Turkey Hill’s chocolate peanut butter was the BEST ice cream I have ever had. They have recently cheapened out and stopped using real ice cream and the ribbons of peanut butter have also disappeared. I can deal with the dairy desert, but I cannot deal with the paltry amount of peanut butter. There’s hardly any. I would rather spend 8, even 10 dollars for a few quarts of the good stuff than save a few bucks for this new dairy desert garbage. These late night pints with the “real ice cream” label made me excited.. but unfortunately this is garbage too. The ice cream is a dark color and it’s too rich. It’s nothing like the original chocolate ice cream that is lighter in color. There’s zero peanut butter ribbon too . Just these awful waxy peanut butter cups that I chose to spit out. These bits don’t melt very easily .. they taste like chocolate flavored candle wax. (also included a photo of the wax bits that I spit out) where can I get a peanut butter ice cream that was like the old Turkey Hill? What a disappointment
by provisionings
14 Comments
So sad to hear when a favorite ice cream switches up and cuts corners on quality :/ dealt with the same thing with Magnum ice cream bars!! Used to be real vanilla bean ice cream and they switched their formula to be that fake, “frozen dessert” type of ice cream with no lil black vanilla bean specks. Such a shame to hear when other brands cut back.
looks like rabbit droppings
How many calories per serving is it?
Turkey Hill sold out. I won’t ever waste my money on them again.
I miss when they were wonderful.
I swear corporate greed is going to be the death of good icecream.
There was a post not too long ago asking for peanut butter ice cream as well. Haagen-Dazs chocolate and peanut butter got quite a few comments/upvotes recommending it, although I’ve never tried it myself
TURKEY HILL IS THE GOATTTT IDC
I have eaten quite a few of their Late Night pints and have been happy with the ice cream & amount of mix-ins. I’ve probably had this one 4 times. Yes, the chocolate ice cream is darker and richer. This is not their regular premium chocolate peanut butter ice cream which has a lighter less intense chocolate taste, and does not contain any pb cups. This one is better than that one imo. I will continue to buy them.
Oh no! I think I just bought 2 of these because I was so excited about how good it looked. Dang
Oh no! I think I just bought 2 of these because I was so excited about how good it looked. Dang!
The cookie one is good. And this is ice cream the container says ice cream no?
Turkey hill and breyers have always been the nastiest , cheap tasting ice cream to me lol
Hmm I did also get this flavor and got a lot of peanut butter ribbon?