Thanks to Mrs. Markley of New Jersey for these old recipes.
Fuzzy_Welcome8348
U can never go wrong w a good old fashioned cake! Nice thrifting find😎🤝
SEA2COLA
Growing up, I remember my Mom *always* bought cake mixes in boxes. When I became an adult and started baking more, I found it’s really not that difficult to achieve the same results from scratch. That being said, I’m both intrigued and repulsed by ‘Mystery Cake’…..
thingonething
I know that last recipe as Mayonnaise cake. I’ve never used Miracle Whip, only Best Foods/Hellmann’s. It’s actually very good cake.
Excusemytootie
This is my grandma’s handwriting 🥺 (so similar that it could be anyway).
nomadquail
Despite the nastiness implied by tomato soup in a cake I have heard they’re pretty good
qawsedrf12
Mystery Cake- its a mystery why there is tomato soup in it
I love these kinds O f finds! Enjoyed going through cake recipes. Thank you for sharing!
Beneficial-Math-2300
There was a tomato soup cake recipe that was making the rounds in my town in 1970. It was very much like the one shown here, but with the addition of melted chocolate. I never tried it myself, but everyone I knew back then was raving about it.
11 Comments
Thanks to Mrs. Markley of New Jersey for these old recipes.
U can never go wrong w a good old fashioned cake! Nice thrifting find😎🤝
Growing up, I remember my Mom *always* bought cake mixes in boxes. When I became an adult and started baking more, I found it’s really not that difficult to achieve the same results from scratch. That being said, I’m both intrigued and repulsed by ‘Mystery Cake’…..
I know that last recipe as Mayonnaise cake. I’ve never used Miracle Whip, only Best Foods/Hellmann’s. It’s actually very good cake.
This is my grandma’s handwriting 🥺 (so similar that it could be anyway).
Despite the nastiness implied by tomato soup in a cake I have heard they’re pretty good
Mystery Cake- its a mystery why there is tomato soup in it
[Dylan did it](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8sYkwhnujA)
Awesome find!
I love these kinds O f finds! Enjoyed going through cake recipes. Thank you for sharing!
There was a tomato soup cake recipe that was making the rounds in my town in 1970. It was very much like the one shown here, but with the addition of melted chocolate. I never tried it myself, but everyone I knew back then was raving about it.
Looks like Hannibal TV series recipe box.