Hey fellow bakers (and cookie lovers)! I’m in a baking competition this Wednesday and can only submit one cookie… but I’ve got three contenders and I’m seriously torn.
Here are the options:
Pistachio Macaroons – chewy, nutty, a little fancy.
Miso Brown Butter Chocolate Chip – salty-sweet, rich, a twist on a classic.
Guinness Chocolate Chip – deep cocoa flavor with a stout kick, especially good for dark chocolate fans.
Which would you want to taste first? Or which one do you think would wow the judges most?
Appreciate the votes and any tips! 🍪 if you are in the NYC area, more information on the competition can be found here: https://www.beerwitchbrooklyn.com/events-1/cookie-bake-off?fbclid=PAZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAacOVmG_Kk2s-7PsrF7YCoQ5ATOt8CP6AvsiXj8lm-gVozRQMTjh6H7AYIYSvA_aem_1VSnAH2a7Gm4btHPfhHP-Q
by BrinasBakery
26 Comments
#3
Guinness chocolate chip
I like the creative flavors of 2 and 3 but macarons will showcase your technical baking skills and attention to detail. I would go with a macaron cookie
They all sound good, but pistachios seem to be having a moment right now. That could just be that I love pistachios though.
Your macaroons are perfect, I think you should do that because (in my opinion) they’re hard to master, but if you added a touch of green food dye they might look more aesthetic up to you though!
2
The chocolate looks good.
Macaroons absolutely 👍🏻
Those macaroons look absolutely amazing!!!
Macaron 100%
Pistachio macarons. Uniquely different, hardly ever find them freshly made in U.S. at least where I’m at. Most of the places that sell macarons here are shipped from overseas.
Those are macarons, not macaroons. Macaroons are the coconut cookies.
Anyway, I’d say # 1 or # 2, depending on the flavor. # 3 probably tastes awesome, but not as visually appealing.
Macarons are not easy to make. You are skilled and they look great.
Macarons. Not everyone will have them.
Just make sure if you’re labelling them, that you put them as macarons not macaroons, macaroons are made of coconut.
While I’m sure the first ones are delicious, they don’t look that appetizing to me
Definitely the Pistachio Macaroons.
I’d personally flip a coin between 2 and 3, with a slight preference for 3.
Honestly though they’re all terrific 👌✨
Macaron
Macroons. They’re definitely harder to master and yours looks so good!
Macarons
Macarons or the double chocolate cookie! Good luck! 🍀
2 or 1 for me!
I personally dislike salt on my cookies so I personally would skip 3 altogether. 😬
Tons of people love it though so who knows?
3
Macarons
#1.
3