 608-257-1652
A word of warning to those looking forward to ordering a pie from Batch Bakehouse — order early before they sell out. This scratch bakery offers seven different varieties of pie including apple cinnamon streusel, dark chocolate bourbon pecan, cherry streusel and more. Preorder by Nov. 21 for pickup on Nov 27. Pies are available for pickup and delivery.
Norske Nook, 100 E. Holum St., DeForest, 608-842-3378
Norwegian food is Norske Nook’s niche. But pie lovers can attest that the restaurant is a go-to for pie lovers around the state. Pie aficionados can stop at one of the restaurant’s three locations for a fresh slice of pie any day. Customers can pick up a pie from the restaurant any day it’s open, however, the deadline for ordering Thanksgiving pies has passed.
Where to find pies in western Wisconsin
Sweet Beet Bakery, 137 S. Knowles Avenue, New Richmond, 715-246-9866
Sweet Beet Bakery takes pride in its ingredients, including its pie fillings, which are all locally sourced. The bakery has eight varieties of pies available for Thanksgiving, including vegan and gluten-free options. Preorder by Nov. 21 for pickup on Nov 27.
Stockholm Pie & General Store, N2030 Spring St., Stockholm, 715-442-5505
Recognized as the top-ranked pie shop in USA TODAY’S Reader’s Choice Awards, Stockholm Pie & General Store, in the village of Stockholm in Pepin County, is a go-to for pie connoisseurs. This family-owned business will take orders for 12 different varieties of pie for Thanksgiving up until Nov. 20. Pies can be picked up by 4 p.m. on Nov. 27. Orders of more than six pies must be called in. Can’t make it over to Stockholm Pie & General Store? The business offers whole-pie shipping within the continental United States.
Norske Nook, 13804 W. Seventh St., Osseo, 715-597-3069
Norwegian food is Norske Nook’s niche. But pie lovers can attest that the restaurant is a go-to for pie lovers around the state. Pie aficionados can stop at one of the restaurant’s three locations for a fresh slice of pie any day. Customers can pick up a pie from the restaurant any day it’s open, however, the deadline for ordering Thanksgiving pies has passed.
Where to find pies in northwest Wisconsin
Alicia’s Baked Goods, 2431 Greenfield Road, Spooner, 715-416-5252
Looking for a pie beyond the traditional apple and pumpkin variety? At Alicia’s Baked Goods in Spooner, you can order something a bit more unique: a bumbleberry pie made with a blend of blackberries, blueberries and raspberries. The cut-off for ordering pies for Thanksgiving is Nov. 21. Pickup dates for orders is Nov. 26 and 27. Orders can be placed over the phone.
Laura’s Bake Shop and Café, 237 Walnut St., Spooner, 715-416-0722
In the little community of Spooner, located in the heart of Washburn County, Laura’s Bake Shop and Café is big on offering customers a wide array of bakery goods including fruit pies and Laura’s banana cream pie and coconut cream pie. And if that wasn’t enough she serves up strawberry, pineapple, blueberry and lemon cheesecake. “Whatever you want, I’ll make it”, is her motto. Call or order online two days before order pickup for the week of Thanksgiving.
Where to find pies in southwest Wisconsin
Crystal Cafe, 126 N. Main St., Iola, 715-445-9227
Last year, Crystal Cafe sold 74,271 slices of pie, cementing its catchphrase of “Pies 2 Die 4”. This third-generation Waupaca County family restaurant is known for hand-rolled pie crusts filled with all-natural ingredients. You can stop in any day for a slice of pie, but customers wanting one of 10 varieties of pie for Thanksgiving need to pre-order by Nov. 24. Pick-up is slated for Nov. 27. Take-and-bake apple pies are also available.
Oakwood Fruit Farm, 31128 Apple Ridge Road, Richland Center, 608-585-2701
Nestled in the hills of southwest Wisconsin, the Oakwood Fruit Farm apple orchard has been a family tradition for five generations. Pre-orders for Apple, blueberry and cherry pies are due by Nov. 20 with pickup set for Nov. 27. Take-and-bake pies are also available. Orders can be placed online.
Omega Bakery, 103 State St. Suite 101, Holmen, 608-373-4890
Although the date for pre-ordering pies for Thanksgiving has passed, Omega Bakery is open for business Monday through Wednesday, Friday and Saturday during the holiday week. A trip to this village of Holmen bakery in La Crosse County is worth the trip for its extensive offering of baked goods, including 18 varieties of pie — fruit, cream, silk and meringue. While the bakery does not take calls, customers can visit the website or stop in.
Where to find pies in central Wisconsin
Misty’s Menu, 9041 State 13 St., Saratoga, 715-325-2330
Misty’s Menu, a cozy diner in Saratoga is known for its comfort food and pie. Owners Brian and Misty Nelson produce more than 100 pies to fill Thanksgiving orders. This year, customers can choose from apple, cherry, pecan banana or coconut cream pies. Call to order now for pickup on Nov. 27.
Blue Willow Café, 1111 N. Fourth Ave., Wausau, 715-675-4543
Located on the west side of Wausau, the Blue Willow Café has a plethora of pies to satisfy anyone’s craving including its decadent coconut cream pie. Varieties available for Thanksgiving preorder include pumpkin, apple, meringue, coconut cream and cherry. Orders should be called in by Nov. 26 with pickup on Nov. 27. A pie pan deposit is included in the price.
Where to find pies in northeastern Wisconsin
Nicolet Restaurant, 525 Reid St., De Pere 920-336-8726
Those who have visited Nicolet Restaurant in De Pere will swear by the lemon meringue pie on the menu which includes coconut cream and banana cream pies. After having a slice of pie, why not purchase a take-and-bake apple or pumpkin pie to bring home for Thanksgiving?
La Sure’s Cakes and Café, 3125 S Washburn St., Oshkosh, 920-231-5227
La Sure’s Cakes and Café has built its reputation on elegantly decorated cakes. They’ve created over a million cakes since the business opened in 1974. Less known but just as delicious are the bakery’s pies with crusts made with real lard to make them both flaky and savory. Pumpkin, apple, Dutch apple, meringue, coconut cream and cherry pies can be ordered before Nov. 26 for pickup on Nov. 27.
Manderfield’s Home Bakery, Appleton and Menasha
Manderfield’s Home Bakery invites you to step through the doors of its three locations to savor the aroma of a real hometown family bakery. The business boasts the largest selection of freshly baked products (including plenty of pie) in Wisconsin’s Fox Valley. Pies for pre-order include caramel apple, apple, mincemeat and pecan. Pies can be ordered online (by Nov. 23 for Thanksgiving) or by visiting any of the three locations: W3176 Springfield Drive, Appleton (east) 920-731-2181; 5100 W. Michaels Drive, Appleton (west) 920-882-6500; and 811 Plank Road, Menasha, 920-725-7794.
Johnston’s Bakery, 1227 Superior Ave., Sheboygan 920-458-3342
There’s a reason Johnston’s Bakery in Sheboygan has won Best Bakery in the Sheboygan Press reader’s choice awards for four consecutive years. Known as the home of the Sheboygan Hard Roll, the bakery also makes a pretty delicious pie. While the Dutch apple and pumpkin are fall favorites, the blueberry pie is a year-round standout. Cut off for pre-orders is Nov. 22 with pickup on Nov. 27. To order, call or visit the bakery.