Canola oil. Medium pot. Gas stove. Brought oil to 375 F. Thought I'd be smart and just watch the color and pull them when they're "restaurant brown" (the 7 at the far end of the dish).

When I dropped them the oil temp dropped to 300 F and never reached 375 before pulling the wings.

After they finally browned enough (30 min or more) they were terribly overcooked. So, I start Googling.

Most results indicate about 12-15 min for refrigerator-cold wings in 375 F oil. This is what I did for the second batch. I even pulled several and stuck them with a digital thermometer which showed about 180° internal. They were perfect…but very pale. Nothing like the browned wings I usually get in a restaurant.

So what did I do wrong? Wrong oil? Inaccurate candy thermometer that I used on the pot?

That pale batch was delicious and I'll be happy eating them like that from now on. I'm just wondering how the restaurants get them so brown without overcooking.

by MSStateDawg

12 Comments

  1. Mrcheeeeeeeeeze

    8 minutes in 375 oil. Maybe a minute or 2 longer because the temp dropped. For extra crisp, dry the skin.

  2. jackburtonsnakeplskn

    Ok, former restaurant employee and current home/tailgate wing maker here. You gotta get the oil to 400. When you drop the wings it’s like putting ice cubes in a drink. I drop my wings at 400, the temp usually goes down to about 350ish then starts to climb again. The key is that when your temp drops to turn up the heat source so it doesn’t go to far. Ideally you want to keep the temp between 350 and 400 for the 12ish minutes. 

  3. If you had the time I actually prefer to par-bake the wings in a low oven, like 300-325 for 35-40 minutes. By this time the fat is rendered and the wings are essentially cooked. Then I’ll either pop them in the fridge for a bit or at least pat thoroughly dry, then fry at 375-400 for a few minutes until crispy. (If you have a grill or smoker that’s even better than the oven step).

  4. Individual_Client985

    Buy bettet quality wings. I love Stater Brothers buffalo marinated and plain, then I blacken them…

  5. Fit-Inflation-7693

    I got you my winga. I’ll just tell you my process and you extract what you will from it. I break my wangz down and put them in a bowl to pat dry with paper towels. Season them if you want but at minimum do salt and cornstarch. Place them on a wire rack with a baking sheet underneath to catch the chicken squirt. I let them decompress for 24 hours in the fridge to dry out . When I fry I bring the temp up to 375 but more importantly I DONT CROWD THE PAN. I fry 7 at a time so the temperature doesn’t drop as much. You want that earl at a minimum 330 F after each batch and you want it to climb up to close to 375 F. I do 12-15 minutes per batch depending on how crispy I want them. Next I baptize them in franks with butter served with a side of celery, baby carrots, and Ken’s chunky blue cheese. Finally the most important step is to grab a roll of paper towels, take off your shirt, slip off your pants, and pop in your blu-ray copy of the King of Queens season 2 or whatever season you left off the last time you made buffalo wings. And enjoy.

  6. Marinade your wings
    Get a good oil
    Get oil to 375 to 400 degrees
    Cook partially then take out and let cool for a few minutes in the fridge or freezer
    Then drop them back in the oil
    This will make them crispy.
    Find your favorite sauce and W

  7. Seasonings exist for a reason. Stop frying bare naked wings.

  8. Quantumentangled

    Pur some seasoning on those! It looks like they are trying to reassemble and reach your spice cabinet.