decided to post an update since so many people asked for it. Memorial Day bbq dad steak pictured here for comparison.
original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/steak/s/vuqvjhkzoF

by ahoycarolina

32 Comments

  1. He didn’t add the “at cooking steak” part. He’s trying to drop hints.

  2. GettingBackRVA2

    Your dad sucks at enjoying quality steak.

  3. savvysearch

    The issue with the bf’s steak is he didn’t let it come to temp before cooking, so there’s heavy banding. The rareness isn’t that different between the two, though. So I’d actually like to know your dad’s complaint. Your dad’s slicing is more attractive and it looks juicier visually.

  4. CreatureTheGathering

    Your dad is jealous that looks delicious

  5. Upper-Fan-6173

    Does your dad often compare himself to or put down your bf? Because that’s weird behavior

  6. ThaEmortalThief

    The cook is on point, question is in the taste. Did he freeze it and then thaw and cook? Meat that you get from the butcher or store, if thawed, shouldn’t be refrozen. If you get it frozen, then slow thaw it, otherwise you change the flavor. Then question is how he seasoned or cooked it. But his temps look next to perfect.

  7. CarpetDismal6204

    Dad’s looks like the clear winner. The original, the bf’s I believe, was too under-done yet somehow still looked dry af.

  8. Whitetiger9876

    I think everyone is misreading. This is the steak the dad cooked. Right?  First post boyfriend cooked. 

    They’re good steaks Brent. 

  9. SlightlyFadedGolf

    Both look good. Your dad’s steak looks better imo. BFs steak looks good too but didn’t get as good of a sear.

  10. clityeastwood805

    Your dad probably likes eating gray overcooked car tires.

  11. Flowkey_mma

    So this picture in here is of your dads steak?

    And the attached link of the thread is a steak your boyfriend made?

    Welp, in that case..
    Your dad is right…
    His steak looks a lot better than your boyfriends.

    Just being honest.

  12. _Bon_Vivant_

    Your dad is being a bit harsh, but your bf does have some learning to do. Your bf’s steak in very inconsistent. Thick gray parts, and nearly rare parts on the same steak.

  13. nonnymauss

    If you disinvite your dad to the cookout I’ll take his plate

  14. Your dad is jealous of your bf which is actually very weird and concerning 😅

  15. jah_hoover_witness

    I am straight and want to date your boyfriend.

  16. External_Art_1835

    Overcooked… definitely not Medium Rare …

  17. Your dad doesn’t like your BF for some reason.

  18. Rushedhomeroughyn

    I think he’s just worried he does other stuff as good as this steak….

Write A Comment