I was reorganizing my pantry last week when I had a moment of recognition. Between the oat milk and nutritional yeast sat a jar of sun-dried tomatoes. Next to it: balsamic vinegar, truffle oil, and pesto.
My college self would have been baffled. These weren’t groceries. They were ingredients you encountered at fancy Italian restaurants where the waiter ground pepper tableside.
Here’s what’s strange about food culture: the things that signal sophistication shift constantly. What feels luxurious one decade becomes ordinary the next. The 90s gave us ingredients that screamed “I know about food”—and now they’re as common as ketchup.
These items marked a turning point when American grocery stores started carrying things you’d previously needed specialty shops to find. They were aspirational without being completely unattainable.
1. Balsamic vinegar
I remember the first time I saw balsamic vinegar on a restaurant menu in 1994. The description made it sound like liquid gold from Italian monks.
A bottle cost $15 to $30—real money for a condiment. People used it sparingly, drizzling a few precious drops over strawberries or grilled vegetables. The really good stuff, aged twelve years in wooden barrels, could run $150 for three ounces.
Now you can grab a bottle at any grocery store for under $10. I go through mine so fast I buy the big bottle. Most of us aren’t getting the monastery-aged version—the cheap stuff is basically red wine vinegar with caramel coloring—but it still tastes good enough for a Tuesday night salad.
2. Sun-dried tomatoes
These wrinkly red things were everywhere in the 90s. Pastas, salads, appetizer spreads—if a restaurant wanted to signal sophisticated Italian cooking, sun-dried tomatoes made an appearance.
At home, they felt extravagant. A small jar packed in oil cost more than fresh tomatoes. They tasted intensely of summer, concentrated and almost sweet, and you used them like jewels dotting your pasta.
Then they disappeared for a while, victims of their own ubiquity. But they’ve quietly returned, and now I keep a jar in my fridge without thinking twice. The shift from luxury to utility feels like growing up—these aren’t special anymore, they’re just a convenient way to add tomato flavor to winter cooking.
3. Goat cheese
In the mid-90s, goat cheese meant you were cultured. It appeared on appetizer plates alongside crackers and fig jam, always at dinner parties where someone owned actual wine glasses.
Before I went vegan, I tried it for the first time at a friend’s house and pretended to love the tangy, slightly funky flavor. Having goat cheese in your fridge sent a message: you’d moved beyond American slices.
Now it’s in every grocery store and often on sale. What used to cost $8 for a small log runs about $4. The shift happened gradually—first at Trader Joe’s, then everywhere else. It stopped being a statement and became another option in the dairy case.
4. Pesto
Before jarred pesto hit supermarkets in the early 90s, this vibrant green sauce was restaurant food. That basil and pine nut combination signaled someone knew about real Italian cooking.
Making it from scratch required a food processor—itself still relatively fancy—plus fresh basil, good olive oil, pine nuts, and nutritional yeast (or parmesan). Not cheap. The jarred version made it accessible, though purists complained.
I remember feeling very grown-up buying my first jar. Now I make it myself when basil’s cheap at the farmers market, and I keep a backup jar for lazy weeknights. The fancy versions still costs plenty, but basic pesto has become weeknight food rather than special-occasion sauce.
5. Truffle oil
Nothing screamed “fancy restaurant” quite like “finished with truffle oil” on a menu. That earthy, almost gasoline-like aroma signaled you were eating somewhere that took itself seriously.
Real truffles cost hundreds of dollars per pound. Truffle oil gave restaurants a way to add that distinctive flavor for less. Most of it was (and is) made with synthetic flavoring rather than actual truffles, but it tasted expensive.
Now truffle oil sits on grocery store shelves next to regular olive oil, usually around $15 for a small bottle. People drizzle it on popcorn. Once something becomes available at Costco, its luxury days are over. Though a little bit on mushroom risotto still makes me feel like I’m getting away with something.
6. Prosciutto
Thin-sliced Italian ham was the mark of a good deli counter in the 90s. They asked for it by name, carefully pronouncing “pro-SHOO-toe,” and watched while someone sliced it paper-thin.
It cost significantly more than regular deli meat—often $12 to $15 per pound when ham was $4. My mother would buy small amounts and used it sparingly, wrapping it around melon at dinner parties or laying it on fancy crackers.
The price hasn’t dropped much, but our willingness to buy it has increased. It’s in the refrigerated section now, pre-packaged and ready to grab. I see it on regular sandwiches at casual lunch spots. When something stops requiring a deli counter transaction, it’s crossed from specialty to standard.
7. Arborio rice
Before the 90s, rice in America meant long-grain white or maybe brown rice if you were health-conscious. Then risotto became a restaurant menu staple, and suddenly we all needed to know about arborio.
This short-grain Italian rice, essential for proper risotto, used to require a trip to a specialty store. It cost three or four times what regular rice cost. The technique—standing over the stove, stirring constantly, adding broth gradually—felt equally sophisticated.
Now arborio sits next to the jasmine and basmati at every grocery store. The price has come down enough that making risotto doesn’t feel like a special occasion. I make it on random Tuesdays, standing at the stove with wine, adding broth and stirring. My college self would have been impressed.
Final thoughts
What these ingredients share isn’t just a decade. They represent a moment when American food culture was opening up, when grocery stores began stocking things our parents never bought.
They were bridge foods—fancy enough to feel special, accessible enough to try at home. They made us feel sophisticated without requiring extensive culinary knowledge or deep pockets. The democratization of these ingredients changed how we cook.
We’re more adventurous now because these gateway foods taught us that trying something new wouldn’t break the bank. The foods that once signaled cultural capital have become pantry basics. Though I do occasionally miss the days when pulling out truffle oil at a dinner party would impress people. Now everyone just asks if it’s the real stuff or synthetic.
What’s Your Plant-Powered Archetype?
Ever wonder what your everyday habits say about your deeper purpose—and how they ripple out to impact the planet?
This 90-second quiz reveals the plant-powered role you’re here to play, and the tiny shift that makes it even more powerful.
12 fun questions. Instant results. Surprisingly accurate.
Dining and Cooking