Mediterranean Seafood, Butter Storage, and More | Full Episode | America’s Test Kitchen (S24 E26)

Becky Hays shows Bridget Lancaster how pan-roasting fish is the quickest way to make delicious cod, topped with a green olive, almond and orange relish. Adam Ried discusses which infrared thermometers are most accurate. Lisa McManus tests butter bells and storage containers to see which kept butter fresh and spreadable. Finally, Dan Souza shows Julia Collin Davison a sweet and savory North African style dish for monkfish, braised with aromatic saffron, cured olives, and orange zest.

Pan-Roasted Cod with Green Olive, Almond, and Orange Relish Recipe: https://cooks.io/3JJypmc
Braised Monkfish with Saffron and Cured Olives Recipe: https://cooks.io/45K6fA9

The Best Infrared Thermometers: https://cooks.io/4lTqb8s
Best Buy: https://cooks.io/4p2zfuv

Butter Storage Containers: https://cooks.io/46a5L5w
Winner: https://cooks.io/463m2sT

00:00 Intro
07:46 Best Infrared Thermometer
11:39 Best Butter Case
14:03 Braised Monkfish Recipe

Subscribe to ATK Full Episodes: https://youtube.com/@ATKFullEpisodes?sub_confirmation=1 ​

Discover more rigorously tested recipes like those shown in this episode on the America’s Test Kitchen App: https://cooks.io/41U3KZF

Get exclusive access to every recipe, review, and more via our homepage: https://cooks.io/4p3y8L9

Buy The Complete America’s Test Kitchen TV Show Cookbook 2001–2026: https://cooks.io/4n4KHE6

Discover the latest recipes, tips, and tricks from Cook’s Insider: https://cooks.io/3JGFe8e

Subscribe to Cook’s Illustrated: https://cooks.io/4oUC80m

Watch More!​
Cook’s Country: https://youtube.com/watch?v=aq-PTfsokrw&list=PL5OCJ46MPEbsRY3B8XlFJR4NWRbRwWq61 ​
Julia At Home: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL5OCJ46MPEbumBCWw_mLGQLn3hQPQW3bb ​
America’s Test Kitchen: https://www.youtube.com/@AmericasTestKitchen

​Follow America’s Test Kitchen: ​​
Instagram: https://instagram.com/testkitchen ​​
Pinterest: https://pinterest.com/testkitchen ​​
TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@testkitchen?lang=en ​​
Facebook: https://facebook.com/americastestkitchen ​​
Twitter: https://twitter.com/testkitchen ​​

At America’s Test Kitchen, we investigate every aspect of cooking—recipes, equipment, ingredients, and techniques—with a goal to empower and inspire home cooks. Since 1992, our team of 50+ cooks, editors, and culinary creatives ask a lot of questions—and do a lot of testing—so that you get dependable, delicious recipes, comprehensive guidance, and thorough and unbiased equipment and ingredient reviews. You can find us in the pages of Cook’s Illustrated magazine, on our television shows America’s Test Kitchen and Cook’s Country, in dozens of best-selling cookbooks, and via the 14,000+ recipes, reviews, and classes available on our website and app. Whether you’re in search of a great weeknight meal or an impressive dinner-party dish, we’ve done the testing to deliver reliable recipes and comprehensive cooking info to your home kitchen. Bring your curiosity, and we’ll make you a better cook.

