My parents brought a four pack of ribeyes from Costco – all different sizes. Managed to pull off a reverse sear and get them all to about the same cook – but would you say this is medium rare?
by Caewil
41 Comments
PipeSegovia2
It depends on taste, I like it that way.
GripLock11
That looks perfect medium rare for me!
aquaticgorilla123
Looks more like medium to me but still looks great!
Training-Till-7344
Light pink throughout with little to no blood/juice is perfectly medium actually, and it looks delicious!
FaawwQ
This is a perfect medium, said as someone who loves medium
Emergency_Ad1152
More medium but looks amazing.
KY_Fli-Guy
Camera shots can be deceiving. Looks closer to medium, but definitely a nice cook on them! Nice job!
Bsow
Looks like a perfect medium which is great for ribeye
opoeto
Looks closer to medium, but could well be the lighting. It’s very close. But I would say 100% would eat it. The only thing is none of them look like ribeyes though
Zhurg
Medium rare could be a brighter red but these still look good
timiwad1967
Medium.
cosmoswhisperer
yummmyyy
porkdozer
Depends on the final temperature, honestly.
Bananogram
Medium. This is how I prefer most steak cuts.
Tweecers
Perfect medium
MountainFace2774
It’s hard to gauge based on a photo. Depending on lighting and the camera, I can make the same steak look medium well or medium rare. Go by actual temp and taste moreso than look.
That being said, I’d eat the hell out of that! Looks delicious to me.
YerbaPanda
That’s a perfect medium. While I prefer medium rare, I would enjoy eating this medium as there is not too much gray band.
mxxxz
How did you cook it?
ArtWeingartner69
Yes, 9.3 would
ivegotafastcar
That is a medium. A yummy juicy medium.
bstsms
Looks more like medium to me.
Substantial-Dig9995
Med
musKholecasualty
Definitely medium. But perfect
C4Cupcake
dammit now I’m hungry *cry*
bankdank
Perfect medium! Would gladly enjoy this!
Wadertot420
I think so. Medium would have a bit larger greyband
Odd_Cartographer7721
You’re over thinking it don’t be so prescriptive about definitions that’s a friggin beautiful meal God bless
Legonistrasz
That is perfect is what it is
Ok-Winter480
Looks more medium
jchef420
It doesn’t matter at all how you cooked your steak as long as that’s the way you enjoy it. Mid rare is the easiest point to cook a steak to. As soon as you see blood on the surface of the meat it’s time to flip it. I’ve cooked thousands of steaks over the years and this is an almost foolproof hack.
Admirable-Title9022
This is the problem with this sub. Everyone thinks medium and medium rare look differently. Even when OP says it’s med rare temp everyone says “well must be the thermometer”. This looks like med rare all day to me. And the temp would agree
TheMan-Myth-Legend1
That’s about as close to medium rare as you can get.
Consistent_Yoghurt_4
Looks like a good medium to me, cooked right
ArcticFoxismyname
Solid medium
SigilumSanctum
As everyone has said it looks like a perfect medium, and looks utterly delicious.
Savage_Justice
That’s mesium
Beneficial-Tip7000
Yep
thirtyone-charlie
This is a more perfect medium. I would be glad to get this in a restaurant if I ordered MR. I would eat it.
thirtyone-charlie
This is a more perfect medium. I would be glad to get this in a restaurant if I ordered MR. I would eat it.
Drpolyy
Medium
ApathicSaint
Perfect medium, and there is absolutely nothing wrong with a perfect medium
41 Comments
It depends on taste, I like it that way.
That looks perfect medium rare for me!
Looks more like medium to me but still looks great!
Light pink throughout with little to no blood/juice is perfectly medium actually, and it looks delicious!
This is a perfect medium, said as someone who loves medium
More medium but looks amazing.
Camera shots can be deceiving. Looks closer to medium, but definitely a nice cook on them! Nice job!
Looks like a perfect medium which is great for ribeye
Looks closer to medium, but could well be the lighting. It’s very close. But I would say 100% would eat it. The only thing is none of them look like ribeyes though
Medium rare could be a brighter red but these still look good
Medium.
yummmyyy
Depends on the final temperature, honestly.
Medium. This is how I prefer most steak cuts.
Perfect medium
It’s hard to gauge based on a photo. Depending on lighting and the camera, I can make the same steak look medium well or medium rare. Go by actual temp and taste moreso than look.
That being said, I’d eat the hell out of that! Looks delicious to me.
That’s a perfect medium. While I prefer medium rare, I would enjoy eating this medium as there is not too much gray band.
How did you cook it?
Yes, 9.3 would
That is a medium. A yummy juicy medium.
Looks more like medium to me.
Med
Definitely medium. But perfect
dammit now I’m hungry *cry*
Perfect medium! Would gladly enjoy this!
I think so. Medium would have a bit larger greyband
You’re over thinking it don’t be so prescriptive about definitions that’s a friggin beautiful meal God bless
That is perfect is what it is
Looks more medium
It doesn’t matter at all how you cooked your steak as long as that’s the way you enjoy it. Mid rare is the easiest point to cook a steak to. As soon as you see blood on the surface of the meat it’s time to flip it. I’ve cooked thousands of steaks over the years and this is an almost foolproof hack.
This is the problem with this sub. Everyone thinks medium and medium rare look differently. Even when OP says it’s med rare temp everyone says “well must be the thermometer”. This looks like med rare all day to me. And the temp would agree
That’s about as close to medium rare as you can get.
Looks like a good medium to me, cooked right
Solid medium
As everyone has said it looks like a perfect medium, and looks utterly delicious.
That’s mesium
Yep
This is a more perfect medium. I would be glad to get this in a restaurant if I ordered MR. I would eat it.
This is a more perfect medium. I would be glad to get this in a restaurant if I ordered MR. I would eat it.
Medium
Perfect medium, and there is absolutely nothing wrong with a perfect medium