Trimmed my first brisket – let me know how I did please!

by buckeyes555

29 Comments

  1. TheSmizzCommander

    First thoughts, sharpen your knife

  2. WesternConfusion8563

    I’d clean that fat side up a little more. Cut the discolored stuff off.

  3. DrInsomnia

    If you haven’t fried up some of the trimmings and given them to the supervisor then we don’t actually know how well you’ve done.

  4. Irish-sausage

    As someone who has never trimmed a brisket but loves to watch 1000 yt videos about trimming briskets, the edges look a bit sharp and not curved enough, in saying that if I attempted to cut a brisket I’d probably be left with a little square of meat from messing up each trim

  5. RoughCabinet6740

    The brisket looks good, and I already love your golden retriever. They make great grilling and smoking companions.

  6. Curt_Uncles

    Both the living animal and the dead animal in these photographs look very good

  7. Separate-Succotash11

    Did you ask your dog for it’s opinion?

    Looks good!

  8. mikeysce

    Your dog is so cute! <3

    Brisket could lose a little more fat. But you can always cut off the extra at dinner time if necessary.

  9. jdogg1413

    Your dog is like “just cook the darn thing already!”

  10. Sufficient-Poet-2582

    Well you squared it up. How about TRIMMING UP the fat cap and deckle?

  11. flyin-lowe

    It’s hard to tell from the angle of the pics but is there a high point that runs along the fat cap side. In the third pic it looks like it is on the left half, just left of center. If so I would trim that off to make it flat. If it’s an illusion you should be good.

  12. blueirish3

    I see judgment in the dogs face of you going to throw out that fat like that rookie

  13. Osejay12

    I’d trim a bit more up top. Get those edges cleaned up too.

    Keep your trimmings and place them on the grate above the brisket for maximum flavor.

  14. Several-Assistant-51

    All I know is the pup is hungry and wonders why he hasn’t been fed

  15. Big_Smooth_CO

    Dull knife but who cares give that dogs some pats

  16. Serious_Toe8613

    I’d leave 1/4 inch fat cap on there next time for moisture. Low n slow 225 – 250 and wrap it once you push through the 165 “stall” wrap it up. The only way to ruin a Brisket is to rush it.
    I did one about that size at 235 for 17 hours…it was fall apart tasty on a soft white bun. Good luck l!

  17. ghettospahgetti5150

    I did a no trim brisket once and it came out pretty good. You could remove more but I say roll with it. Bigger issue is I’d watch that dog if I was you. Those are brisket eyes…👀

  18. Adistrength

    Bunch of high and mighty shit talkers lol you did great man

  19. justw4tch1ng1th4pp3n

    1-thats a golden retriever, not a brisket you don’t get any more milk. Eat some. Eat some of your food
    2- on the actual trim, I would leave them fat the fat cap up when I smoke

  20. user101101100

    Not a brisket comment, but could you give that sweet little puppers a belly rub from me 🙂

  21. TheRemedyKitchen

    It’s a bit rough, but I’ve definitely seen worse attempts by more experienced people. Keep at it! And take care of your knives

  22. Bonerschnitzel69

    Looks pretty good regardless of the knife comments because I’ve been there too and good luck with the cook and let us know how it turns out