#AmericasTestKitchen #FullEpisode #FoodScience

[Music] Today on America’s Test Kitchen, Becky makes Bridget pan roasted cod with green olive, almond, and orange relish. Adam reviews infrared thermometers. Lisa reviews butter storage containers. And Dan makes Julia brazed monkfish with saffron and cured olives. It’s all coming up right here on America’s Test Kitchen. [Music] Hand roasted fish when done well is the epitome of high reward for low effort. But things can go wrong. And that’s when you call your fairy cod mother as I have. Becky’s here and she’s going to show us how to pan roast fish the right way. I love that title, by the way. I’ll take yours. I’ll take it. Yeah. This is a foolproof recipe. The fish will be nice and moist, well browned, and cod is lean and mild. So, we’re going to be making a Greek olive relish to go with it. Oo, that sounds great. Yeah. really good. So easy. Okay, so let’s start by making the relish. All right, we have half a cup of green brined olives. They’ve been pitted. Half a cup of toasted slivered almonds. This will give a nice bit of crunch to the relish. Nice. And then a teaspoon of grated orange zest. Now orange and olive goes beautifully together. Gorgeous. This is going to be a really nice complent to that lean fish. And then just one small garlic clove that’s been minced up. Okay. Okay. So, I’ll just pulse this about 10 times in the processor. All right. There we go. You can see the olives and the nuts still have a little bit of texture. And you can smell that orange zest already. It’s so fragrant. Well, I love that the flavors you’re using are very, very fresh because you don’t want to mask cod, any kind of fish really, but especially cod because it’s so lightly flavored. Yeah. It’s so delicate. So, this is just a really nice mix of flavors here. All right. Now I have 1/4 cup of extra virgin olive oil and 1/4 cup of orange juice. More orange. Yeah. So I just zested the orange first and then got some juice. Two teaspoons of white wine vinegar just to brighten things up a little bit. And then just a little bit of cayenne. Not even going to add all of it. I just want a little bit. Just a little pinch just to give the barest hint of spice in the background. Pinch of a pinch. A pinch of a pinch. That’s it. All right. That looks pretty good. That was pretty easy, right Bridget? Yes. Okay. And now I just have some mint. Some fresh mint leaves. I know. You want a sniff? Orange and mint. Yeah. So, we want a/4 cup. The way I chop fresh mint, I just ball it up like this. And then go through it in one direction and kind of turn it and go in another direction. Lovely. Oh, smells great. Lots of good smells going on. We haven’t even turned on the stove yet. That looks pretty good to me. It sure does. I’m going to put that into the relish. So, that’s a/4 cup. Just going to season it with a little bit of salt. Doesn’t need much because those olives have a fair bit of salt. Right. And that is ready to go. All right, let’s cook this fish. They are beautiful. They’re gorgeous, aren’t they? Nice cod fililelets. I made sure to get fillets that were at least an inch thick. An inch and a half would be good as well. Filelets that are too thin will just overcook with this method. And you never get them brown enough. Exactly. Okay. So, at least one inch thick. You can use snapper. You could also use sea bass. Okay. With coda is my favorite. These are four to six ounce fililelets. I’m just want to pat them dry. That’s one of the keys of getting good browning is making sure that it’s nice and dry. Absolutely. All right. Another way that we’re going to help these guys brown is I’m going to sprinkle them with a half teaspoon of sugar. When that sugar hits the pan, it’s going to help to caramelize really quickly. Half a teaspoon divided among the four fillets here. And this won’t make the fish taste sweet at all. It’ll just make it nice and brown. Going to give them some salt as well. And some pepper. So, I made sure to season the side that I want to serve presentation side up. This is the nice rounded side. So, this is the side that I want to have that nice browning. So, we’re going to brown the fish. I have a tablespoon of oil in a non-stick skillet here. This is an oven safe skillet. We’re going to sear it on the stove and then put it in the oven. So once that oil starts to shimmer, which I see is just about happening, we’ll put these guys in. And we’ll put them in sugared side down. That’s a good sound. That’s a great sound. I like how you’re capturing some of the oil as you put that in, too. Yep. I want to help with that browning. Another thing I’m going to do is I’m going to press down on the fish a little bit. Okay. I want to make sure we have good contact with the bottom of the skillet. Gotcha. So, we’re going to let these brown for 2 minutes and then we’ll flip them over. Okay. All right. It’s