10 pounder! Did I overcook it?

by bucsjosh

23 Comments

  1. bob-loblaw-esq

    Looks like a good medium for me. It’s more than I would like, but I’d still take that baby home and introduce her to mama.

  2. Huge_Plankton_905

    A tiny bit over cooked but I definitely would not complain 

  3. No-Second-Kill-Death

    Don’t stick in the probe that far. 

    That’s what she. Nfm. 

    I would eat it!!!

    That’s….

  4. covertpenguin3390

    That cut is forgiving so I’m sure it was still good but yeah there are way better ways to cook rib roasts IMO. Look up reverse sear. It’s no fail and will give you desired doneness end to end. If you have someone who refuses to eat med rare, just take their slice and cook it more on stove / in oven / air fryer instead of compromising entire roast

  5. WCMModels

    Yes. Recovering professional chef here.

    Look at your photos of the sliced meat, the grey cooked area is usually smaller when prepared in a restaurant.

    Also the center, especially the middle cuts is usually darker red.

    Everybody has their preferences but cooking to the standard doneness preserves moisture, texture and mouthfeel.

  6. thebrain_pinky

    yea it is burnt. sent to me for proper disposal.

  7. Taskmaster_Fantatic

    Hey… ummm, so… what cut of meat is that?

  8. OsoHaleysman

    Looks good . I missed the mark on my tomahawk steaks today.

  9. Soggy_Cracker

    Depends on if you were going for a roast or more of a traditional prime rib style. But it’s something I would gladly eat.

  10. Europia79

    Bro, 921 degrees is way overcooked !!! j/k lol 😛

    Next time, probably wanna either cut the CAP off and “wave it over the fire” separately, OR, cut the roast into more manageable sections, then serve “medallions” instead of “slices”.

    Otherwise, looks pretty good: My only criticism is that the CAP is way overcooked and the FAT hasn’t rendered.

  11. itsbuddytime

    Its kind of a tad of extra work, but if you cut the bones off first, you can twine them back on, but over the cap to protect it. Other than that, that some solid eating.

Write A Comment