I wouldn’t give it a 1 out of 10. I think you are being a little hard on yourself. For real though. I would eat that without question.
DJHoZ
For me a 10/10, no question.
Rob5on
A little bit more sear would be great, but this is a very solid 7 to 8 to me. Good job!
notduckduckbob
Change title is my feedback. Looks great and probably tasted great.
ckm808
7/10
Would be a 12/10 if it had a crust
Airstrike_1203
IMO…Perfect
Major_Replacement905
Best rating I can give you. I would devour this if you put it in front of me and tell all the neighbors how badly they would want one of your steaks. This steak looks so good to me. Way to go!
Gregg-Da-Keg
Perfect medium rare. What cut is this?
OrlandoOpossum
That looks good and you know it.
genie-cream
7!
Outrageous_Ad4252
Doneness looks great, but next time, make sure (regardless of cooking method) that heat source is HIGH so that meat quickly sears. Gets the best char
Prudent_Two_1292
Yumm
Dangerous_Reach_6424
Temperature is right, needs a tad more crust. Looks like it kept juicy. Solid 8.
Wise-Ad-7248
For how lumpy that piece a meat is I’d say that’s an 8/10. You got a pretty good sear for it to not lay flat
macyglowx
I’ll give it an 8/10
Hefty-Plastic8417
8
zakkzander888
9
jjhuffington
9… can’t give it a 10 unless I get to taste it.. lmao
Confident-Walrus4814
Looks great to me!
Salty_Slug
Perfect temp 5/5, sear could be better 3/5. 8/10
AggressiveAudience63
That is a tough shape to cook evenly. Nice job with that. How did you prepare this. I would give it a 7.5.
montyswingwell
Yummy 🤤
Outside_Loquat9448
I would be thrilled to be served this
tehc0w
It looks like a roast more than a steak (maybe because of the perspective).
As a steak, 7 because crust can be better but still looks delicious
vinnsy9
8, good job
Many_Feeling_3818
Is this steak supposed to be cooked medium?
the_viking97
10!
sidlives1
How did you cook this? Looks really good on the interior, but I agree it would have been nice to get a bit more of a sear in the outside.
RageKage559803
8. Looks awesome. Could maybe use a better sear / crust.
Practical-Ad-6859
8.5
cyclorphan
Looks like the right doneness, would destroy.
A little more crust would make it truly top tier.
LaWattcher
It’s good 👍 so 9 more steak to go ??
Old-Capital5079
9.5. Beautiful meat 🤤
TranslatorRoyal8710
8.1 that’ll eat!
Specific-Swing-2790
Perfect!
PorkChopSandwiches-
Looks awesome to me, I agree about trying to get more crust, but I’m eating this no problem
38 Comments
I wouldn’t give it a 1 out of 10. I think you are being a little hard on yourself.
For real though. I would eat that without question.
For me a 10/10, no question.
A little bit more sear would be great, but this is a very solid 7 to 8 to me. Good job!
Change title is my feedback. Looks great and probably tasted great.
7/10
Would be a 12/10 if it had a crust
IMO…Perfect
Best rating I can give you. I would devour this if you put it in front of me and tell all the neighbors how badly they would want one of your steaks. This steak looks so good to me. Way to go!
Perfect medium rare. What cut is this?
That looks good and you know it.
7!
Doneness looks great, but next time, make sure (regardless of cooking method) that heat source is HIGH so that meat quickly sears. Gets the best char
Yumm
Temperature is right, needs a tad more crust. Looks like it kept juicy. Solid 8.
For how lumpy that piece a meat is I’d say that’s an 8/10. You got a pretty good sear for it to not lay flat
I’ll give it an 8/10
8
9
9… can’t give it a 10 unless I get to taste it.. lmao
Looks great to me!
Perfect temp 5/5, sear could be better 3/5. 8/10
That is a tough shape to cook evenly. Nice job with that. How did you prepare this. I would give it a 7.5.
Yummy 🤤
I would be thrilled to be served this
It looks like a roast more than a steak (maybe because of the perspective).
As a steak, 7 because crust can be better but still looks delicious
8, good job
Is this steak supposed to be cooked medium?
10!
How did you cook this? Looks really good on the interior, but I agree it would have been nice to get a bit more of a sear in the outside.
8. Looks awesome. Could maybe use a better sear / crust.
8.5
Looks like the right doneness, would destroy.
A little more crust would make it truly top tier.
It’s good 👍 so 9 more steak to go ??
9.5. Beautiful meat 🤤
8.1 that’ll eat!
Perfect!
Looks awesome to me, I agree about trying to get more crust, but I’m eating this no problem
strong 7 to a light 8
9