No walk-ins, you have to order around 10a to pick up same day between 4-9p.
I got the pepperoni, it was delicious and unlike any pizza I’ve had before. Impressive!
by NightShadowJ
13 Comments
ButDidYouCry
How does dine-in work?
Lionelchesterfield
All right so I tried this place a week ago, the one in Berwyn. You can tell everything is super fresh and well made but overall I just didn’t find it to be as amazing as folks in this sub claim it is. I will say though that my favorite thing about this pizza is how deceivingly light it is. It doesn’t feel like a gut bomb compared to other pan or deep dish pizzas.
Mrfreeze5386
So you have to go to their website at 10am to place the order for same day? I just tried and it says currently unavailable?
joshua9663
Whata the name of that cheese called?! Need to get it next time
233up
Where’s the cheese?
BigPoppaDubDub
I’m not doing all that for a pizza in the greatest pizza city in the world
Gennaro_Svastano
By the slice?
PMmeyourNattoGohan
OK, I wanted Milly’s this weekend but their website online order interface was broken/down. Did you call in?
toastedclown
I live nearby and order from them occasionally. It’s really good! Is it the best? I don’t know. It’s a variation of the Burt Katz style, a little lighter with less emphasis on the frico cheese edge. George’s Deep Dish on Clark does a somewhat similar style.
measy24
I try them again about a month ago and I’ll still stick with george’s is way better.
gcn0611
My favorite bougie pizza place. Love that they use peppadew peppers, which are hard to find, and I don’t feel like absolute crap after eating a few slices. Idk how he gets it so light
Apprehensive_Key_103
This pizza is a mediocre version of George’s on the northside, which I would highly recommend people check out if they like pan pizza a-la Pequods. Milly’s doesn’t have a lot of flavor to it, though the crust isn’t bad, but George’s gets all the components right. Their olive/roasted garlic pizza is funky pizza heaven
BloodOnTheTeaLeaves
I’m sorry but dont believe everyone who says George’s is better!! Is Milly’s my favorite pizza in the city? No (it’s Bob’s, which is apparently a controversial opinion, and Paulie Gees), but Milly’s is also fantastic, especially the day after. I thought George’s was good, but I probably won’t go back.
13 Comments
How does dine-in work?
All right so I tried this place a week ago, the one in Berwyn. You can tell everything is super fresh and well made but overall I just didn’t find it to be as amazing as folks in this sub claim it is. I will say though that my favorite thing about this pizza is how deceivingly light it is. It doesn’t feel like a gut bomb compared to other pan or deep dish pizzas.
So you have to go to their website at 10am to place the order for same day? I just tried and it says currently unavailable?
Whata the name of that cheese called?! Need to get it next time
Where’s the cheese?
I’m not doing all that for a pizza in the greatest pizza city in the world
By the slice?
OK, I wanted Milly’s this weekend but their website online order interface was broken/down. Did you call in?
I live nearby and order from them occasionally. It’s really good! Is it the best? I don’t know. It’s a variation of the Burt Katz style, a little lighter with less emphasis on the frico cheese edge. George’s Deep Dish on Clark does a somewhat similar style.
I try them again about a month ago and I’ll still stick with george’s is way better.
My favorite bougie pizza place. Love that they use peppadew peppers, which are hard to find, and I don’t feel like absolute crap after eating a few slices. Idk how he gets it so light
This pizza is a mediocre version of George’s on the northside, which I would highly recommend people check out if they like pan pizza a-la Pequods. Milly’s doesn’t have a lot of flavor to it, though the crust isn’t bad, but George’s gets all the components right. Their olive/roasted garlic pizza is funky pizza heaven
I’m sorry but dont believe everyone who says George’s is better!! Is Milly’s my favorite pizza in the city? No (it’s Bob’s, which is apparently a controversial opinion, and Paulie Gees), but Milly’s is also fantastic, especially the day after. I thought George’s was good, but I probably won’t go back.