Disclaimer: I am far from an expert with royal icing and have only made it a handful of times. These are just my amateur observations and they could be quite affected by my lack of experience. I use the same recipe for both types.
The first picture is an example of the organic powdered sugar royal icing that has those little cracks because it started drying before I finished spreading it out and getting the air bubbles out. It is MUCH glossier in real life.
Second picture al
Taste:
- Organic (tapioca starch): Very neutral and takes on the flavour of whatever you add to it (ex: vanilla, almond). Stays softer under the crust and is creamier.
- Regular (Corn starch): Typical powdered sugar taste, kind of soap-like (in my opinion). Dries much harder and doesnt have that nice soft under crust as much.
Mixing (both made using stand mixer):
- Organic (tapioca starch): Doesn't fluff up as much, a little
- Regular (Corn starch): Fluffs up more, feels like it would be easier to over mix
Piping:
- Organic (tapioca starch): Flood consistency crusts over quicker, creating these cracks if you dont work quickly (shown in picture). Levels out easier. More prone to air bubbles.
- Regular (Corn starch): Doesn't level out as nicely but theres a bit more time to work with it before it crusts over. Less prone to air bubbles.
Final dried appearance:
- Organic (tapioca starch): Beautifully glossy, but shows cracks if you don't work quickly enough. Less prone to bleeding. Much less prone to cratering (I've never had a single crater with tapioca based powdered sugar in royal icing)
- Regular (Corn starch): Very matte, strangely for me it dries glittery even though I don't add any. More prone to bleeding. Much more prone to catering.
Final Verdict:
- Organic (tapioca starch): Taste is so much better, beautiful glossy finish, have to work quicker, once its dried, less prone to bleeding and cratering.
- Regular (Corn starch): Taste is not amazing, very matte finish, more flexibility when its wet, when it dries there may be craters
My questions:
- For those who have experience with the tapioca starch powdered sugar in royal icing, is there anything I can do to prevent those cracks in the icing if i need longer to work with it? It only happens with large areas of flood consistency icing.
- Does anyone else experience the strange glittery appearance on the very matte base with regular royal icing once its dried? I'm not complaining! It's very pretty, but I wouldnt want it for every applicaiton.
by Fluffysleepypanda
2 Comments
Are you using meringue powder in your recipe? Maybe if you posted your other ingredients/recipe it may help to narrow down the causes. I’m wondering if the glittery appearance may be due to overmixing?
Just for some background info, [here’s Stella Parks’ article on organic powdered sugar.](https://www.seriouseats.com/organic-powdered-sugar-versus-conventional-baking-cornstarch-tapioca)