been 2 minutes. Let’s take a peek. And you can see I’m I’m not using non-stick spatulas here. I’m just going to be really careful with the pan. Oh, I’m happy with that. Beautiful color. Yeah, I like your flipping technique, too. Yeah, two spatulas is really helpful here. Oh, look at that. Oh, these are perfect. Non-stick pan makes this very easy. That was just two minutes. Two minutes. And that’s because of the sugar, right? So, those look gorgeous. I’m going to put these into a 425 degree oven for 7 to 10 minutes until they reach 140° and they’ll be nice and moist and tender and perfect. Okay, it’s been 7 minutes. Let’s take a peek. Oo, those are gorgeous, aren’t they? They are gorgeous. Let’s check. And we want about 140 for the temperature here. All right, 140. Nice. All right, these on a platter here. That’s okay. You can see that flakes apart a little bit. But that just means that it’s perfectly cooked. So that’s fine with me. Yes. I’m just adding some lemon wedges around the edge there. Okay. I’m going to give you this nice end piece. I think it’s the best one. I always want my guests to have the best one. There you go. And we have to have this beautiful olive relish. Yes. Nice generous scoop of that on the side. I’m so glad you didn’t just dollop it on the fish because that’s a beautiful crust. Yeah. We don’t want to hide that beautiful browning that we got. Bonapetit. I don’t even think it needs the lemon. You could squeeze it on there, but we have this beautiful relish. Mhm. Oh, that is so good. That fish so juicy. You can see how juicy it is. It’s perfectly tender. The browning is gorgeous. And then this relish just compliments it. The fresh mint, the olives. This is fine dining quality food. Even better. So, you got to make it at home. That’s right. Gorgeous. You’re the codmother. I earned my title, right? You absolutely do. Thanks so much, Becky. My pleasure. If you want to make this beautiful dish at home, it starts with using cod fillets that are at least 1 in thick. Sprinkle the fish with a little sugar to speed up browning and use both the stove top and the oven to cook the fish through. So, from America’s Test Kitchen and the fairy cod mother herself, it’s pan roasted cod with green olive, almond, and orange relish. M m. Bibbidity bobby. Yes. Oh yeah. Love what you’re watching? Take your cooking to the next level with our essential membership. Get instant access to thousands of recipes, tips, techniques, product reviews, and step-by-step videos. Our members app allows you to search by ingredient, set dietary preferences, and save your favorite recipes. For those looking to level up, our newest feature, ATK classes, offers more in-depth instruction led by ATK experts so you can gain greater confidence in the kitchen. Start your free trial by visiting the app store or going to americaskitchen.com/youtube today. [Music] Well, we have the equipment to take the temperature of our food, but what about the cooking surfaces? Adam’s here and he’s gonna tell us about infrared thermometers. I thought maybe you were training to be a state trooper there. Maybe I could talk myself out of speeding tickets. Infrared thermometers, what these do is they take the temperature of a surface really quickly and from a distance so you don’t have to touch it. They’re used a lot in industry. They’re used with machinery, duct work to spot check hot and cold spots that can give you an idea if there’s some sort of problem. They’re also used in commercial kitchens. And we were wondering whether they had a place in the home kitchen, too. And if so, which one is best? We have this lineup of seven. Price range was $24 to $162. Big range. Big range. We tested these on both cast iron skillets like this one and stainless steel skillets. We read four different temperatures. 68°, 310°, 450°, and 1,50°. It’s a thermometer, so accuracy is important to test. The best ones here, if they’re used carefully, were accurate within about three degrees of the true temperature. Oh, okay. If used carefully is an interesting point, though, because some of these were off by more than 100°, that is not their fault because the accuracy is susceptible to a lot of different factors. You need to be careful and sort of develop your set of best practices for using these. Some of those factors are, but not limited to how reflective the surface is, the humidity in the air, how thick the air is, the angle at which you’re temping. You want to try and get right over whatever is you’re temping so it’s perpendicular. So, we consider these good for giving you a ballpark reading. And that can be useful. Definitely. If you want to see if your grill is heated up or if you’re using a double burner griddle, you want to see which spots are cold, which spots are warm. Spot checking a freezer or a refrigerator for warm and cold spots. Any kind of surface that you’re