It’s pretty amazing actually. I took a bottle to the local hangout and everyone there loved it. The Fire Roasted Garlic Habanero and Ghost Pepper Wing Sauce are also very good.
Drawsfoodpoorly
I threw a big bottle away.
Moodbocaj
If you’re a fan of strong mushrooms, you’ll dig it. I’m a big fan of it. Great on a burger, not much heat though.
No_Button4702
No
vex91
This one was super weird for me, I thought it was kind of gross when I tasted it by itself. But there actually were certain foods that I added it to that I thought the flavors worked really well with. Definitely not one that you will be adding to everything though so a small bottle is probably the way to go for this one.
Moondoobious
I put it in potato soup. I haven’t found another use for it.
sudo_meh
I didn’t like this at all, none of my friends did either.
Ashamed_Cell_7562
Update. Tried it on a crescent roll (only like bland thing i had that i could try it on to taste it). It was pretty good, more of a condiment really. Garlicky and herby, I enjoyed it but it’s not spicy at all. Solid 3/10 as a hot sauce.
Toolivedrew65
Any time I see this stuff posted here I know the comments are about to be all saying how trash it is.
Much_Grand_8558
I love it, but I’m told I have weird tastes.
bcwitb
After reading all the comments here, I have to agree with all of them. For me it depends on my mood. I have bought the stuff several times and used it all up…..but, some days I didnt even want to think about it because it is very earthy (can be nasty earthy) other days I craved it for the same reason. As someone else said. It is a very polarizing sauce.
Jaded_Helicopter_376
Dude I ruined some steaks with this like an idiot!!!!! I marinaded them in it and they were disgusting!!!!!!!!
IZZO79
I’ve tried it. It’s not bad with definitely an original taste.
Kaizen-_
I love Melinda’s, but wasn’t a big fan of this one. Rather have the Scorpion or Roasted Garlic
International_Fly608
I’m a huge fan of this one. Great on roasted chicken. Had it in a chicken cacciatore I made as well.
QueenAzshara
I didn’t like it all
Duff-Guy
Only Melinda’s sauce i don’t like. Their ghost pepper wing sauce is a staple around here
No-Dress-7645
Horrible. The worst of theirs by far
Lower_Funny
My partner fuckin loves it. I don’t as much. Very mushroomy
skeletons_asshole
I’ve heard it’s good on proteins if you are into the sort of taste it has. Personally I’d rather lick postage stamps for a meal than taste this again.
KingxRaizen
Yeah it’s tasty. 8/10 imo
Their ghost pepper sauce is like 9.5/10
itsdaviddude
I love it, one of my go to sauces but a lot of people seem to not like it
humdawg
This is a very love it or hate it sauce 😆
terfez
I think it’s terrible. I always pull out this story as proof:
Our office manager bought it for our office. An office of 50 different people of all ages, ethnicities, tastes, dietary restrictions etc. Some people like spicy and some people don’t. Well we never finished the bottle. I tried it on at least 5 different dishes, it never improved any dish. It is a sad substitute for dipping. Sad substitute for anything. The bottle is like 3 years old now in the fridge
For comparison, we have office ketchup, office sriracha, Tabasco, soy sauce, we cycle through those all the time
twotoonies
0/10
The ghost pepper wing sauce from Melinda’s is a solid 8/10 though. It’s a staple in my house.
SmallRocks
I did not like it at all. No heat and a weird flavor. I used it twice and trashed it.
Dark_Flatus
I can drink this stuff straight. Its my favorite. Although I think the general consensus is that its bad. More for me.
HighSolstice
I didn’t like it at all but my sister did so I gave the rest of the bottle to her.
GpRex
About every 3 months I try it again just to see if it’s actually not that bad. Just to remind me how awful it is. It belongs in the trash.
The_cursed_yeet
I love it. They have a hotter one with ghost pepper that’s extra good. It’s great on burgers, pasta, and pizza.
Dudejax
My favorite.
YborOgre
My wife loves it. I’m kinda meh about it. She likes it on pizza crust
piranhadub
I seriously hate throwing food away or wasting anything consumable. I bought this horseshit last year and it’s still on the top row of my fridge door, I leave it there as a reminder to look into things before purchase if/when possible.
LascivX
Trash
RIPcompo
It’s literally in your hand. Try it, don’t tell us, flush your telephone down the toilet.
Technical-Weird-3472
As others have said it’s garbage 🗑️
Apocalypso777
You’ll love it or hate it
unicornamoungbeasts
NO!
YouDoneGoofd
I’ve realized I hate everything by that brand
Spacedust2808
I enjoy it on eggs.
Hopper29
It’s really amazing how polarizing this sauce is.
Something about its flavor profile, people either like it, love it or absolutely despise it like they were just tricked into licking a used diaper.
I have one of these tiny bottles but I haven’t got around to trying it I’m slowly going thru the whole Melinda’s tiny bottle tour, can’t wait to try it and see what it’s like for me.
SirCaptainReynolds
Nope. Put it back.
