Blue Bell never misses in my opinion but this is one is exceptional. If you’re a fan of the cookie, you will not be disappointed! The ice cream itself is not just vanilla, it tastes like the cookie but with hints of like graham/gingerbread to me and there’s chunks of oatmeal creme pie throughout. 10/10.
by dominiccast
10 Comments
……..wait till you try The Pecan Pie one. The Oatmeal Cream Pie is awesome, love it would marry it.
I love the gooey butter cake one
Looks delicious and I might have to pick this up.
Yes this flavor is like no other. Amazing!
I keep seeing this, i just need to buy it. One of those flavors that could be amazing or just really bad
Easily one of their best flavors since 2020
This would be so good with some apple crisp 🤤
This is one of my favorites from Blue Bell! I really want to try the new Pecan Pie one, but haven’t seen it near me yet.
Wow this flavor just really a something. Wanting to buy right now….
Interesting, I’ll have to see if it’s in my area