cooking on, whether it’s a preheated skillet or a baking stone in the oven or even an outdoor pizza oven. Great for that kind of thing, too. So the way these work is they actually measure energy that’s radiating from the surface and convert that into a temperature. That energy is called emissivity and it ranges from zero to one. You can go online and find a chart. Different materials have different emissivity ratings. And we found that the more accurate infrared thermometers allows you to adjust for the emissivity of whatever the material you were temping. Gotcha. But you got to do a little homework. Got to do a little homework. Got to go online, find out what the emissivity is. So, aside from the accuracy issues, there are a couple of design factors that made some easier to use than others. They all operate with a laser beam or two, just to give you an indication of where you’re temping. It helps you aim. Our favorite one had a laser beam and a circle around it, like a bullseye. It was actually much easier to see than a single or a double beam, even in broad daylight. This one was also adjustable for the emissivity. And the handle, believe it or not, made a difference to our testers. It was sort of a medium thickness, medium length. People with different sized hands all found it comfortable. Some of the others were a little too small, a little too chunky. This is our winning infrared thermometer. It’s the ThermoWorks industrial IR with circle laser. It’s got an emissivity adjustment. If you use it according to best practices, it’s accurate to within 1.7 degrees. There you go. A little homework and the right equipment, you can tell the temperature of your skillet and so much more. And our winner is the Therma Works Industrial IR with Circle Laser and it runs about $90. [Music] In the test kitchen, we fly through cases of butter. But at home, a single stick can last for weeks. Over time, butter can absorb flavors and odors from nearby foods if it’s not stored properly. So, we tested butter storage containers in two styles: dishes and bells. Now, butter bells originated in France, and they’re always used at room temperature. You pack the croc upside down with softened butter and you fill this with a small amount of water. This forms an airtight seal. Now, you do have to change the water every few days to keep the butter beautifully spreadable. Just look at this. Now, we tested this assortment of butter bells, tasting the butter every day. All the bells kept butter fresh for two weeks, but our favorite was this one, the original butterbell croc. This large, easy to grab knob gave it an edge over these other butter bells. Its flared shape is simple to fill and use, and butter stayed fresh and spreadable throughout our testing. We also tested butter dishes both in the refrigerator and at room temperature. As a control, we stored a stick of butter in the fridge and at room temperature, but kept them in their original wrappers. We checked all the butters every day looking for signs of spoilage. Now, first we found that every container did better than the original wrappers. Next, we found that dishes kept butter fine at room temperature for two weeks, just like the butter bells. But in the fridge, they worked for about three weeks, and one dish lasted a full month. And that’s our winner, the lock and lock rectangular food container and tray. These flaps seal tightly to keep butter extra fresh. It’s meant to be used upside down, so the lid doubles as a flat surface of the butter. It even has these measurement markings right on the bottom. Now, with either of our winners, your butter will stay fresher longer. Love our in-depth reviews? Get the latest from our reviews team delivered straight to your inbox. Our welle equipped cook newsletter provides top product picks, nononsense buying guides, and must try recipes. No extra fluff, just the smartest ways to shop, save, and cook. Sign up for free now at americasestkitchen.com/newsletter. [Music] Monkfish is a very meaty, sturdy fish that is perfect for brazing. And today, Dan’s going to show us how. So, I love monkfish. It’s such an interesting fish. Great texture, and it really does hold up well to brazing. Today we’re going to work with a lot of kind of North African flavors to build this. So it’s going to be really complex, sweet, savory, really aromatic. So I’m going to start with the aromatics. And I have one onion here, which I’m going to have and then slice pole to pole into about quarter inch thick slices. Okay. Okay. Great. So we’ve got our onions cut. We’re going to work with carrots as well. This actually plays into that kind of savory and sweet thing we’re talking about. So very savory with the onions. This is going to add some natural sweetness to the dish. So, I’m going to slice these down the center into two. Okay, I’m going to slice these a quarter inch thick. I’m