If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.

Natural peanut butter is better for you and just as delicious as the not-so-natural brands, but there’s one problem — it needs to be stirred every time you use it. Because the oils separate from the solids, you have to take a spoon to your natural peanut butter to get it to its spreadable consistency, and that can often lead to oily messes on your countertop.

The solution is this super handy peanut butter mixer that keeps everything contained and leaves your peanut butter perfectly spreadable every single time.

stanley x loveshackfancy august 2025 drop, new stanley x loveshackfancy collection, late summer loveshackfancy x stanley 1913

Related story

Stanley x LoveShackFancy’s End-of-Summer ‘Ibiza Sunset’ Collection Is Now Live — & It’s Their Biggest Drop Yet

Spotted by Food Network, this mixer is made specifically for natural nut butters. It comes with a metal lid that screws right onto your 16-ounce jar with a three-inch mouth and features a simple mixing rod that’s easy to turn thanks to the handle. And when you’re done mixing, the included silicone ring around the center opening keeps all your peanut butter inside the jar.

“For any fans of natural peanut butter, you know the struggle! This is the kind of tool you didn’t even realize you were missing in your life,” the caption of a recent Food Network post reads.

Grandpa Witmer’s Old Fashioned Mess-Free Nut Butter Mixer is going to change the way you consume peanut butter forever. It’s easy to use, easy to clean, and leaves you with perfect, spreadable peanut butter every time you use it.

Food Network Loves This Natural Peanut Butter Mixer From Amazon

Grandpa Witmer’s Old Fashioned Mess-Free Natural Peanut Butter Mixer

“Does exactly what it claims to,” one Amazon reviewer wrote. “For jars of natural peanut butter that separate into oil and peanut butter too thick to get out of the jar, it mixes them very well.”

“This product is just what I have been waiting for!” someone else wrote. “All those years wasted fighting the stiff peanut butter with a knife or a spoon. No more! … I have a little non-slip pad on my kitchen counter, which helped a great deal for the first few turns through the stiff peanut butter. After that, it was a breeze … I love it, love it, love it!!!!!”

And someone else added, “This is a must-have for anyone who likes natural peanut butter. No more mess or struggling to mix the peanuts and the oil … We just leave these on the jar, which makes it even easier — a quick crank or two and you are all set.”

Stop struggling with your natural peanut butters. Use this handy crank, and you’ll never have to suffer through the dreaded stir again!

Satisfy your sweet tooth with more awesome Costco bakery items seen in the gallery below.

Dining and Cooking