I know I know. Caymus? We don’t do that here. 80’s Caymus, however, is not the same as modern Caymus. Randy Dunn was the mastermind of Caymus in the 80s, with this vintage actually being the first that he stepped away in a fully official capacity from the property. Tasting notes for both wines as follows:

2014 Domaine Leflaive Batard-Montrachet: where do I begin? A legendary vineyard and producer combination with a great white wine vintage to boot. I think the wine has started to come around nicely, with an excellent balance of fruit and slight funkiness starting to come in. Lemon curd, roasted yellow apples, Bosc pear, and hints of pineapple and guava meld perfectly with the white truffle and mineral character of the wine. The oak frames the wine well, adding subtle vanilla and baking spice notes that interplay nicely with toasted hazelnut. The real standout is the structure. Incredible persistence with a richness and creaminess that is perfectly offset by the acidity. Special wine.

1986 Caymus Special Selection: don’t ever let anyone tell you that Napa can’t age. Some of my favorite wines ever have been Napa Cabernet from the 70s and 80s. Still plenty of fruit, though the character was more dried. Cherry, blackberry liqueur, black cherry, and fruit leather are what comes to mind. There’s an earthiness to this wine, like fresh turned soil and roasted oyster mushrooms. Coffee, dark Chocolate, burnt cinnamon, and cigar box notes are very present. Elevated tannins are balanced by surprisingly present acidity. Once again, a finish that just doesn’t quit. I also had some 2001 Mouton at the same time, and was surprised to prefer the Caymus to the Bordeaux. If only they still made wines like this!

This was a great meal that was made better by the people I got to share it with. Wine is meant to be consumed and shared, so let this post be a reason to open that wine you’ve been holding onto!

by patton115

7 Comments

  1. Grenache-a-trois

    80s Napa is just spectacular. Great notes

  2. It’s crazy how much this subreddit loves to hate on Napa lol to the point of saying Napa can’t age. 

  3. Mtn_Drew3113

    One of the best bottles I’ve ever tasted was a 1980 Caymus Grace Family vineyard, when Grace Family was bottling at Caymus’s facility. A lot of people would pass over that bottle and not even think twice. I’ve got a 91 special select I’m saving for a rainy day in the near future. There’s a reason Caymus is what it is today. It started out as something very special. If you can find any 02 or 03 of regular Caymus or special select, I’d highly recommend picking them up. Truly awesome bottles. Kudos to you for recognizing how awesome these older wines are. Old Napa is one of my favorite things to drink. Beringer, Dominus, Colgin, Dalla Valle, Eisele. All these wines age gracefully.

  4. jollycreation

    If these pointless and hurtful tariffs keep up, I suspect people in this sub will be “forced” to deepen their exposure to Napa wines, and learn that some of their preconceived notions of this appellation are mistaken.

  5. alexx3064

    so 88 Caymus and older are the ones to go for?

Write A Comment