CarniverousCosmos
It’s awesome w
spicynoodsinmuhmouf
Insanely good yes
Axel_Foley14
No
zambulu
maybe try it and tell us what you think
JAF7715
I love it on my omelets
Grindhouser
Really good on a burger
Skeletor-P-Funk
It’s genuinely one of the worst things I have ever tasted, which is crazy because their Fire Roasted Garlic & Habanero is absolutely delicious (#2 to Marie Sharp’s Belizean Heat though).
It’s not even worth the one dollar asking price for a sample bottle, it went straight into the trash after one taste.
49 Comments
It’s pretty amazing actually. I took a bottle to the local hangout and everyone there loved it. The Fire Roasted Garlic Habanero and Ghost Pepper Wing Sauce are also very good.
I threw a big bottle away.
If you’re a fan of strong mushrooms, you’ll dig it. I’m a big fan of it. Great on a burger, not much heat though.
No
This one was super weird for me, I thought it was kind of gross when I tasted it by itself. But there actually were certain foods that I added it to that I thought the flavors worked really well with. Definitely not one that you will be adding to everything though so a small bottle is probably the way to go for this one.
I put it in potato soup. I haven’t found another use for it.
I didn’t like this at all, none of my friends did either.
Update. Tried it on a crescent roll (only like bland thing i had that i could try it on to taste it). It was pretty good, more of a condiment really. Garlicky and herby, I enjoyed it but it’s not spicy at all. Solid 3/10 as a hot sauce.
Any time I see this stuff posted here I know the comments are about to be all saying how trash it is.
I love it, but I’m told I have weird tastes.
After reading all the comments here, I have to agree with all of them. For me it depends on my mood. I have bought the stuff several times and used it all up…..but, some days I didnt even want to think about it because it is very earthy (can be nasty earthy) other days I craved it for the same reason. As someone else said. It is a very polarizing sauce.
Dude I ruined some steaks with this like an idiot!!!!! I marinaded them in it and they were disgusting!!!!!!!!
I’ve tried it. It’s not bad with definitely an original taste.
I love Melinda’s, but wasn’t a big fan of this one. Rather have the Scorpion or Roasted Garlic
I’m a huge fan of this one. Great on roasted chicken. Had it in a chicken cacciatore I made as well.
I didn’t like it all
Only Melinda’s sauce i don’t like. Their ghost pepper wing sauce is a staple around here
Horrible. The worst of theirs by far
My partner fuckin loves it. I don’t as much. Very mushroomy
I’ve heard it’s good on proteins if you are into the sort of taste it has. Personally I’d rather lick postage stamps for a meal than taste this again.
Yeah it’s tasty. 8/10 imo
Their ghost pepper sauce is like 9.5/10
I love it, one of my go to sauces but a lot of people seem to not like it
This is a very love it or hate it sauce 😆
I think it’s terrible. I always pull out this story as proof:
Our office manager bought it for our office. An office of 50 different people of all ages, ethnicities, tastes, dietary restrictions etc. Some people like spicy and some people don’t. Well we never finished the bottle. I tried it on at least 5 different dishes, it never improved any dish. It is a sad substitute for dipping. Sad substitute for anything. The bottle is like 3 years old now in the fridge
For comparison, we have office ketchup, office sriracha, Tabasco, soy sauce, we cycle through those all the time
0/10
The ghost pepper wing sauce from Melinda’s is a solid 8/10 though. It’s a staple in my house.
I did not like it at all. No heat and a weird flavor. I used it twice and trashed it.
I can drink this stuff straight. Its my favorite. Although I think the general consensus is that its bad. More for me.
I didn’t like it at all but my sister did so I gave the rest of the bottle to her.
About every 3 months I try it again just to see if it’s actually not that bad. Just to remind me how awful it is. It belongs in the trash.
I love it. They have a hotter one with ghost pepper that’s extra good. It’s great on burgers, pasta, and pizza.
My favorite.
My wife loves it. I’m kinda meh about it. She likes it on pizza crust
I seriously hate throwing food away or wasting anything consumable. I bought this horseshit last year and it’s still on the top row of my fridge door, I leave it there as a reminder to look into things before purchase if/when possible.
Trash
It’s literally in your hand. Try it, don’t tell us, flush your telephone down the toilet.
As others have said it’s garbage 🗑️
You’ll love it or hate it
NO!
I’ve realized I hate everything by that brand
I enjoy it on eggs.
It’s really amazing how polarizing this sauce is.
Something about its flavor profile, people either like it, love it or absolutely despise it like they were just tricked into licking a used diaper.
I have one of these tiny bottles but I haven’t got around to trying it I’m slowly going thru the whole Melinda’s tiny bottle tour, can’t wait to try it and see what it’s like for me.
Nope. Put it back.
It’s awesome w
Insanely good yes
No
maybe try it and tell us what you think
I love it on my omelets
Really good on a burger
It’s genuinely one of the worst things I have ever tasted, which is crazy because their Fire Roasted Garlic & Habanero is absolutely delicious (#2 to Marie Sharp’s Belizean Heat though).
It’s not even worth the one dollar asking price for a sample bottle, it went straight into the trash after one taste.