I bake those every year and they always turn out great. This year decided to add some food coloring to the dough to make them more fun.

This is the recipe I used: https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/146819/spooky-witches-fingers/

by Objective_Nevirka

23 Comments

  1. CalendarEastern6261

    It is scary. But looks interesting !!!

  2. henrytabby

    Yeah, they look great! And thanks for posting which recipe you used

  3. bluepushkin

    I hate it. And love it. That’s what I love about Halloween baking. You get a moment of ew, no thank you! Followed by, oh go on then! Deliciously creepy OP.

  4. Autumn_breezes

    LOL, these are the coolest Halloween cookies!!!!! VERY CREATIVE!!!

  5. cassielovesderby

    Omg are those almonds as the fingernails?

  6. Aggravating_Eye874

    They look amazing and off putting in the same time, well done, OP!

  7. valerierosati

    I love how realistic these look, the little knuckle lines and the β€œblood” at the nails are such a nice touch. The colors make them even better this year; they look straight out of a witch’s kitchen.

  8. night0sphere

    my friend took these to school senior year a decade ago and i’ll never forget how grossed out i was. they did taste great though LOL i was just thinking about them yesterday so it’s fun to see someone make them!

  9. Antique-Presence4962

    These are awesome! Food coloring definitely improved!

  10. Love! Did you bake with almonds on the cookie and then take the almond off and add jam then place the almond back on like the recipe says? This seems odd to me. Why not add the jam, then place almond over, then bake?

  11. Individual-Sort5026

    There’s an anime where you eat the fingers and become powerful. These would go so hard with that

  12. the_brees_knees_

    gross, give me 5 to eat 🀣 no but seriously good job!

  13. Muted-Low5536

    These look disturbingly tasty, which is perfect for Halloween.

  14. lilguyanonymous

    This one I couldn’t. Nice work.

  15. KingArthurBaking

    **Tired:** Ladyfingers

    **Wired:** Hagfingers

    Well done!