My first time trying pumpkin-flavored ice cream of any brand so I have nothing to compare this to. I found this B&J flavor enjoyable. I’ll be seeking other pumpkin cheesecake ice creams to taste and compare this one to but I’ll definitely have this one again this season. 🍨
Healthy_Attitude_533
I tried this last year and I liked it! I tried it again a week ago, just for seasonal fun, and I really enjoyed it! I feel like this flavor was great and the graham cracker crumbs were an added bonus.
potsieharris
They sold this in my college store. It was like crack to me.
15 years later I recently tried it and it was quite good, but not as crazy amazing as I remember. Not sure if they changed the recipe or I just don’t have as many tastebuds as before or what.
druscilla333
Aw hell yeah. If it’s anything as amazing and the strawberry cheesecake I am so excited to get my hands on it!
AppUnwrapper1
I so want to buy some pumpkin ice cream but I see I have no self control around pints. 😞
cocolimenuts
This and the salted pecan pie are my favorite seasonals.
Anxious_Beaver15
I like pumpkin flavored treats, but for some reason pumpkin ice cream just doesn’t do it for me. I feel like I want those flavors in something warm and toasty
AndyPandyRu
Strawberry Cheesecake is my favorite but this is a very close second. I’m still waiting for it to show up this year, here in Colorado. I’ve been checking the stores in my area for the last couple weeks and still none on the shelves.
IDunnoReallyIDont
Cheesecake pieces would’ve made this perfect!
ryoukiddingmi
The Target brand Pumpkin Cheesecake is $2.99 where I live and it’s awesome!! Tried it for the first time this week and I love it
edit: Also, my pint had a toooon of graham cracker pieces in it
yellowzonker
It’s still pretty good but they’ve drastically reduced the graham cracker swirl, which is disappointing.
11 Comments
My first time trying pumpkin-flavored ice cream of any brand so I have nothing to compare this to. I found this B&J flavor enjoyable. I’ll be seeking other pumpkin cheesecake ice creams to taste and compare this one to but I’ll definitely have this one again this season. 🍨
I tried this last year and I liked it! I tried it again a week ago, just for seasonal fun, and I really enjoyed it! I feel like this flavor was great and the graham cracker crumbs were an added bonus.
They sold this in my college store. It was like crack to me.
15 years later I recently tried it and it was quite good, but not as crazy amazing as I remember. Not sure if they changed the recipe or I just don’t have as many tastebuds as before or what.
Aw hell yeah. If it’s anything as amazing and the strawberry cheesecake I am so excited to get my hands on it!
I so want to buy some pumpkin ice cream but I see I have no self control around pints. 😞
This and the salted pecan pie are my favorite seasonals.
I like pumpkin flavored treats, but for some reason pumpkin ice cream just doesn’t do it for me. I feel like I want those flavors in something warm and toasty
Strawberry Cheesecake is my favorite but this is a very close second. I’m still waiting for it to show up this year, here in Colorado. I’ve been checking the stores in my area for the last couple weeks and still none on the shelves.
Cheesecake pieces would’ve made this perfect!
The Target brand Pumpkin Cheesecake is $2.99 where I live and it’s awesome!! Tried it for the first time this week and I love it
edit: Also, my pint had a toooon of graham cracker pieces in it
It’s still pretty good but they’ve drastically reduced the graham cracker swirl, which is disappointing.