The peanut butter base is delicious, plus the swirls of caramel and chocolate covered pretzels elevate it and add a nice flavor and texture. Also they skimped on absolutely nothing, this thing is packed with the chocolate covered pretzels and caramel.
by Sharp_Athlete_6847
19 Comments
Yes, I agree, it’s great
Great flavor even though it can be a bit too sweet and decadent once you’ve eaten over half the pint, which is what I usually end up doing lol. It really does make me feel like I’m eating the ice cream version of a candy bar.
Yeah this stuff is goood. I wish they made a version with chocolate ice cream and peanut butter swirls with the pretzels and caramel as well as one with vanilla with peanut butter swirls and chocolate swirls with the chocolate covered pretzels and caramel swirls.
What store can you get this brand at?
https://preview.redd.it/r5lbd08g9tof1.png?width=680&format=png&auto=webp&s=1c5bb0a3a706d7afbebdb8771ffadf80594dbca4
This must be their spin on a Reese’s Take 5! I’ll have to try it soon
What’s grocery store did you get it from? My local dropped this flavor and i cant seem to find it anywhere now.
Damn good, never disappoints me
I thought it was a bit too heavy on the peanut butter flavor but the mix ins are good
It’s just like a Take 5 candy bar. Very good
Perfectly salted too. And I love that the mix-ins are generous without being annoying
It’s easily their best flavor
Jeni’s never lets me down. Thank you, Jeni 😍
I wanted to like this bc I love jeni’s and this is right up my alley but I find this flavor kinda dry/chalky and I thought the pretzels tasted weirdly stale. Maybe i had a bad batch.
It’s so good. I’m not huge peanut butter lover but I’m obsessed with this flavor. It’s decadent but not over-the-top heavy
I remember I got this just because it was on sale one week. What a great week that was.
one of my fav home ice creams to have yummm
it looks amazing. having finally sampled a pint of jeni’s i know the ten dollars they demand is not wasted.
it really is chronic as hell
Literally just ate this flavor for the first time tonight. I’m not the biggest PB ice cream fan, but the pretzel and caramel mix-ins compliment it so well that I couldn’t stop eating it. Might have to add it to my ice cream rotation