hearing the sound of a very sharp knife. It is making a really lovely crack through those carrots. Carrots can be a tough vegetable to cut through if you have a dull knife. So, this is nice and easy. Add this to my bowl with the onions. Now, we’re going to work with an orange. This is going to add some lovely aroma to it. It’s also going to hit a little bit more on that sweetness profile, and it’s going to work in a couple of different ways in the dish. So, I’m going to use my peeler to take off nice wide strips here. Orange zest. Orange zest. Okay. So, two of these are going to go into the bowl with the other aromatics. And this third one here, I’m going to mince really fine. And we’re going to mix it with some garlic. Oo. So, this is going to go into our bowl with a teaspoon of minced garlic. We’re actually going to save this and it’s going to go in at the very end of cooking. Ah, a nice bright hit at the end. So, we have 2 tablespoons of extra-virgin olive oil over medium high heat and we want it to just shimmer. which you can kind of see it happening now. We’re going to go in with all of our aromatics. And 1/4 teaspoon of salt, you know, with the orange in there. That really is an interesting brazing profile. A little bit different than maybe what you’ve had before for braised fish. Yeah. So, I actually grew up eating brazed monk fish. We had it a lot. Yeah. My mother always brazed it in a tomato broth, though. Oh, I love it. With a little bit of paprika. Yeah. It was kind of a standard dish in our house. So, I’m excited to see it done another way because I it really never dawned on me to make it different than she always made it. That’s great. Yeah, it’s going to have some of the same flavors. We have paprika and tomato paste going in, but yeah, a few other things going on as well. So, we’re going to cook this until everything is nice and soft and a little bit of browning, which is going to be nice for flavor. Takes anywhere from 10 to 12 minutes. All right, this is looking beautiful. You can see there’s some fond on the bottom there. Everything’s nice and wilted and the onions get a little bit sweeter when you cook them that way. So, that’s going to help out the dish a lot. Awesome. So, now let’s turn our focus to the monk fish. It’s not a looker. It’s not a looker in any way, right? If you’ve ever seen a whole monk fish, oh, they’re evil looking, massive head and huge teeth. They’re an interesting fish. They’re a bottom dweller and they’re like an assassin, like attack hunter, right? And so, they don’t move a lot, but when they do, they can go really quickly. And their muscle structure is really unique. I think that kind of almost lobster-like texture that some people attribute to it, it comes from that. And it’s going to hold up really well. It’s not the kind of fish that flakes apart. So, brazing is a perfect thing to do with it. So, when you’re shopping for monkfish, you’re only going to see the tail portion. If you see it like this at the supermarket, this means that it has the membrane still attached. Hasn’t been peeled yet. Hasn’t been peeled. And it’s something you can do at home, but I don’t know, it’s kind of a mess. And a lot of times you end up taking off more fish than you’d like. So, highly, highly recommend having your fish monger or whoever’s behind the fish counter do it for you. And then you should have something that looks like this, right? So, really, really clean. And this is what we’re going to work with. All right. So, we’re just going to cut this into manageable pieces about 3 in in length. So, we’ll probably get three out of this piece here. How many pounds of monk fish is this? This is 1 and a2 pounds. So, I’m going to pat this nice and dry. And we’re just going to season it with salt and pepper. Black pepper is a really nice component of this dish, too, just in terms of how it balances out some of the sweetness. That really nice heat and sweet is always nice. All right, so I’m just going to flip these over and repeat. And now that everything’s beautiful and soft in here, we’re going to add the rest of our sauce ingredients. We’re going to start with four teaspoons of minced garlic. Got a tablespoon of tomato paste. Again, lots of richness and savoriness, but some sweetness as well. Mhm. And I’ve got 1 and 1/4 teaspoons of paprika. 