Don’t ask me why I bought two of them when the recipe says I just need a few tablespoons.

But, when I went back to look at the recipes I was perusing, they say to use pistachio paste and these are more like butters. Is it still okay to use them for a pistachio gelato / ice cream? Anybody here use them before?

by Legitimate_Skirt5467

5 Comments

  1. onesadbun

    I’ve done it before! I didn’t use a proper recipe though I just added it to a plain vanilla base and added until it tasted the way I wanted.

  2. AnimalBasedAl

    That second one looks to be much lower quality, I’d consider making your own pistachio butter!

  3. steamed_pork_bunz

    I do! In fact I have even used that same jar with the ivory colored label you have there and it turned out great. I also add buttery pistachios at the end, inspired by butter pecan. I’m still workshopping my recipe, but if you’d like to try it I’d be happy to put it in a comment.

  4. markhalliday8

    Personally, I think you’d struggle because they are only 45 percent pistachio. So logically, it’s 55 percent something else, likely oil and sugar.

    I think it would still be good but not as good as pistachio paste.

    I would make vanilla and swirl it in.

  5. donovanwest

    I’ve done it before. I might’ve rather had paste but it was still good. Maybe cut back on the sugar in your recipe since that will have a lot