I haven’t done this in years but I’ve been hankering for it. I figured it would never taste the same as I remember but the technique was how I remember. It came out very good if a little sweeter than I recall. Her seasoning may have been a little different. 50 years clouds the memory. Still I was reading up on sear, not sear, what people add etc. in the end I did it just like she did.
I had a 2.3 lb beef arm roast (she always used chuck. Back when it was ACTUALLY cheap) so that might be a little flavor difference). I seasoned it with seasoning salt and cracked pepper and a little French thyme. Set it straight in the 4.5 qt crockpot on top of the sliced onion and chucked a can of diced tomatoes and juice in. Rinsed the can with about a 1/3 cup water and added that which brought the liquid level up to just staring to come up the sides of the roast. Cooked on low for about 3-4 hours, added potatoes and carrots on top, not a ton. I figured if I wanted more vegetables I’d roast extra. Cooked a total of 9 hrs from cold start low the whole time.
I thickened the juice (a good 3 cups in the end) with corn starch and I did add a half cube of Knorr’s beef bouillon to combat the sweet edge. If you like the flavor don’t bother with that part. I think it comes from the carrots. That was just right.
The Roast is just a perfect consistency and not at all dry. She always said to just use the tomatoes because the acid helped make the meat extra tender. It seems like a way different way to do it than everything I read looking around the internet. which is either a version of Mississippi or at least uses a packet of soup. So if you want to try something a little more straightforward give it a try. That’s a true 1970 Crockpot roast recipe.
by karinchup
8 Comments
Love it! Sounds really straightforward. Thanks for sharing!
I made pot roast today too. I used tomato paste but might try regular canned tomatoes next time.
Awesome. Sounds classic. What size tomato can?
It looks delicious!
thanks for the recipe!
Looks superb, thanks for the straight up old school recipe.
Pot Roast of my favorite comfort meals! I love it over Polenta with roasted carrots, green beans and Parker Josie rolls!
what, no half gallon of brine oil like with the mississippi?… how could that possibly be good? /s
that looks awesome, i can almost smell the picture 🙂