If you like the taste of Mrs. Butterworth’s syrup, you’ll like this. But for me, I don’t like any artificial syrup taste. Anyone know of a more natural tasting maple ice cream?
by Entire_Pride1656
17 Comments
Providence451
I love Life is Good Vermont Maple Cream, but I also like this one so you might disagree.
Ok_Inflation_3746
Come to Vermont I gotchu
SnackForagers
Jeni’s pancake flavor
dezie1224
Straus Maple Cream / it’s divine!
RedLeggedApe
Too bad, sounds good.
SnooCrickets8742
It didn’t do a lot for me. I went back to their cookie butter ice cream.
tracyinge
That’s so strange.
It’s made with real maple syrup but somehow they manage to make it seem fake? I’ve heard the same complaint about their banana cream pie ice cream, it’s made with real bananas and people complain that because of all the sugar added, it tastes like taffy.
RPO1728
There’s too dam much salting these days lol
Cultural_Spend_5391
I didn’t like it either
Best-Scientist1995
It doesn’t even sound like it’d be good lol
onomatopoetess
I liked it! To each their own 🤷♀️
Alternative_Hand_110
I didn’t like it at all either. Just cloyingly sweet and fake tasting.
Ill_Chemical_5150
Good to know. I’ll stick with the Cookie Butter one.
keithnyc
Thank you. I normally go nuts for stuff like this, but this was just “ehhhhh”. Still waiting for their cheesecake, ckoc. peanut butter and horchata to reappear
Internal-Ad61
So glad I saw this because I planned on trying this lol. I’m a real maple syrup only kind of person.
17 Comments
I love Life is Good Vermont Maple Cream, but I also like this one so you might disagree.
Come to Vermont I gotchu
Jeni’s pancake flavor
Straus Maple Cream / it’s divine!
Too bad, sounds good.
It didn’t do a lot for me. I went back to their cookie butter ice cream.
That’s so strange.
It’s made with real maple syrup but somehow they manage to make it seem fake? I’ve heard the same complaint about their banana cream pie ice cream, it’s made with real bananas and people complain that because of all the sugar added, it tastes like taffy.
There’s too dam much salting these days lol
I didn’t like it either
It doesn’t even sound like it’d be good lol
I liked it! To each their own 🤷♀️
I didn’t like it at all either. Just cloyingly sweet and fake tasting.
Good to know. I’ll stick with the Cookie Butter one.
Thank you. I normally go nuts for stuff like this, but this was just “ehhhhh”. Still waiting for their cheesecake, ckoc. peanut butter and horchata to reappear
So glad I saw this because I planned on trying this lol. I’m a real maple syrup only kind of person.
Straus Maple ftw. Tastes like real fresh maple.
First mistake is trusting Joe w ice cream