I have to have these two at all times in my freezer. What’s y’all’s go to Ben and Jerry’s and why?
by ProperDeparture9996
33 Comments
Darwin343
I’d probably go with Oat of this Swirl and Peanut Butter Cup as my two favorites. Dirt Cake is a close 3rd.
Fuzzy_Welcome8348
Nahh these ain’t the best
kwadguy
The toppers and sundaes, which are being heavily promoted and are taking up more and more of the B&Js display, are their attempt to improve the bottom line by including about 2oz LESS product per pint without reducing cost. Yeah, I know Haagen Dazs did this years ago. But I guess B&Js has now decided “I want a piece of THAT!”
SmilingSunBlackMoon
I had Dirt Cake like a month ago and I can’t stop thinking about it. I love the big chunks of cookie, it’s perfect.
aquatic_kitten19
I find chunky monkey to be so underwhelming! It could be incredible and it’s just not at its full potential. Impretzively fudged is my favorite flavor
Magical_Olive
Dirt Cake is so good as someone who likes mix ins. I swear there were like 5 whole Oreos in my last cart.
FowlTemptress
Chubby Hubby and Chunky Monkey! I also really like New York Super Fudge Chunk. However, I live in a part of NYC where supermarkets don’t really have a lot of space so there are only approx. 6 flavors to choose from. I almost faint when I visit my retired parents in FL and see the variety in Publix.
ChemistryFit2315
You must not have yet tried fudgy flan
ProfessorPossessed
Not even close. No class
mjgabriellac
My two faves are this Dirt Cake and then Chubby Hubby!!
Retiredandsohappy
Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch
econhistoryrules
Cherry Garcia. Iconic.
brightpinkhat
I need Ice Cream Sammie back today.
FormalGrass8148
You forgot Cherry Garcia and Milk & Cookies
dbqhoney
Ben and Jerry’s are all pretty much the same. Fudge chunks, Oreo cookies, chocolate cookie dough, brownie bites, rinse and repeat.
Marshmallow sky was delicious, and my all time favorite is discontinued: Bovinity Divinity
ForbidInjustice
Americone Dream is definitely top-tier B&J for me.
B-Girl93
Dirt Cake is good but in my freezer now is PB S’more.. it’s so good. I also would get Half Baked or The Tonight Dough or any of the ones with brownie something.
idklikeaburnerorwe
Tried Dirt Cake a while back and it’s easily in my top 5 (that vanilla pudding base is wonderful)! Usually go for Minter Wonderland, Americone Dream, Thick Mint, and Chocolate Therapy
PunnyPrinter
Dirt Cake and Phish food
stripes177
I agree with the chunky monkey 🐒 🍌
_barrakuda2
I’m always going to a phish food girlie. Why? Because it’s basically the only gluten free flavor
PeachThyme
I have never tried dirt cake because I eould get so sad when the ganache layer is gone!
Mine are half baked (the gooey brownie chunks are to DIE for) and milk and cookies!
Dancing_sequin
I really like the Tonight Dough, that still a thing lol
soggy_donut92696
I’m addicted to the dirt cake so so good
JaneEyrewasHere
Phish Food was the first Ben and Jerry’s I ever tried 30 years ago and I have yet to find a flavor that rivals it. Half Baked is a decent second place though.
Affectionate-Soft-90
The only thing you need to add to Dirt Cake is gummy worms.
poop-azz
Dirt Cake is wild good
Reasonable-Ad7755
Im going cherry garcia as my number 1
EatMe200
Your dirt cake looks so much different than the pints of dirt cake I’ve gotten?
ericthedad
It’s Tonight Dough by a HUGE margin. I like a ton of B&J flavors but Tonight Dough is miles ahead of anything else.
Straightdraglover
Dirt cake needs gummy worms
everything_is_cats
My top two favorites are Phish Food and Americone Dream.
I just want ice cream with a reasonable amount of toppings. I refuse to buy any of the Cores, Sundaes, or Topped flavors because all three just seem like an excuses to reduce the amount of actual ice cream for some topping that you could easily add on yourself.
33 Comments
I’d probably go with Oat of this Swirl and Peanut Butter Cup as my two favorites. Dirt Cake is a close 3rd.
Nahh these ain’t the best
The toppers and sundaes, which are being heavily promoted and are taking up more and more of the B&Js display, are their attempt to improve the bottom line by including about 2oz LESS product per pint without reducing cost. Yeah, I know Haagen Dazs did this years ago. But I guess B&Js has now decided “I want a piece of THAT!”
I had Dirt Cake like a month ago and I can’t stop thinking about it. I love the big chunks of cookie, it’s perfect.
I find chunky monkey to be so underwhelming! It could be incredible and it’s just not at its full potential. Impretzively fudged is my favorite flavor
Dirt Cake is so good as someone who likes mix ins. I swear there were like 5 whole Oreos in my last cart.
Chubby Hubby and Chunky Monkey! I also really like New York Super Fudge Chunk. However, I live in a part of NYC where supermarkets don’t really have a lot of space so there are only approx. 6 flavors to choose from. I almost faint when I visit my retired parents in FL and see the variety in Publix.
You must not have yet tried fudgy flan
Not even close. No class
My two faves are this Dirt Cake and then Chubby Hubby!!
Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch
Cherry Garcia. Iconic.
I need Ice Cream Sammie back today.
You forgot Cherry Garcia and Milk & Cookies
Ben and Jerry’s are all pretty much the same. Fudge chunks, Oreo cookies, chocolate cookie dough, brownie bites, rinse and repeat.
No. Sorry.
1. Dulce delish
2. Phish food
3. Bossin cream pie
4. Cherry Garcia
Marshmallow sky was delicious, and my all time favorite is discontinued: Bovinity Divinity
Americone Dream is definitely top-tier B&J for me.
Dirt Cake is good but in my freezer now is PB S’more.. it’s so good. I also would get Half Baked or The Tonight Dough or any of the ones with brownie something.
Tried Dirt Cake a while back and it’s easily in my top 5 (that vanilla pudding base is wonderful)! Usually go for Minter Wonderland, Americone Dream, Thick Mint, and Chocolate Therapy
Dirt Cake and Phish food
I agree with the chunky monkey 🐒 🍌
I’m always going to a phish food girlie. Why? Because it’s basically the only gluten free flavor
I have never tried dirt cake because I eould get so sad when the ganache layer is gone!
Mine are half baked (the gooey brownie chunks are to DIE for) and milk and cookies!
I really like the Tonight Dough, that still a thing lol
I’m addicted to the dirt cake so so good
Phish Food was the first Ben and Jerry’s I ever tried 30 years ago and I have yet to find a flavor that rivals it. Half
Baked is a decent second place though.
The only thing you need to add to Dirt Cake is gummy worms.
Dirt Cake is wild good
Im going cherry garcia as my number 1
Your dirt cake looks so much different than the pints of dirt cake I’ve gotten?
It’s Tonight Dough by a HUGE margin. I like a ton of B&J flavors but Tonight Dough is miles ahead of anything else.
Dirt cake needs gummy worms
My top two favorites are Phish Food and Americone Dream.
I just want ice cream with a reasonable amount of toppings. I refuse to buy any of the Cores, Sundaes, or Topped flavors because all three just seem like an excuses to reduce the amount of actual ice cream for some topping that you could easily add on yourself.