I’m craving a vanilla soft serve with crushed Reese’s peanut butter cups mixed in. Is Carvel my best bet for something like that?
Mister Softee and the upscale soft serve spots don’t really do this. A McFlurry comes close but no peanut butter cup option!
For reference, I used to visit Martha’s Dandee Creme up by Lake George and loved their soft serve!
EDIT: For anyone coming back to this, I did go to Carvel and they had something very close to what I wanted! But I think I’ll try to go to Goodiez this summer too.
by dwchambers
12 Comments
RIP Dairy Queen
Not helpful but the [old Milk & Cream Cereal bar](https://maps.app.goo.gl/JLMZ7EBgRRRmzLSM6) that closed a few years ago would have what you wanted. They had soft serve with reese cereal and reese pieces. Kind of a shame they closed because I remember the last time I went, they had a really cool Ruggrats collab.
Marvel Frozen Dairy has reese’s pieces as a topping, They also do shakes with their soft serve so I think you can mx in that way?
16 Handles may be an option, there’s one on the UWS
Surprised that no one has mentioned Soft Swerve yet, my favorite soft serve in NYC, though I’m not sure if they have peanut butter cups as a topping.
[https://www.softswervenyc.com/](https://www.softswervenyc.com/)
edit*
No peanut butter cups, but they do have Reese’s puffs.
kith treats
These are all fair suggestions! Unfortunately I think peanut butter cups are substantially enough different from (and, IMHO, better than) Reese’s pieces! Peanut butter cups are still soft in ice cream but the pieces are hard and crunchy.
Kith on Flatbush in Brooklyn?
Rays in the east village. They even deep fry them
If you find yourself out on Long Island, Spoons in Seaford has exactly what you’re looking for, just not exactly an immediate option from the city
[Goodiez](https://g.co/kgs/MCp9Zsu) on 7th Avenue in Park Slope does this.
When I was very young, I liked the Peanut Butter Blizzard at Dairy Queen.