When most people think of Tuscany, they picture rolling hills, Chianti vineyards, and maybe a plate of tagliatelle al tartufo (truffle pasta) washed down with a glass of red wine.
And don’t get me wrong—those are worth the hype. But the thing about Tuscan food is that its soul isn’t found in the glossy restaurant menus built for tourists.
It’s in the quiet, humble dishes the locals grow up eating.
I learned that the hard way.
On my first trip to Florence, I ordered what every traveler does: Florentine steak, bruschetta, and a bottle of Chianti Classico.
Solid choices—but it wasn’t until an old trattoria owner convinced me to try pappa al pomodoro that I really tasted Tuscany.
Since then, I’ve made it a rule to skip at least one “safe” dish and order what the locals are having.
So, here are nine traditional Tuscan dishes that rarely make it to tourists’ tables—but absolutely should.
1) Pappa al pomodoro
It doesn’t get humbler than this: stale bread, ripe tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, and basil. That’s it.
But like a lot of Italian cooking, the magic is in the simplicity—and in using ingredients at their peak.
Pappa al pomodoro is basically a thick tomato-bread soup, born out of cucina povera, the “poor kitchen” tradition that defines so much of Tuscany’s comfort food.
Locals usually eat it warm in winter or chilled in summer, and it’s one of those dishes that instantly transports you to someone’s grandmother’s kitchen.
It’s hearty, rich, and almost creamy from the soaked bread.
Most tourists overlook it because it doesn’t look fancy. No meat, no cheese pull, no “Instagram moment.”
But one spoonful, and you get a lesson in how to turn scraps into gold—something the best chefs (and maybe the best people) all know how to do.
2) Ribollita
If pappa al pomodoro is the starter course of Tuscan simplicity, ribollita is the masterclass.
The name literally means “reboiled,” and that’s exactly what it is—a stew of day-old bread, beans, and vegetables that’s reheated the next day for even deeper flavor.
Locals make it with cavolo nero (Tuscan kale), carrots, onions, and cannellini beans.
It’s thick enough to stand a spoon in, and every bite feels like it’s been simmered in centuries of farmhouse kitchens.
When I asked a Florentine friend why more travelers don’t order it, she laughed and said, “Because it’s ugly.”
She’s right. It’s brownish, mushy, and rustic—but that’s the point. Ribollita is comfort in edible form.
It’s also a reminder that great food isn’t always photogenic—and great experiences rarely are, either.
3) Pici cacio e pepe
Everyone knows cacio e pepe, the Roman dish of pasta, cheese, and pepper.
But few realize Tuscany has its own spin, made with pici, a hand-rolled pasta from Siena that’s thicker, chewier, and about as far from machine-made spaghetti as it gets.
Watching a nonna roll pici by hand is an art form—she doesn’t measure, she just feels it. And that’s exactly what this dish is about: feel.
The sauce clings to the rough texture of the pasta like it was born for it.
Most tourists skip over it in favor of tagliatelle al ragù or carbonara, but pici cacio e pepe is Tuscany’s quiet rebellion against perfection.
It’s a bit uneven, a bit rustic, and completely unforgettable.
It’s also a good metaphor for life: the imperfect things often end up being the most satisfying.
4) Lampredotto
Here’s where things get divisive.
Lampredotto is Florence’s most famous street food—but it’s also one of the least ordered by foreigners.
It’s made from the fourth stomach of a cow, slow-cooked in broth, sliced thin, and served in a sandwich with spicy or herb sauce.
Sounds intimidating, right? But here’s the thing: locals love it.
You’ll find businessmen and construction workers alike lined up at tiny lampredottai carts around the city, scarfing it down on their lunch break.
I was hesitant the first time I tried it. Then I took a bite—and it was tender, flavorful, and surprisingly comforting.
It tastes like Tuscany itself: earthy, honest, and a little wild.
Not everything delicious comes wrapped in truffle shavings.