1 teaspoon of ground cumin, half a teaspoon of dried mint. Then I have quarter teaspoon of saffron. Oh, hello. Quarter teaspoon. Quarter teaspoon. Ah, nice. I up the Annie there a little. Yeah, you did. Right. Oh, saffron and a braze is the best. Especially when there’s fish in it because you can really taste that nuanced fragrance of the saffron. I don’t like it when it gets covered up with lots of big meaty things. Exactly. Yep. Okay, great. We’re just cooking this until it’s fragrant. And that has already happened. Smells pretty fragrant to me. Great. So, now we’re going to do a little deglazing with one 8 oz bottle of clam juice. You know, seafood broth out there isn’t generally very good. And clam juice is really consistent and adds just some nice background brininess. It’s not going to come off as clam chowder or anything, but adds a lot of flavor here. And then you can use that. You can scrape up all of that fond once it gets delazed. There. Going to add our monkfish now and just kind of nestle this into the liquid. Make sure that it’s got good contact. Oh, that smells good. Damn. Doesn’t it? Yeah. Already. And I’m just going to spoon a little bit of the sauce over the top. Get that nice and incorporated so it’s not just unseasoned on top there. Makes sense. You’re going to have to flip the fish over during cooking or just leave it be. Just leave it be. Let it ride. Yeah. Let it ride. And you know the thing is like brazing most of the time it takes forever, right? It’s this big project. You’re like, I’m going to braze something in the winter. What’s great about fish is it cooks so quickly. You get like that comfort and that homeiness but in a fraction of the time. And usually we braze in the oven, but I don’t see the oven on behind you. No need. This is a good summertime dish. You know, you don’t have to turn your oven on. It’s not going to heat up your kitchen very much. So, we’re going to let this cook until the monkfish hits 140°. That’s really important. A lot of people think about temping with just like steaks and meat, but with fish, it’s just as important. And that’s going to make sure we have really tender, juicy results. It’s going to be perfectly cooked. And that’s going to take anywhere from 8 to 12 minutes. Okay, let’s check out our fish. Oh, what a nice simmer. Smells good, too. It does. All right. So, I’m going to take our temp here. We’re looking for about 140. All right. There we go. We’re at 142. Not bad. Nice. Not spot on, but really nice there. So, I’m going to turn the heat off. And then I’m going to go fishing for our orange zest strips. They’ve done their job. They’ve contributed lots of flavor. So, our final components. We’ve got lots of cooked, rich flavors in there. And a lot of this is going to add brightness and kind of pops of complimentary flavor. So, we first have 1/4 cup of chopped oil cured olives. Oil cured is not the best name for them. That’s kind of a misnomer. They’re actually salt cured, but they’re really rich and dense. You know, there’s no liquid to kind of dilute anything. So, they’re going to add a lot of nice salinity and a lot of richness, too. Then, we’ve got two tablespoons of fresh mint that’s been chopped. Oh, so fresh mint to compliment the dried mint that you put in earlier. Double mint. Double mint fish. And then for some acidity, a teaspoon of cherry vinegar. M. And then finally, we have our garlic and orange zest mixture from before. Mhm. So, this is where we’re going to get fresh orange flavor and that little bit of nice punch from that garlic. Yeah. A little kick. Little kick. So, we’re going to gently just stir this in. Oh, yeah. It’s almost like a folding motion really more than anything. Beautiful. Oh, that smells delicious. Just do a quick taste for seasoning. It needs a little salt. Does it? Mhm. And a little bit of more pepper. That’s really our only heat in the dish. So, it’s nice to have good amount of pepper in there. All right, I’m going to give you this really nice big piece here. Oh, thank you. Lots of beautiful vegetables. That is beautiful, isn’t it? It’s gorgeous. And really, not that much effort involved. No. I’m going to go and put some of the sauce first. I just want to get a sense of the flavors. Oh, I love it. You do? I do. The carrots, the onions, but then the saffron, and then a little bit of that oil cured olive, and then the mint. It’s a complex mixture of flavors. Well, and the fish is perfectly cooked. I love that monkfish texture. It’s so nice. It’s so unique among white fish, but it’s got the nice resiliency. Yes. You know, in that kind of lobsterish way. In that lobstery way. Damn, this is lovely. Thank you. You’re welcome. So, if you want to make brazed monk fish, pull out your Dutch oven and build a flavorful brazing liquid using a variety of spices and clam juice. And simmer the fish until it reaches 140°. from America’s Test Kitchen. Brazed monkfish with saffron and olives. You can get this recipe and all the recipes from this season along with select episodes and our product reviews at our website americaaskitchen.com/tv. I’m going to make this for my mother. She I think she would like the updated sauce. If you’re ready to take your cooking to the next level, head over to americasestkitchen.com and get a free trial of our ATK essential membership. While you’re there, you can sign up for our free email newsletters and download our app. So, what are you waiting for?