Sometimes it’s served from a food cart and eaten standing up, surrounded by locals who know you’re about to be converted.
5) Cinghiale in umido
If Tuscany had a signature scent, it would be cinghiale in umido simmering in a pot somewhere in the countryside.
This slow-cooked wild boar stew is rich, gamey, and deeply aromatic, flavored with red wine, juniper berries, and herbs.
You’ll find it in mountain towns like Montalcino or Volterra, especially in autumn when hunting season is in full swing.
It’s a dish that speaks to the region’s love of bold, earthy flavors and the balance between nature and nurture.
So why don’t travelers order it more often? Probably because they stick to pasta or pizza—and that’s fine. But if you want to experience Tuscany’s soul, this is the dish to do it.
It’s the kind of meal that demands slow eating and good company—two things we could all use more of.
6) Crostini di fegatini
Every Tuscan nonna has her version of this: toasted bread topped with a smooth chicken liver pâté that’s equal parts rich and rustic.
It’s often served as part of an antipasto platter, but most travelers don’t touch it, assuming it’s “too intense.” Big mistake.
The spread is creamy, savory, and laced with capers, anchovies, and a splash of Vin Santo (a sweet dessert wine).
It’s one of those dishes that teaches you something about contrast—how salt and sweetness, bitterness and richness can all coexist beautifully.
In a way, it’s like life: balance the flavors, and everything makes sense.
7) Trippa alla fiorentina
Yes, another offal dish. Tuscany loves nose-to-tail cooking, and trippa alla fiorentina is another example of why.
Made with beef tripe, tomatoes, and herbs, it’s slow-cooked until tender and topped with a generous sprinkling of Parmesan.
Locals swear by it, but most tourists won’t go near it. Maybe it’s the texture, maybe it’s the idea of what it is—but that’s a shame.
Because once you get past the label, it’s deeply satisfying comfort food.
The first time I tried it, an old Florentine chef told me, “If you want to understand our city, start with our tripe.”
He wasn’t wrong. It’s humble, surprising, and full of character—just like Florence itself.
8) Castagnaccio
After all that savory food, you’ll want something sweet—but not too sweet. Castagnaccio is the perfect finish.
It’s a dense, rustic cake made from chestnut flour, olive oil, pine nuts, raisins, and rosemary.
No sugar, no butter, no eggs—just the ingredients Tuscan peasants had on hand centuries ago.
At first bite, it’s earthy and almost bitter, but then the sweetness of the raisins kicks in, and suddenly it all makes sense.
It’s the kind of dessert that forces you to slow down and pay attention.
I like that about it. In a world full of sugar bombs and fancy plating, castagnaccio reminds you that subtlety still has a place at the table.
9) Schiacciata all’uva
Lastly—and I mean that both literally and figuratively—there’s schiacciata all’uva, a sweet focaccia made during the grape harvest.
Bakers take ripe Sangiovese grapes, press them into olive oil–brushed dough, and bake it until the fruit bursts, releasing its juices into the bread.
It’s messy, fragrant, and unbelievably good when eaten warm.
It’s also a fleeting treat, usually available only in early autumn. Locals see it as a small celebration of the season—a way of saying thanks to the land before the wine is made.
Most travelers never even know it exists. But trust me, if you spot it in a bakery window, don’t hesitate.
It’s Tuscany at its most joyful: simple, seasonal, and unapologetically imperfect.
The bottom line
Tuscany has plenty of postcard-perfect dishes, and you should absolutely enjoy them.
But if you stop there, you’ll miss what makes the region truly special: its respect for ingredients, history, and humility.
Food, like life, isn’t just about chasing what looks good—it’s about curiosity.
Trying a dish you’ve never heard of (and might not even be able to pronounce) can open you up in the same way a good book or a bold decision can.
So next time you’re in Tuscany, skip the tourist menu. Ask your waiter what their grandmother cooks on Sundays.
You might discover that the best things in life—and in food—are the ones everyone else is too afraid to order.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
Dining and Cooking